Step back in time with the Gurdon Gallup home, an enchanting 1830 Antique Cape that embodies the rich history and architectural beauty that Mystic is renowned for. Located within walking distance to the vibrant heart of Downtown Mystic, this residence offers easy access to an array of charming shops, delectable restaurants, lively bars, picturesque marinas, the iconic Drawbridge, and the convenient train station. Once the abode of Captain Washington, this storied home is a testament to Mystic's seafaring heritage and allure. The residence has gracefully evolved over the years, now presenting a spacious 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom layout that spans 2,475 square feet of living space. The first floor is adorned with three magnificent fireplaces, each contributing to the home's character and inviting ambiance. The modern kitchen, strategically positioned between the dining and living rooms, boasts contemporary amenities for effortless entertaining. The home's recent addition includes the versatile third bedroom, currently serving as a music and office space. A dedicated office, full bathroom and covered porch complete this section of the home. The upper level reveals two additional bedrooms, another full bathroom with a walk-in closet, laundry facilities, and a private balcony for serene moments.
Outside, the property delights with sun-soaked patios, a covered porch for relaxation, lush gardens, a classic stone wall, and the unique feature of an outdoor shower. The luxury of a garage in Mystic cannot be overstated, and this home offers an attached, tandem garage with space for two vehicles. Experience the historic charm and modern elegance that coalesce within the walls and grounds of this treasured Mystic residence, where the past and present merge to create exceptional living.
Single-familyProperty Type
1830Year Built
0.44 acresLot Size
$425Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 garage spacesParking
Listed by Heather Sawyer• William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Bought with Sandy Bliven• RE/MAX South County
Source:Smart MLS #24090061
Redfin Estimate
$935,433
$115K since sold in July 2025$29K since August
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 3.9% lower than the average sale price ($973K) of 6 comparable homes.
1830 Gurdon Gallup home allows you to savor the past while enjoying the quality, comfort and amenities of a total renovation and expansion in 2008. Located in the Historic District of Mystic and just a few steps to the drawbridge, restaurants and shopping, This distinctive Expanded Cape home lives large yet will surely keep you warm with three working Rumford Fireplaces. Home boasts a custom designed gourmet kitchen with soapstone counters, cherry cabinets, Sub Zero Refrigerator, Wolf Gas Range and a wet bar. Stunning wide board floors keep the old world charm alive and well. Updated Bathrooms feature marble inlayed & basket weave tile. Central AC and a Surround Sound System truly raise the bar and complete the picture for this timeless historic home.
Smart MLS #E242122
Dec 30, 2010
Listing Removed
—
Aug 21, 2010
Listed
$629,000
$286/sq ft
Smart MLS #E239704
Aug 17, 2010
Listing Removed
—
Jun 1, 2010
Listed
$629,000
$286/sq ft
Smart MLS #E228791
Nov 30, 2009
Listing Removed
—
Apr 27, 2009
Listed
$649,000
$295/sq ft
Smart MLS #E219948
Nov 30, 2008
Listing Removed
—
Jun 6, 2008
Listed
$730,000
$331/sq ft
Public Records
Apr 30, 2002
Sold
$262,000
$119/sq ft
Smart MLS #E124052
Feb 8, 2002
Listed
$289,900
$132/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 16, 1989
Sold
$180,000
$82/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2022
$9,844 (+9.8%)
$112,910 + $301,140
$414,050
2021
$8,966 (+0.8%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2020
$8,893 (+4.5%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2019
$8,508 (+1.2%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2018
$8,406 (+1.9%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2017
$8,250 (+25.7%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2016
$6,561 (+5.9%)
$107,100 + $165,830
$272,930
2014
$6,193 (−0.8%)
$107,100 + $165,830
$272,930
2011
$6,245
$107,100 + $165,830
$272,930
Tax history for 42 New London Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2022
$9,844 (+9.8%)
$112,910 + $301,140
$414,050
2021
$8,966 (+0.8%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2020
$8,893 (+4.5%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2019
$8,508 (+1.2%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2018
$8,406 (+1.9%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2017
$8,250 (+25.7%)
$90,370 + $227,920
$318,290
2016
$6,561 (+5.9%)
$107,100 + $165,830
$272,930
2014
$6,193 (−0.8%)
$107,100 + $165,830
$272,930
2011
$6,245
$107,100 + $165,830
$272,930
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.