Perfectly situated directly across from East Rock Park & walking distance to Yale, this exceptional home offers an unbeatable location. Rich in charm & character, this impressive residence features approx. 4,400 sq ft. of beautifully restored living space, providing room for everyone. A covered front porch with classic columns overlooks the park, setting the tone for the elegance found throughout. The property offers a large driveway with ample parking, an oversized 2-car garage, and a partially fenced, level yard ideal for outdoor entertaining. Step through the glass double front doors into a grand foyer where original woodwork, detailed moldings, and restored built-ins immediately captivate. The home's historic character has been thoughtfully preserved while seamlessly integrating modern updates. The 1st floor boasts an open-concept living & entertaining area with endless flexibility. At the heart of the space is a fireplace with built-in bench seating along the windows, flowing effortlessly into the formal dining room. The dining area connects to the fully remodeled kitchen & Butler's pantry, featuring new cabinetry, stainless appliances, quartz countertops & a central island. Just off the kitchen are a walk-in pantry & one of the home's laundry areas. 2 staircases provide access to the 2nd floor, allowing for privacy & versatility. The front staircase leads to the primary suite, complete with a bathroom featuring a walk-in shower, soaking tub & dual sinks.
French doors open to a private balcony overlooking New Haven, while an attached bonus room serves as an expansive dressing room/walk-in closet. This wing also includes 2 additional bedrooms that share a full bath. The rear wing of the 2nd floor-accessible via a separate staircase off the kitchen-is perfect for guests or extended family & includes 3 more bedrooms & a full bathroom. The 3rd floor offers more flexibility with 3 additional rooms, a full bathroom & a kitchenette, making it ideal for an in-law setup, home office, or creative space. Additional highlights include freshly painted interior and exterior, a brand-new furnace & a beautiful covered back porch-perfect for relaxing or entertaining. This extraordinary home blends historic elegance, modern comfort, and an unbeatable East Rock location.
Est. $4,745 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 74 Cold Spring St
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
Smart MLS #24148335
Jun 12, 2026
Sold
$1,400,000
$319/sq ft
Mar 19, 2026
Contingent
—
Mar 9, 2026
Listed
$1,299,999
$296/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$20,824 (−6.4%)
$246,540 + $313,250
$559,790
2022
$22,252 (+17.6%)
$246,540 + $313,250
$559,790
2021
$18,927
$185,500 + $245,840
$431,340
2020
$18,927 (+2.1%)
$185,500 + $245,840
$431,340
2019
$18,539
$185,500 + $245,840
$431,340
2018
$18,539 (+11.1%)
$185,500 + $245,840
$431,340
2017
$16,684 (−10.3%)
$185,500 + $245,840
$431,340
2016
$18,594
$208,740 + $238,770
$447,510
2014
$18,594 (+1.8%)
$208,740 + $238,770
$447,510
2011
$18,258
$208,740 + $238,770
$447,510
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
8
Baths
3
Stories
3
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
0.35 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
4,389
Year built
1900
Style
Single Family Residential
County
New Haven County
APN
1244985
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 12, 2023.
RS1
Special Single-Family District
These districts exist for the protection of certain fully developed single-family areas of relatively small total size but of unique and irreplaceable value to the community as a whole. The specific purpose of these districts is to stabilize and preserve the low-density residential character of these areas to the maximum possible extent. To this end the use of land and buildings within these areas is limited primarily to single-family homes. The particular character, size and surroundings of these areas create little need for the location within their boundaries of further such non-residential uses as generally support a low-density residential area, and the location of any further such uses within these areas would undesirably limit or diminish the number of homes in them. It is hereby found and declared that these regulations are necessary for the protection of these areas and that their protection is essential to the maintenance of a balanced community of sound residential areas of diverse types.
Permitted uses
Include but are not limited to:
Housing-Single unit
Infrastructure
Fire house
Police station
Post office
Park & open space
Property details
Parking
Garage Information
Garage & Parking: Detached Garage
Garages Number: 2
Interior
Interior Information
Total Rooms: 12
Laundry Room Location: main level off kitchen and the 2nd floor
Laundry Room Info: Main Level, Upper Level
Interior Features: Open Floor Plan
In-Law Apartment: Possible
Fireplaces Total: 1
Appliances Included: Electric Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Dishwasher