Perfectly Imperfect Updated Antique Gem on 3.3 bucolic acres surrounded by protected land, where many birds and other wildlife can be enjoyed. This historic home has so many charms, including exposed beams and original chestnut flooring. It has been lovingly updated and maintained without visibly changing its historic nature. One owner is a professional landscape architect and has filled the property with many native trees and plants and created a pastoral butterfly meadow where year after year monarchs have returned. Two vegetable gardens, as well as, a fruit orchard with apples, pears, peaches, and plums. Blueberries, raspberries, and concord grapes keep the owners fed from early Spring until late fall. A small bluestone patio under a wisteria and dutchmen's pipe-planted arbor between the house and a charming Summer House create great shade and outdoor seating. Three outbuildings sit on the property: a small barn/garage, a chicken coop (without chickens), and a Summer House with a new cedar roof and bluestone flooring; great to enjoy and entertain in during the summer months. The house itself currently consists of three bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms. The first floor contains a living room with original exposed timbers, an 18th century Rumford fireplace along with bread oven, wide-board oak flooring, an open cathedral ceiling and loft area. The spacious dining room comes with a corner cupboard. The updated cozy eat-in kitchen has a Bertazzoni dual fuel range,
Bosch dishwasher, and Beko refrigerator, and a small wood stove to keep things extra cozy during the cold winter months. There is also a library/tv room with a large walk-in closet, which can easily be used as a first-floor bedroom. A full bath with tub and a half bath completes the first floor. Upstairs there are three bedrooms: a main bedroom with a walk-in outfitted closet and two additional bedrooms, and an updated bathroom with shower stall. All of these features give the ease of modern convenience while keeping the cherished historic beauty. Updated Features: House roof replaced 2018 (barn and chicken coop roof as well), Summer house roof replaced 2025 Kitchen updated 2019 (fridge and range also replaced in 2019) Alarm system contains: thermostat controls, security, smoke, co2, flood and low temperature sensors, all remotely controlled via an app to adjust the temperature prior to arrival. Whole house Generac generator powered by a 1000-gallon propane tank. Central a/c: two zones added 2024. Other features: Forced hot air (oil) 1st floor. Electric baseboard heat (2nd floor) (each room with its own thermostat). Septic replaced in 2012, septic pump 2025. Unfinished basement containing gas washer/dryer and additional refrigerator/freezer plus a stand-alone freezer. Unfinished attic for storage. Electric upgrade to 200 amps. Hot water tank replaced 2019. Well pump replaced 2022. Water pressure tank 2025. Water filtration and treatment system.
Single-familyProperty Type
1800Year Built
3.3 acresLot Size
$400Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 garage spacesParking
Listed by Kathryn Clair• William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Listed by Kathryn Bassett• William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Bought with Oliver Brown• Houlihan Lawrence
Source:Smart MLS #24110281
Redfin Estimate
$839,294
$21K since sold in September 2025$23K since August
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 49.9% higher than the average sale price ($560K) of 6 comparable homes.
Wonderful classic antique home on over 3 acres of pasture in sought after Merryall section on New Milford. 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bath. One main level bedroom and two upstairs, cathedral ceiling in living room with Rumpford Fireplace and open loft, wide plank flooring throughout. Elegant grounds with mature plantings, small orchard and open field. Perfect weekend or full time home.
Smart MLS #98536381
Jul 24, 2012
Listing Removed
—
Apr 23, 2012
Listed
$390,000
$186/sq ft
Smart MLS #98503850
Nov 30, 2011
Listing Removed
—
Jun 6, 2011
Listed
$475,000
$227/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$9,591 (+2.2%)
$71,740 + $259,210
$330,950
2022
$9,382 (+1.4%)
$71,740 + $259,210
$330,950
2021
$9,257 (+7.9%)
$71,740 + $259,210
$330,950
2020
$8,576 (−0.1%)
$79,590 + $219,450
$299,040
2019
$8,588 (+1.9%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2018
$8,430 (+3.4%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2017
$8,155 (+1.8%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2016
$8,011 (+14.0%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2014
$7,025
$79,590 + $187,530
$267,120
Tax history for 32 Cherniske Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$9,591 (+2.2%)
$71,740 + $259,210
$330,950
2022
$9,382 (+1.4%)
$71,740 + $259,210
$330,950
2021
$9,257 (+7.9%)
$71,740 + $259,210
$330,950
2020
$8,576 (−0.1%)
$79,590 + $219,450
$299,040
2019
$8,588 (+1.9%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2018
$8,430 (+3.4%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2017
$8,155 (+1.8%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2016
$8,011 (+14.0%)
$79,590 + $219,660
$299,250
2014
$7,025
$79,590 + $187,530
$267,120
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.