Welcome to 34 Button Road, a stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial with a potential fourth bedroom, set on nearly 2 acres of beautifully manicured grounds in North Stonington. Built in 2004, this home blends the timeless charm of a historic residence with modern convenience. Inside, you'll find spacious and light-filled living areas featuring rich hardwood floors and striking coffered ceilings that set the tone for elegance throughout the main level. Expansive south-facing windows fill the home with natural sunlight all day long, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The well-appointed kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and living spaces, perfect for both entertaining and everyday living. The primary suite offers a private retreat with a generous walk-in closet and spa-like bath. A versatile bonus room above the two-car garage adds even more flexibility for a home office, guest space, or playroom. Outside, enjoy nearly two acres of landscaped gardens, mature plantings, and peaceful surroundings, all creating a sense of privacy while still being conveniently located just 20 minutes to downtown Mystic and 15 minutes from the Rhode Island line. This is a rare opportunity to own a home with classic character and modern comfort in one of North Stonington's most desirable settings.
Finished attic space and bonus room above garage not included in total square footage.
Single-familyProperty Type
2004Year Built
1.97 acresLot Size
$277Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 garage spacesParking
Listed by Kelsey Kelley• Slocum Realty
Bought with Samantha Storey• RE/MAX Coast and Country
Source:Smart MLS #24125627
Redfin Estimate
$682,036
$7,036 since sold in October 2025$10K since July
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 15.5% higher than the average sale price ($591K) of 6 comparable homes.
Save this one to your favorites, or you might be frustrated later when you come back and can't find it. North Stonington is known for it's private large lots and this house has just the right options to personalize it to your lifestyle. Granite and stainless appoint the kitchen which contrast beautifully with the hardwood mahogany floors. Throughout the home are built-in cabinets custom made on-site. Hydro heat, air conditioning and a wood burning fireplace make this home comfortable all year round. And it's easy to maintain too with central vacuum, 2 car barn and even a wood working shop over the barn garage. It's a home for modern living from the fenced garden and chicken coop to the wired iPad docks!
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$7,549 (+1.9%)
$52,850 + $207,550
$260,400
2022
$7,408 (−0.5%)
$52,850 + $207,550
$260,400
2021
$7,447 (+6.0%)
$52,850 + $207,550
$260,400
2020
$7,025 (+1.7%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2019
$6,906 (+2.8%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2018
$6,716 (+4.4%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2017
$6,430 (+1.9%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2016
$6,311 (+3.8%)
$54,250 + $179,480
$233,730
2014
$6,078 (+1.0%)
$57,610 + $177,520
$235,130
2011
$6,019
$57,610 + $177,520
$235,130
Tax history for 34 Button Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$7,549 (+1.9%)
$52,850 + $207,550
$260,400
2022
$7,408 (−0.5%)
$52,850 + $207,550
$260,400
2021
$7,447 (+6.0%)
$52,850 + $207,550
$260,400
2020
$7,025 (+1.7%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2019
$6,906 (+2.8%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2018
$6,716 (+4.4%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2017
$6,430 (+1.9%)
$54,250 + $183,890
$238,140
2016
$6,311 (+3.8%)
$54,250 + $179,480
$233,730
2014
$6,078 (+1.0%)
$57,610 + $177,520
$235,130
2011
$6,019
$57,610 + $177,520
$235,130
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.