16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Off market jan 2020 for $458K

$845,798

Est. refi paymentEst. refi $1,935/mo

•

2,513

sq ft

16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371

About this home

This unique California Style ranch with mid-century modern design enjoys elevated western facing views over the Old Lyme Country Club golf course. Updated in 2014 this iconic home features a custom kitchen with Carrera marble counters, center island, stainless appliances, reclaimed wide board floors and a wood burning fireplace. The large living room with fireplace and gleaming wood floors is ideal for entertaining while the adjacent den offers a cozier space to relax and chill. The master bedroom wing was re-imagined to include a stunning full bath, new hardwood floors, walk in closet and laundry. Two guestrooms share a new bath featuring Carrera marble surfaces and Grohe fixtures. Other improvements include a new water filtration system, new gutters, and a fresh exterior paint job in 2017. Rich in character and charm with a new modern twist this property is a winner! Owner/Agent related.

Single-familyProperty Type

1955Year Built

0.8 acresLot Size

$337Est. Price/Sq.Ft.

1 car garageParking

Listed by Judith Schaaf • Coldwell Banker Realty

Bought with Carol O'Hare • Coldwell Banker Realty

Source:Smart MLS #170242894

Redfin Estimate

$845,798

$388K since sold in January 2020$24K since October

Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale

This home's estimate is 35.7% higher than the average sale price ($623K) of 6 comparable homes.

SOLD OCT 23, 2026
$385,000
A
3 beds3 baths2,116 sq ft
4 NOTTINGHAM Dr, Old Lyme, CT 06371
SOLD OCT 31, 2026
$1,100,000
B
3 beds2 baths3,113 sq ft
60 Lyme St, Old Lyme, CT 06371
SOLD OCT 19, 2026
$650,000
C
3 beds2 baths2,114 sq ft
18 Shepard St, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
SOLD SEP 24, 2026
$675,000
D
3 beds2 baths1,788 sq ft
84 Ayers Point Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475
SOLD SEP 2, 2026
$365,000
E
3 beds2 baths1,056 sq ft
5 Blackwell Ln, Old Lyme, CT 06371
SOLD JUN 12, 2026
$565,000
F
3 beds2 baths1,767 sq ft
76-1 River St W, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.

Earn from this home

Sell

$478,164

Est. take-home

List your home with Redfin and save $8,458

Refinance

Est. cash available

Get cash now or lower your monthly rate

Rent

$3,405/mo

Redfin rental estimate

List your home for rent

Market trends in 06371, CT

Last updated October 2026

Buyer's Market

Seller's Market

Balanced market

Sale-to-list price

97.9%

0.6% MoM

Median sale price

$715K

$45K MoM

Avg. days on market

38d

18 days MoM

Recently sold homes

8 MoM

New listings for sale

OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM
$525,000
3 beds1.5 baths1,104 sq ft
6 Blackwell Ln, Old Lyme, CT 06371
NEW 18 HRS AGO
$500,000
3 beds2 baths1,512 sq ft
61 Salem Rd, Lyme, CT 06371
COMING SOON
$995,000
3 beds3.5 baths3,527 sq ft
103 & 96 Shore Dr, Lyme, CT 06371
VIDEO TOUR
$535,000
3 beds2 baths1,878 sq ft
55 Rogers Lake Trl, Old Lyme, CT 06371
$399,990
4 beds3 baths2,148 sq ft
60 Town Woods Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371
$2,195,000
4 beds2.5 baths3,198 sq ft
119 Bill Hill Rd, Lyme, CT 06371
See all

Provided by Redfin

Sale history for 16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

Date

Event

Price

Smart MLS #170242894

Jan 27, 2020

Pending

—

Jan 27, 2020

Sold

$458,200

$182/sq ft

Dec 3, 2019

Contingent

—

Oct 31, 2019

Relisted

—

Oct 21, 2019

Contingent

—

Oct 14, 2019

Listed

$498,000

$198/sq ft

Smart MLS #M9139487

Oct 30, 2013

Sold

$370,000

$147/sq ft

Mar 19, 2013

Listed

$389,000

$155/sq ft

Smart MLS #M9124579

Apr 19, 2011

Listing Removed

—

Sep 19, 2010

Listed

$445,000

$177/sq ft

Year

Property tax

Land + Additions

Assessment*

2023

$7,132

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2022

$7,132 (+0.8%)

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2021

$7,072 (+0.4%)

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2020

$7,041 (−1.3%)

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2019

$7,133 (+2.3%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2018

$6,974 (+0.7%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2017

$6,923 (+2.6%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2016

$6,748 (−9.2%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2014

$7,433 (+4.4%)

$180,500 + $197,600

$378,100

2011

$7,120

$180,500 + $188,400

$368,900

Tax history for 16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

Year

Property tax

Land + Additions

Assessment*

2023

$7,132

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2022

$7,132 (+0.8%)

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2021

$7,072 (+0.4%)

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2020

$7,041 (−1.3%)

$144,400 + $159,100

$303,500

2019

$7,133 (+2.3%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2018

$6,974 (+0.7%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2017

$6,923 (+2.6%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2016

$6,748 (−9.2%)

$144,400 + $173,900

$318,300

2014

$7,433 (+4.4%)

$180,500 + $197,600

$378,100

2011

$7,120

$180,500 + $188,400

$368,900

*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.

Public record

Beds

Baths

Stories

Lot width

—

Lot depth

—

Lot size

0.8 Acres

Year renovated

—

Sq. Ft.

2,513

Year built

1955

Style

Single Family Residential

County

New London County

APN

1553203

Parking Spaces

—

Basement

—

Accessible

—

HOA Dues

—

Garage

—

Features

—

Last updated by owner on Jul 14, 2023.

Property details

Parking

Garage Information
Garage & Parking: Under House Garage
Garages Number: 1

Interior

Interior Information
Total Rooms: 5
Laundry Room Info: Main Level
Interior Features: Cable - Available
Fireplaces Total: 2
Cooling System: Central Air
Appliances Included: Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Disposal, Washer, Dryer

Bathroom Information
# of Baths (Full): 2

Bedroom Information
Beds Total: 3

Room Information
Rooms Additional: Foyer, Laundry Room
Room Count: 8
Basement Description: Unfinished, Concrete Floor, Garage Access
Has Attic
Attic Description: Pull-Down Stairs

Exterior

Exterior Features
Roof Information: Wood Shingle
Exterior Siding: Wood
Exterior Features: Garden Area, Gutters, Patio, Shed

Lot Information
Lot Description: Golf Course View, Sloping Lot, Treed

Building Information
Foundation Type: Concrete
Construction Description: Frame
Color: grey

Property Information
Property Type: Single Family For Sale
Living Area SQFT Per Public Record: 2513
Driveway Type: Asphalt

Financial

Assessments Information
Assessed Value: $318,300

Utilities

Utility Information
Water Source: Private Well
Sewage System: Septic
Hot Water Description: Domestic
Heat Type: Hot Air, Zoned
Heat Fuel Type: Oil
Fuel Tank Location: In Garage

Location

School Information
Intermediate School: Per Board of Ed
High School: Lyme-Old Lyme
Elementary School: Per Board of Ed

Location Information
State: Connecticut
Nearby Amenities: Golf Course, Library, Playground/Tot Lot, Shopping/Mall, Tennis Courts
Directions: McCurdy Road to Johnnycake Hill. house on your left.
County: New London

Public facts

Beds: 3
Baths: 2.0
Sq. Ft.: 2,513
Stories: 1.0
Lot Size: 0.8 acres
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 1955
Year Renovated: —
County: New London County
APN: 1553203

Home facts updated by county records on Jul 13, 2023

Other

Documents & Disclosures
Supplement Count Public: 2

Around this home

Schools

K - 12
Preschool & daycare

Mile Creek School

Public K-5 • Assigned • 2.2mi

9/10

Lyme-Old Lyme Middle School

Public 6-8 • Assigned • 0.9mi

8/10

Lyme-Old Lyme High School

Public 9-12 • Assigned • 0.8mi

7/10

Provided by GreatSchools

Lifestyle

Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic

Climate risks

1/10 Flood Factor

Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years

1/10 Fire Factor

Unlikely to be in a wildfire in next 30 years

5/10 Heat Factor

7 days above 94° expected this year, 17 days in 30 years

8/10 Wind Factor

80% chance of strong winds in next 30 years

4/10 Air Factor

5 unhealthy days expected this year, 7 days in 30 years

Provided by First Street

Historical weather

Old Lyme, CT • 06371

Average low and high temperatures (°F)

35°

22°

37°

23°

50°

33°

59°

42°

67°

51°

78°

60°

82°

66°

79°

60°

75°

58°

63°

47°

54°

38°

40°

26°

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Sun exposure

In this area, properties receive around 9.1 hours in June and 4.6 hours in December, which is comparable to the U.S. average for solar exposure.

9.1 hrs

4.6 hrs

JuneDecember

Provided by Shadowmap

Estimated sale price

$804,000 – $973,000

Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Save up to $8,458 in fees. 3 minutes to get started.

Get a free, detailed breakdown of how we calculated your estimate.

Nearby similar homes

OPEN SAT, 11AM TO 3PMVIDEO TOUR

$1,175,000

4 beds2.5 baths3,484 sq ft

20 Twin Valley Rd, East Lyme, CT 06333

Luxury home • Chef's kitchen • Quartz countertops

OPEN SAT, 11AM TO 3PM3D & VIDEO TOUR

$1,442,995

4 beds2.5 baths2,831 sq ft

1 Twin Valley Rd, East Lyme, CT 06333

Pro kitchen • Electric fireplace • Walk-in closet

$695,000

2 beds2 baths1,176 sq ft

39 Dudley Ave, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

In town location • Beautiful gardens • Manicured grounds

$399,990

4 beds3 baths2,148 sq ft

60 Town Woods Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Finished lower level • Large yard • Secluded setting

$925,000

4 beds2.5 baths2,782 sq ft

16 Sands Dr, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Fully permitted dock • Open floor plan • Granite countertops

$1,100,000

3 beds2 baths2,904 sq ft

26 Willard Ave, Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Hardwood floors • Center island • Cozy gas fireplace

New listings for sale in 06371

OPEN SUN, 12PM TO 2PM

$525,000

3 beds1.5 baths1,104 sq ft

6 Blackwell Ln, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Cul-de-sac • Bonus sunroom • Private half bath

NEW 18 HRS AGO

$500,000

3 beds2 baths1,512 sq ft

61 Salem Rd, Lyme, CT 06371

Masonry fireplace • Built-in bookshelves • Walkout lower level

COMING SOON

$995,000

3 beds3.5 baths3,527 sq ft

103 & 96 Shore Dr, Lyme, CT 06371

Waterfront home • Water frontage • Fixed dock

VIDEO TOUR

$535,000

3 beds2 baths1,878 sq ft

55 Rogers Lake Trl, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Eat in kitchen • Pantry closets • 0.39 acre lot

$399,990

4 beds3 baths2,148 sq ft

60 Town Woods Rd, Old Lyme, CT 06371

Finished lower level • Large yard • Secluded setting

$2,195,000

4 beds2.5 baths3,198 sq ft

119 Bill Hill Rd, Lyme, CT 06371

14.46 acre lot • 5 garage spots • Built 1973

Home values near 16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

Data from public records.

Address	Redfin Estimate
25 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 2750 Sq. Ft.	—
10 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 2 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 1792 Sq. Ft.	$805,499
12 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 2 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 2293 Sq. Ft.	$1,125,273
4 Meetinghouse Ln, Old Lyme, CT 3 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 3845 Sq. Ft.	$1,339,602
3 McCurdy Ct, Old Lyme, CT 2 Beds \| 1 Baths \| 1316 Sq. Ft.	$488,698
25 McCurdy Rd, Old Lyme, CT 3 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 3338 Sq. Ft.	$947,163
27 McCurdy Rd, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 3391 Sq. Ft.	$1,809,870

Address	Redfin Estimate
3 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 4 Baths \| 3702 Sq. Ft.	$1,820,556
6 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 3 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 6492 Sq. Ft.	$2,541,132
4 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 5 Beds \| 4.5 Baths \| 3952 Sq. Ft.	$1,517,227
3 Meetinghouse Ln Apartment A, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3 Baths \| 3946 Sq. Ft.	$1,136,872
4 McCurdy Ct, Old Lyme, CT 3 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2106 Sq. Ft.	$689,823
29 McCurdy Rd, Old Lyme, CT 2 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2072 Sq. Ft.	$1,040,240
1 Meetinghouse Ln, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 2 Baths \| 2438 Sq. Ft.	$1,191,396

Address	Redfin Estimate
8 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3 Baths \| 3044 Sq. Ft.	$1,058,362
14 Johnny Cake Hill Rd, Old Lyme, CT 2 Beds \| 3 Baths \| 3266 Sq. Ft.	$1,097,739
6 Meetinghouse Ln, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 3894 Sq. Ft.	$1,169,571
5 Meetinghouse Ln, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 4.5 Baths \| 3850 Sq. Ft.	$1,401,986
23 McCurdy Rd, Old Lyme, CT 3 Beds \| 2.5 Baths \| 1966 Sq. Ft.	$760,481
27 McCurdy Rd Apartment A, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 3391 Sq. Ft.	$1,364,256
7 Meetinghouse Ln, Old Lyme, CT 4 Beds \| 3.5 Baths \| 2440 Sq. Ft.	$1,150,834

Property information provided by Smart MLS when last listed in 2019. This data may not match . Learn more.

Download the Redfin App on the Apple App Store

Download the Redfin App from the Google Play Store

Join us

Become an Agent

Get referrals

Careers

Find homes faster

About us

Find us

Subsidiaries

Affiliated Business

Countries

United States

Canada

Updated September 2025: By searching, you agree to the Terms of Use, and Privacy Policy.

Do not sell or share my personal information.

REDFIN and all REDFIN variants, WALK SCORE, and the R logos, are trademarks of Redfin Corporation, registered or pending in the USPTO.

Redfin Brokerage Licenses

California DRE #01521930

Redfin is licensed to do business in New York as Redfin Real Estate. NY Standard Operating Procedures

New Mexico Real Estate Licenses

TREC: Info About Brokerage Services, Consumer Protection Notice

All mortgage lending products and information are provided by Rocket Mortgage, LLC | NMLS #3030; www.NMLSConsumerAccess.org. Licensed in 50 states. This site is not authorized by the New York State Department of Financial Services for mortgage solicitation or loan applications activities related to properties located in the State of New York.

Redfin Corporation is an affiliated business of Rocket Limited Partnership. Each company, and their subsidiaries, are separate legal entities operated and managed through its own management and governance structures.

If you are using a screen reader, or having trouble reading this website, please call Redfin Customer Support for help at 1-844-759-7732.

REDFIN IS COMMITTED TO AND ABIDES BY THE FAIR HOUSING ACT AND EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT. READ REDFIN'S FAIR HOUSING POLICY AND THE NEW YORK STATE FAIR HOUSING NOTICE.

GreatSchools Ratings provided by GreatSchools.org.

Houses for rent in New London County	Agents near me	Westport, CT homes for sale	New London County Housing Market
Houses for sale near me	Greenwich, CT homes for sale	New Haven, CT homes for sale
Land for sale near me	Stamford, CT homes for sale	Milford, CT homes for sale
Open Houses near me	West Hartford, CT homes for sale	New London County Property Records
Condos for sale near me	Norwalk, CT homes for sale	CT New Listings

Suffolk County homes for sale
New Haven County homes for sale
Norfolk County homes for sale

Westerly homes for sale
Mystic homes for sale
Groton homes for sale

About this home

Redfin Estimate

Earn from this home

Market trends in 06371, CT

Sale history for 16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

Tax history for 16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

Public record

Property details

Around this home

Schools

Lifestyle

Climate risks

Historical weather

Sun exposure

Nearby similar homes

New listings for sale in 06371

Home values near 16 Johnny Cake Hill Rd

More real estate resources