Spectacular country estate with most picturesque park-like setting including expansive level yard, flowering gardens, & fully fenced, heated, salt water, in-ground pool with vast bluestone patio, plus separate pool house with full bath. Set back privately on sought after Farmingville cul-de-sac, yet just moments to town for shopping, restaurants, library, & theaters. True pride of ownership in this exceptional home with extensive recent improvements inside & out (see list in additional remarks). This true lifestyle home offers abundant natural light & walls of windows overlooking the resort-like pool entertaining area. The heart of this special home is the 35x12 sun room with timbered vaulted ceiling & skylights, which offers flexible living space for an office, sitting room, or media room. Step up from the sun room to the light-filled breakfast room with skylights & stunning white kitchen with contrasting black granite counters. The main floor also features the inviting family room with gas fireplace & wall of custom built-ins; formal LR with 2nd fireplace & French doors to the sun room; formal DR with bay window; & newly remodeled luxe powder room. Total 3,035 sf with 3 BRS & 3/1 baths including the pool house. The impressive primary suite features a large spa-like bath with marble floors, jetted tub, & separate shower. So much more - walk-up attic; finished lower level rec room with office alcove; multiple garden sheds; generator; irrigation; & just 69 miles to Midtown!
Recent updates: 2020 (previous owner) - New septic systems, New roof * Fall 2021 - Interior freshly painted, Oak wood floors sanded and stained, New LVP flooring in family room and basement, New Hot Water Heater, New whole house generator wired and installed, Updated propane tank for generator/family room fireplace, Updated primary bath floor heating * Spring 2022 - Repaved driveway and Belgian blocks reset, Two new AC units for dual zone, New pool liner, New pool equipment including piping, filter, pump and heater, New propane tank added for heating, Pool chlorination system converted to salt, Freshly painted pool house interior * Fall 2022 - Bluestone paving around pool (reset Belgian blocks) and walkways, Additional bluestone side patio and fire pit added, Expanded bluestone front porch patio, Updated landscaping, WiFi sprinkler system installed, Updated laundry room * Spring 2024 - LVP flooring in sunroom, Additional bathroom window added to pool house for ventilation, Updated jewel box powder room * Spring 2025 - Updated landscape lighting, Exterior house and pool house painted, Chimneys repointed
Single-familyProperty Type
1967Year Built
1.34 acresLot Size
$402Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Laura Ancona• William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Est. $4,793 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 46 Tally Ho Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
Smart MLS #24162412
May 28, 2026
Sold
$1,219,000
$402/sq ft
Apr 30, 2026
Pending
—
Mar 27, 2026
Listed
$1,279,000
$421/sq ft
Smart MLS #24103875
Dec 5, 2025
Listing Removed
—
Sep 23, 2025
Relisted
—
Sep 5, 2025
Contingent
—
Aug 19, 2025
Relisted
—
Jul 15, 2025
Listing Removed
—
Jun 22, 2025
Listed
$1,279,000
$421/sq ft
Jun 14, 2025
Coming Soon
*
Smart MLS #170386317
Aug 6, 2021
Sold
$790,000
$260/sq ft
Jun 30, 2021
Contingent
—
Apr 6, 2021
Listed
$849,900
$280/sq ft
Apr 3, 2021
Coming Soon
$849,900
$280/sq ft
Location... location... location. Beautiful Colonial style residence on a picture perfect lot boasting an in-ground pool with cabana and pond frontage. Pride of ownership is evident throughout with numerous upgrades over the years. Brand new roof and septic system. Custom kitchen with granite counters and high end finishes open to a cathedral family room with fireplace; 34 Foot Heated Sun Room with Anderson windows and built in hot tub to relax in and enjoy; this sun-drenched home includes an automatic back-up generator. This is a must see.