Tucked on a quiet Yalesville street just minutes from Wallingford town center, the Hartford Line train station, the Farmington Canal Heritage Trail, and several golf clubs, this thoughtfully kept 3-bedroom, 2-bath split-level is move-in ready and full of charm! Inside, gleaming hardwood floors and 9-foot ceilings set an open, welcoming tone. The oversized kitchen anchors the main level with leather granite counters, a center island, and sliders that open to a bright, enclosed, and insulated sunroom. Three bedrooms and a full bath round out the main level. The lower level brings together a spacious family room with a fully remodeled en-suite bath and laundry/utilities. A full walk-out door also provides easy access directly from the yard. The covered carport links the sunroom to the 14x30 ft. workshop - virtually no weather between you and your tools! Wired with 200-amp service, heavy-duty flooring, and an electric heater, it is a true year-round workspace. The newest and most meaningful upgrade - a fully waterproofed basement with a new sump pump - was completed in 2025. Earlier replacements (2018-2019) include: roof, windows, deep well pump and expansion tank, 50-gallon water heater, 100-amp electrical service with sub-panel, and kitchen appliances. Reliable oil hot-water heat and ceiling fans throughout keep the home comfortable year-round. Public sewer, private well, and a 0.54-acre lot complete the offering!
Est. $2,640 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 91 Nicholas Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
Smart MLS #24184474
Aug 20, 2026
Sold
$461,000
$317/sq ft
Jun 29, 2026
Pending
—
Jun 26, 2026
Listed
$409,900
$282/sq ft
Jun 19, 2026
Coming Soon
$409,900
$282/sq ft
Smart MLS #170475559
May 5, 2022
Sold
$320,000
$220/sq ft
Mar 28, 2022
Contingent
—
Mar 25, 2022
Listed
$329,900
$227/sq ft
Located just ten minutes from Wallingford town center, a quick drive to Wallingford Country Club or Tradition Golf Club. This very well-maintained home is brimming with natural light, hardwood floors, tons of new upgrades, a kitchen that flows into the sunroom with quick access to the backyard and workshop, a family room turned into a master bedroom with an updated bathroom as an ensuite. Upgrades completed in 2019 include new roof, new deep well pump and expansion tank, newly updated vinyl flooring on lower level, new windows, lower-level bathroom addition adding 103 sq ft and tub, new sump pump replaced in 2018, new 50-gallon water tank, new leather granite kitchen countertops, new refrigerator and dishwasher, generator, 100-amp service with 60-amp sub panel. Sunroom enclosed and insulated. Workshop addition completed with 200-amp service, heavy duty flooring, 4 electrical heaters on 4 GFCIs and 4 breakers. Excavated backyard ready to make your own. Cozy up and watch the sunrise or sunset from the sunroom or enjoy a family and friends fun filled evening outdoors around the fire pit. Relax, entertain, and begin your next adventure!
Public Records
Nov 26, 2018
Sold
$200,000
$138/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$4,788 (+1.0%)
$82,300 + $80,900
$163,200
2022
$4,739 (+2.3%)
$82,300 + $80,900
$163,200
2021
$4,632 (−0.4%)
$82,300 + $80,100
$162,400
2020
$4,650
$92,300 + $67,000
$159,300
2019
$4,650 (+1.9%)
$92,300 + $67,000
$159,300
2018
$4,562 (+0.3%)
$92,300 + $67,000
$159,300
2017
$4,548 (+2.4%)
$92,300 + $67,000
$159,300
2016
$4,443 (+2.4%)
$92,300 + $67,000
$159,300
2014
$4,340 (+2.6%)
$92,300 + $69,100
$161,400
2011
$4,232
$92,300 + $69,100
$161,400
Public record
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
1
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
0.54 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
1,056
Year built
1961
Style
Single Family Residential
County
New Haven County
APN
2052376
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 12, 2023.
Property details
Parking
Garage Information
Garage & Parking: Carport, Driveway
Garages Number: 2
Parking Information
Parking Total Spaces: 4
Interior
Interior Information
Total Rooms: 7
Laundry Room Info: Lower Level
Fireplaces Total: 1
Cooling System: Ceiling Fans
Appliances Included: Electric Cooktop, Microwave, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Washer, Dryer