Nestled in a breathtaking landscape, exquisitely restored & expanded, this one-of-a-kind home exudes understated elegance; a living piece of history re-imagined for today's lifestyles. Boasting 5+ acres of meticulously maintained gardens, lawns & flowering trees, a casual stateliness greets you as you enter the stone drive to this magical setting. Step inside the interior to discover spacious rooms flooded w/natural light flowing seamlessly from one to the next, all thoughtfully designed while maintaining the home's original aesthetic. The open floorplan provides flexibility for daily living along w/ tremendous conveniences: the full service laundry, a mudroom, a walk-in pantry & storage closets ensuring easy living. Refined craftmanship is carried throughout the millwork, cabinetry, flooring & decor. Upstairs 6 bedrooms w/4 updated baths complete the 2nd level. Outside 2 antique barns stand proudly offering endless storage, workshops, or creative spaces. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the 3 car detached garage complete w/lifts for 2 add' vehicles. A completely renovated guest house allows visitors private accommodations or an ideal in-law/nanny option. Whether it's recreation on the open lawns, relaxing by the pool or enjoying meals al fresco, this property is a peaceful retreat. Its unique combination of gorgeous land, historic buildings & lush gardens creates a tranquil, enchanting setting, perfect for those seeking a home w/soul, character & endless potential
Single-familyProperty Type
1772Year Built
5.53 acresLot Size
$567Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
3 garage spacesParking
Listed by Mary Beth Stow• Houlihan Lawrence
Bought with Holly Giordano• William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Source:Smart MLS #24038630
Redfin Estimate
$3,007,553
$318K since sold in December 2024$81K since August
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 64.6% higher than the average sale price ($1.83M) of 5 comparable homes.
The “Nathan Tuttle House” is picturesquely sited on 5.53 bucolic, level acres in a highly desirable neighborhood. This landmark home has been beautifully expanded & updated for today’s lifestyle & offers 5/6 bdrms, 4.5 bths, 8 fpls, wide plank chestnut, pine & hardwood floors, MBR suite w/fpl & extraordinary views. FR features 8 Fr. doors which open to an expansive terrace overlooking the pool & beautifully landscaped property with specimen plantings, lovely gardens, rolling lawns, natural fields & original rock walls. Outbuildings inc. a 864 SF barn suitable for horses, shed, 187 SF office & 584 SF 1 bdrm cottage. A must see historic Wilton gem, perfect for family living and memorable entertaining. See Addendum1 COM D&P@TP
Nathan Tuttle House c1772 Antique Colonial Tastefully Updated for Today's Lifestyle Gated entry to expansive 5.53 acre property with approx. 700' frontage on Millstone Rd. Open porch entry to large Foyer offering front to back views of property Family Room -fireplace with carved marble mantle & Dining Area features 7 French Doors opening to Stone Terrace overlooking gardens, inground pool, expansive lawn and property Living Room with carved mantle fireplace and wide plank pine wood floors Dining Room with original stone hearth fireplace, wide board chestnut floors & bay window Original Library with rich paneling, wide plank pine floors, bookcases and gas log fireplace Kitchen features custom cabinetry, large center island, marble countertops, walk-in pantry as well as the original butler's pantry with glass front cabinets Powder Room Laundry/Mud Room with built-ins and black slate floor Sunroom with fireplace, game table area opening to stone terrace overlooking sweeping lawns and beautiful gardens Two staircases access the Master Bedroom with fireplace, wall of closets, sitting room offering spectacular vistas of barns, gardens and property Master Bath with double head shower and dressing area w/walk-in closet & built-ins Two Bedrooms or Bedroom + Studio share the Hall Bath with shower Bedroom with fireplace and hardwood floor Bedroom with fireplace and hardwood floor Bedroom with hardwood floor 3 bedrooms share 2 Full Baths Walk up Floored Attic offers abundant storage space Partial Basement with interior access, 3 new oil tanks 2006 Two car detached Garage with storage Loft - attached heated & cooled Office 187 SF Cottage with living room, fireplace, bedroom, full bath & small galley kitchen 584 SF Barn with 2 stalls, tack room suitable for horses 864SF Shed Barn for storage 216 SF Wood Shingle Roof on main house, garage, cottage, barns, replaced in 2011 In ground concrete pool w/new pool tile, bluestone coping, decks in 2011 Security System, Whole House generator New Septic System for home installed in 2011by William Dexter Eight fireplaces Entire Exterior of House Painted in 2011 5.53 Acres of beautifully maintained property with rock walls, broad lawns, tall shade and pine trees, open fields and perennial gardens. Own a piece of history!
Public Records
Apr 16, 1985
Sold
$695,000
$131/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$34,894 (+28.5%)
$409,680 + $782,880
$1,192,560
2022
$27,153 (+1.3%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2021
$26,806 (+1.5%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2020
$26,412 (−3.8%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2019
$27,451 (−32.3%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2018
$40,532 (−1.3%)
$618,680 + $819,140
$1,437,820
2017
$41,049 (+1.6%)
$658,840 + $819,350
$1,478,190
2016
$40,414 (+3.1%)
$658,840 + $819,350
$1,478,190
2014
$39,187
$658,840 + $819,350
$1,478,190
Tax history for 239 Millstone Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$34,894 (+28.5%)
$409,680 + $782,880
$1,192,560
2022
$27,153 (+1.3%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2021
$26,806 (+1.5%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2020
$26,412 (−3.8%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2019
$27,451 (−32.3%)
$409,680 + $552,160
$961,840
2018
$40,532 (−1.3%)
$618,680 + $819,140
$1,437,820
2017
$41,049 (+1.6%)
$658,840 + $819,350
$1,478,190
2016
$40,414 (+3.1%)
$658,840 + $819,350
$1,478,190
2014
$39,187
$658,840 + $819,350
$1,478,190
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.