Search no more. This beautiful, historic home, built in 1840, known as the Dr. Andrew Castle House or as the Castle-Russell House, is sure to please the antique home lover in you! Listed in the National Register of Historic Places, this lovingly cared-for home is a wonderful example of original architecture combined with tastefully updated modern amenities. Sitting on 1.53 acres on a rise overlooking the road, adorned with lovely stone walls and gardens, this thirteen-room home, with five bedrooms and three full bathrooms, has plenty of space indoors and out for your living needs. The versatile floorplan allows for main floor bedrooms, if desired, along with plenty of space for one or more home offices. Some of the many other features of the main floor include a recently remodeled bathroom, updated modern kitchen with a six-burner stove and wide plank floors, main floor laundry, and so much more. Upstairs are five bedrooms including the master bedroom that includes a full ensuite, along with another full bathroom and plenty of attic storage space. In the basement you'll find an additional (approx) 475 square feet of recently renovated space with full-size windows and a private exterior walkout entrance. Conveniently located just minutes from shopping and route 15, it's a short drive to downtown New Haven, Yale University, and the New Haven train station, making it an ideal location for commuters, or maybe even that bed and breakfast you've always dreamed about opening.
Some of the many recent mechanical updates include a new furnace with a new hot water holding tank, a new mini-split system for the finished basement area, and one new air conditioner condenser. There is the ability to add a bathroom to the finished basement area if a new owner desired one, making it an even more versatile space. Please note that being listed in the National Register of Historic Places does not place restrictions on what can be done to the home. From www.nps.gov/subjects/nationalregister/faqs.htm "Under Federal Law, the listing of a property in the National Register places no restrictions on what a non-federal owner may do with their property up to and including destruction, unless the property is involved in a project that receives Federal assistance, usually funding or licensing/permitting." Schedule an appointment today to see this wonderful home. You'll be glad you did.
Single-familyProperty Type
1840Year Built
1.53 acresLot Size
$175Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by John Farkash• Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
Bought with Michelle Wininger• William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l
Source:Smart MLS #170408780
Redfin Estimate
$763,921
$226K since sold in October 2021$13K since August
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 18.5% lower than the average sale price ($937K) of 6 comparable homes.
Immaculate 1840 National Historical Society Colonial. Features include 13 rooms, 5 br, 2.5 bath, 5 fireplaces with plenty of room to spread out. The original craftsmanship of this home is not to be missed, with wide plank wood floors, period appropriate wall coverings and just enough modern touches makes this home attractive to all types.
Public Records
Feb 3, 2004
Sold
$525,000
$121/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$12,881 (+3.0%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2022
$12,507 (+2.7%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2021
$12,184 (+2.7%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2020
$11,867 (−3.6%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2019
$12,312 (+1.0%)
$104,510 + $201,530
$306,040
2018
$12,190 (−9.0%)
$104,510 + $201,530
$306,040
2017
$13,401 (+2.3%)
$104,510 + $235,270
$339,780
2016
$13,095 (+8.1%)
$104,510 + $235,270
$339,780
2014
$12,110 (+2.4%)
$115,920 + $230,370
$346,290
2011
$11,822
$115,920 + $230,370
$346,290
Tax history for 555 Amity Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$12,881 (+3.0%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2022
$12,507 (+2.7%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2021
$12,184 (+2.7%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2020
$11,867 (−3.6%)
$98,560 + $187,180
$285,740
2019
$12,312 (+1.0%)
$104,510 + $201,530
$306,040
2018
$12,190 (−9.0%)
$104,510 + $201,530
$306,040
2017
$13,401 (+2.3%)
$104,510 + $235,270
$339,780
2016
$13,095 (+8.1%)
$104,510 + $235,270
$339,780
2014
$12,110 (+2.4%)
$115,920 + $230,370
$346,290
2011
$11,822
$115,920 + $230,370
$346,290
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.