Great Opportunity for Savvy Investor! Distinguished Brick Estate on 3.87 Acres in need of TLC. Discover this hidden gem just outside Cumming city limits. Located conveniently near GA 400 Exit 16 and Lake Lanier, this property offers unparalleled privacy and convenience. As you drive down the tree-lined entrance, you'll be greeted by an elegant 2-story brick home featuring a grand foyer with a curved staircase and luxurious marble flooring. The main level boasts a master bedroom and sitting room, complemented by a spacious living room, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen, and a cozy keeping room. Upstairs, find three large bedrooms each with it's own full bath, perfect for accommodating family and guests. The finished terrace level features a family room with a fireplace, and space for a 2nd kitchen for entertaining and recreation area that opens out to the inviting pool and patio. Ample storage is available in the large unfinished basement, providing plenty of room for your belongings. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the four-car oversized garage attached to the main house, while the separate Carriage House offers three additional garage bays for all your toys! Plus a full garage apartment, ideal for extended family, visitors or generating rental income. For recreation, enjoy your own private tennis (pickleball) court, ensuring endless hours of outdoor enjoyment right at home. The total bedroom count and square footage includes the 2 bedrooms and 2 and a half baths in the Carriage House.
Single-familyProperty Type
1994Year Built
3.87 acresLot Size
$164Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
7 car garageParking
Listed by Elaine Thomas• Keller Williams Realty Community Partners
Listed by Caroline Chester• Keller Williams Realty Community Partners
Bought with Elaine Thomas• Keller Williams Realty Community Partners
Bought with Caroline Chester• Keller Williams Realty Community Partners
Source:FMLS #7422490
Redfin Estimate
$1,104,469
$154K since sold in December 2024$1,000 since July
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 94.1% higher than the average sale price ($569K) of 6 comparable homes.
Great Opportunity for Savvy Investor! Distinguished Brick Estate on 3.87 Acres in need of TLC. Discover this hidden gem just outside Cumming city limits. Located conveniently near GA 400 Exit 16 and Lake Lanier, this property offers unparalleled privacy and convenience. As you drive down the tree-lined entrance, you'll be greeted by an elegant 2-story brick home featuring a grand foyer with a curved staircase and luxurious marble flooring. The main level boasts a master bedroom and sitting room, complemented by a spacious living room, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen, and a cozy keeping room. Upstairs, find three large bedrooms each with it's own full bath, perfect for accommodating family and guests. The finished terrace level features a family room with a fireplace, and space for a 2nd kitchen for entertaining and recreation area that opens out to the inviting pool and patio. Ample storage is available in the large unfinished basement, providing plenty of room for your belongings. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the four-car oversized garage attached to the main house, while the separate Carriage House offers three additional garage bays for all your toys! Plus a full 2 Bedroom garage apartment, ideal for extended family, visitors or generating rental income. For recreation, enjoy your own private tennis (pickleball) court, ensuring endless hours of outdoor enjoyment right at home. The total bedroom count and square footage includes the 2 bedrooms and 2 and a half baths in the Carriage House.
Public Records
Feb 16, 2011
Sold
$633,000
$94/sq ft
Public Records
Dec 29, 1997
Sold
$865,000
$128/sq ft
Public Records
Jun 5, 1992
Sold
$55,000
$8/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 1, 1991
Sold
$33,000
$5/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$3,417 (+84.7%)
$154,800 + $320,032
$474,832
2024
$1,850 (+4.3%)
$154,800 + $320,032
$474,832
2023
$1,774 (−2.9%)
$127,712 + $286,752
$414,464
2022
$1,827 (+2.7%)
$98,684 + $238,140
$336,824
2021
$1,778 (+0.8%)
$81,272 + $203,036
$284,308
2020
$1,764 (−0.6%)
$73,532 + $195,296
$268,828
2019
$1,776 (−0.4%)
$77,400 + $192,152
$269,552
2018
$1,783 (−3.2%)
$77,400 + $183,620
$261,020
2017
$1,842 (−74.6%)
$77,400 + $207,156
$284,556
2016
$7,254 (+22.3%)
$69,660 + $207,156
$276,816
2014
$5,931 (+0.3%)
$38,700 + $189,328
$228,028
2013
$5,912 (−0.9%)
$38,700 + $187,760
$226,460
2012
$5,967 (+0.9%)
$38,700 + $189,968
$228,668
2011
$5,912 (−2.5%)
$34,832 + $190,524
$225,356
2010
$6,063 (−13.7%)
$61,920 + $247,012
$308,932
2009
$7,027
$61,920 + $247,012
$308,932
2008
$7,027
$61,920 + $247,012
$308,932
Tax history for 1955 Pilgrim Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$3,417 (+84.7%)
$154,800 + $320,032
$474,832
2024
$1,850 (+4.3%)
$154,800 + $320,032
$474,832
2023
$1,774 (−2.9%)
$127,712 + $286,752
$414,464
2022
$1,827 (+2.7%)
$98,684 + $238,140
$336,824
2021
$1,778 (+0.8%)
$81,272 + $203,036
$284,308
2020
$1,764 (−0.6%)
$73,532 + $195,296
$268,828
2019
$1,776 (−0.4%)
$77,400 + $192,152
$269,552
2018
$1,783 (−3.2%)
$77,400 + $183,620
$261,020
2017
$1,842 (−74.6%)
$77,400 + $207,156
$284,556
2016
$7,254 (+22.3%)
$69,660 + $207,156
$276,816
2014
$5,931 (+0.3%)
$38,700 + $189,328
$228,028
2013
$5,912 (−0.9%)
$38,700 + $187,760
$226,460
2012
$5,967 (+0.9%)
$38,700 + $189,968
$228,668
2011
$5,912 (−2.5%)
$34,832 + $190,524
$225,356
2010
$6,063 (−13.7%)
$61,920 + $247,012
$308,932
2009
$7,027
$61,920 + $247,012
$308,932
2008
$7,027
$61,920 + $247,012
$308,932
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.