Montezuma, IN homes for sale & real estate

Montezuma, IN Homes for Sale

Discover this beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bath home sitting on 23 acres in Rosedale, IN — just north of Lyford! Built in 2015, this 1,800 sq. ft. home blends modern amenities of city water and high-speed internet with peaceful rural living, offering everything from productive land to move-in-ready updates. Home Features: Spacious open floor plan with new flooring (2025) throughout New roof (2023) for worry-free living City water for convenience and reliability Expansive 3-car garage with plenty of room for vehicles, toys, or a workshop New privacy fence (2025) creating a secure, private backyard oasis Outbuildings & Outdoor Amenities: Heated and Insulated “man cave / she

Montezuma, IN Homes for Sale

This charming three-bedroom, one-bath home is a great opportunity for those looking to roll up their sleeves and create something truly special. A classic fixer-upper, it’s packed with potential and waiting for the right owner to bring it back to life. Original hardwood floors offer timeless character. Outside, you’ll find a one-car garage with an attached workshop—perfect for tinkering, storage, or weekend projects. Whether you're restoring a vintage car or building the next great birdhouse, there’s room to make it happen. The layout includes a spacious living area and a cozy kitchen, ready for your modern updates. With three bedrooms, including a generously sized p

Montezuma, IN Homes for Sale

Escape the hustle and embrace the serenity of rural living in this spacious 3-bedroom, 2-bath sanctuary. Nestled beside a gentle creek, this inviting home offers the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern convenience. Step inside to discover a generous living room anchored by a cozy fireplace and framed by picturesque views. The large dine-in kitchen is ideal for family meals and entertaining, with ample space and natural light. Thoughtfully designed with split bedrooms for added privacy, this home also features a fully finished walkout basement—perfect for a game room, guest suite, or quiet retreat. Whether you're sipping coffee on the porch or exploring the surrounding countryside

Montezuma, IN Homes for Sale

Feast your eyes on this charmer. A 3-bedroom home that's practically tap-dancing with delight to meet you. Prepare to be wowed by the kitchen, where culinary dreams take flight around a beautiful kitchen island, just begging for you to gather round with friends, family, or maybe just a really good cookbook. The porch offers a spot to sit and watch the world go by, while the generous lot provides ample space for all your outdoor aspirations. This is more than just a house; it's a happy-making home just waiting to be filled with laughter and love.

Montezuma, IN Homes for Sale

Discover 525 S 4th St, a single-family residence ready to welcome its new owners. This brick foursquare home features four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths. Inside, its classic charm is showcased by beautiful wood trim, elegant pocket doors, and practical built-ins. The main level offers a living room, formal dining, kitchen, laundry, and a half bath. All four bedrooms and a full bathroom are on the upper level. The basement is accessible from both the main level and an exterior door. This home makes a great first impression with a large, covered front porch perfect for relaxation. Situated on a . 2 acre lot, the property offers yard space for a garden, a play area, or room for pets. A sid

Montezuma, IN Homes for Sale

Wow! This property has it all-seclusion, rolling hardwoods, a year-round creek, food plots, and incredible wildlife diversity. A true big-buck producer, this turn-key hunting retreat features a fully remodeled 3,240+/- sq. ft. lodge that sleeps 16. Updates include a new kitchen with modern countertops, cabinets, appliances, and island; a new laundry room, bath, flooring, HVAC, and a hunting locker room. The property is fully set up with a trail system, 6 elevated blinds, and 15 tree stands (including 9 Millennium ladders) strategically placed along proven funnels and pinch points. Rock Run Creek flows through the land, providing scenic beauty and a reliable water source for wildlife. Seven-