Shirley, IN homes for sale & real estate

Shirley, IN Homes for Sale

Step into timeless charm with this gem at 5378 W State Road 38 in New Castle, Indiana. Completely rehabbed in 2024, major appliances including water heater, furnace, and A/C are 2 years old, and a new septic in 2025. Boasting 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths across 1,316 sq ft, this home blends historic character with modern comforts. The upstairs bedroom offers a serene sitting room and walk-in shower, while the eat-in kitchen dazzles with newer cabinetry and contemporary plumbing fixtures. A well-appointed utility room ensures convenience with laundry hookups and essential appliances, all leading to a private backyard and detached one-car garage ideal for extra storage or a workshop.

Shirley, IN Homes for Sale

This unique property offers approximately 2,200 square feet of living space with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms, along with a private well and septic system. There is also second two-story barn/shop, which has electric and water run to it, and partially insulated. The well house is heated and large enough for storage. There is a second septic located on property across from the house. This home has undergone significant remodeling. Fully functional kitchen, gas fireplace, full bath, and bedroom space has been added. There are still a few finishing projects for the next owner. Remaining projects include finishing and covering the former garage-door area in the master bedroom, installing a few

Shirley, IN Homes for Sale

This 1925 Home welcomes you into a quality that is hard to come by these days. Full brick exterior, real hardwood flooring, tall wood baseboards, and beveled glass doors. The covered front porch greets with a porch swing to enjoy an Indiana evening. The living room offers a resting place and a decorative fireplace. Across the hall you enter the formal dining room with a bench seat and built ins. Head to the kitchen, loaded with Stainless steel appliances including a gas stove, wood cabinets and there is plenty of countertop space. Main level bedroom has a walk-in closet. Upstairs you will find three more bedrooms, two with walk-in closets, one of those even has 2 walk in closets! There are

Shirley, IN Homes for Sale

Welcome to 8 School Street, a distinguished single-family residence built in the heart of Markleville. This is a rare opportunity to own 3 acres in town Markleville! This single-family home offering a generous 2336 square feet of living space with newer upgrades! You will love the engineered hardwood floors. This attractive property presents a unique opportunity to embrace a lifestyle rich in character and modern comforts, with a modern remodel in 2019. The heart of the home, the kitchen, is thoughtfully appointed with stainless steel appliances and a convenient island, providing both functionality and a welcoming space for culinary endeavors. Well appointed with three bedrooms. The primary

Shirley, IN Homes for Sale

Welcome to your new construction home! This home is an exceptional find in the heart of Markleville. This home is newly constructed in 2026 and offers generous 2128 square feet of meticulously designed living space. This home spares no expense. You will love the high-end windows, spray foam insulation downstairs to help with noise reduction, upgraded cabinets, doors, and appliances! This property truly distinguishes itself as a premier home for those seeking contemporary comfort and sophisticated living. If you are looking for move-in ready, this is your home. The home offers three well-appointed bedrooms, providing ample accommodations. Complementing these are two full bathrooms and one ha

Shirley, IN Homes for Sale

Wake up to lake views and fall asleep to the sounds of the woods. This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom retreat sits on five wooded acres overlooking Lake Haven in Henry County, offering the rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and lake access all in one property. Spend your mornings with coffee on the covered front porch, evenings entertaining on the side deck, and every season in between soaking up the view from the three-seasons room. With deer, birds, and other wildlife regularly passing through the property, this home feels like a year-round nature retreat - while the lake itself invites you to fish, paddle, or simply unwind on the water. Inside, the home offers a functional floor plan. T