Rental market trends for
Bay Shore, NY
The average rent price in Bay Shore was $3,132 last month, up $23 month over month.
Median rent
$3,132
Month-over-month change
+$23
Average rent in Bay Shore
In August 2025, Bay Shore rental prices increased $23 compared to last month.
$3,132
+0.74% month over month
Median rent of neighborhoods in Bay Shore
| Neighborhood | Median rent | MoM (% change) |
|---|---|---|
| Long Island | $3,100 | -11.43% |
| Islip | $2,500 | -13.40% |
| Penataquit Point | $2,745 | +14.37% |
| Pine Aire | $3,050 | +22.00% |
| Downtown | $2,707 | +23.07% |
Last updated: 09/24/2025
Average rent of nearby cities
Here's how Bay Shore's average rent of $3,132 compares to nearby cities.
Last updated: 09/24/2025
More resources for Bay Shore
- Property types
- Cities
- Neighborhoods
- Zip codes
- Bedrooms
- Price
- Amenities
| Condos for rent in Bay Shore | |||
| Houses for rent in Bay Shore | |||
| Apartments for rent in Bay Shore | |||
| Rooms for rent in Bay Shore | |||
| Rental listings in Bay Shore |


United States
Canada