Butler, IN homes for sale & real estate

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Come check out this beautifully maintained home on over 2 acres in Dekalb County. Home has 2 large living areas, one of which has previously been used as a 4th bedroom. Family room features cathedral ceilings. All appliances are included. All new windows and doors in 2023. 2 car detached garage has an additional 16x24 area for parking or use as a covered patio for entertaining and enjoying the beautiful scenery called your back yard. There are 2 smaller sheds. One was used for wood, and the newer shed was used for lawn mower, outside tools, toys and pool products & chemicals. Don’t miss this move in ready home!

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Welcome to this stunning Pleasant Point estate on a half-acre private peninsula with 400 ft of lake frontage on Hamilton Lake. This fully furnished, turnkey 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home features luxury vinyl plank flooring, quartz countertops, and Pella windows with built-in blinds. The main living area showcases panoramic lake views, a 20' beadboard with beamed ceiling, and gas log fireplace. The primary bedroom offers 16' vaulted ceilings, and floor to ceiling windows overlooking the lake. In the primary bath you will find a bubble tub with a fireplace, a custom 2-person shower, and heated floors. The primary also features a custom-designed walk-in closet with built-in storage and a washer/dr

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Discover the potential on this charming 2 story, 4 bedroom home right in town. Just a short distance to Hamilton Lake! This 4 bedroom residence is sol "AS IS" and needs a little TLC ready for you to make it your own. As you step inside you'll appreciate the natural woodwork and abundant natural light that fill the spacious living areas. The main level features 2 spacious family rooms and a bedroom that connects to a large bathroom, complete with built in cabinets for ample storage. Upstairs, you'll find 3 additional bedrooms and a convenient half bath, perfect for family and guests. The decent sized yard provides plenty of space for outdoor activities, and the sizable deck in the

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

OPEN HOUSE, SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 17 FROM 1:00-3:00!! This is one very sweet country property! It has everything you could ever want for entertaining!! It has a brand new "never been swam in" liner! Look behind the fenced in pool/fire pit area because the property extends way beyond! You will also find 3 apple, 1 cherry, 2 peach trees, and a nice shed! The backyard is reason enough to buy this property but the house has so much to offer as well! All of the big ticket items have been taken care of. The roof was completely torn off and replaced in 2019. All of the windows have already been replaced by Champion. The Watchdog sump pump was replaced in 2023 and has a backup sump. Th

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Nestled on a tranquil 2-acre lot, this beautiful two-story home with a full basement offers over 3,000 square feet of flexible living space. Tucked away through a wooded area for ultimate privacy, the home sits 166 feet off County Road 75A, offering the perfect retreat. Featuring 3 conforming bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and several additional rooms that can be used as bedrooms, dens, or offices, this home adapts to your every need. The attached side-load 3-car garage provides convenient dual access from both the main living area and the basement. In addition, a detached two-story outbuilding, approximately 32 x 25, offers endless possibilities as a workshop, studio, or finish out as an ADU. Th

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

What an AWESOME setting!!! This property has it all!!! With a little over 6 acres (approx 1 wooded) with a stocked pond, NEW outbuilding with heat and a/c, and a 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath ranch home on a full/finished basement, with a 3 car garage! Entering through the foyer area, step into the very open/spacious living room with cozy gas log fireplace. Down the hallway to the right is the laundry room leading out to the garage, a full bath, as well as 3 of the bedrooms. The large master suite has dual vanities, large walk in closet, soaking tub and stand up shower. Going left from the foyer entrance is the beautiful kitchen with plenty of space, lots of storage, and dining area with access to

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Picture PERFECT setting. Nestled amoung trees rather than neighbors. This pristine farm house is like new but has character too. This home has been through a thorough, down to the studs remodel with nearly everything updated, including but not limited to. .. roof, windows, siding, walls, electric, plumbing, HVAC, water heater, softner, flooring and lighting. Kitchen and bath fixtures are all new as well with stainless steel appliances included. Main bedroom, bath and laundry are all on the 1st floor. Perimeter drain has been installed to keep water away from the foundation and walls have been sealed and recoated as well. 30x40 barn is great for storage or animals. Ideal location on a paved

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Escape to your own private oasis in this stunning waterfront property. With breathtaking views of the lake, a private dock, and plenty of storage space (inside and out), you'll feel like you're on vacation every day. 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom spacious floor plan with tons of natural light. The finished basement has tons of storage space. It is plumbed for an additional bathroom in the basement or to have a mother-in-law suite, the possibilities are endless. This home would be perfect for entertaining with the massive decks overlooking the lake and backyard. Well maintained and updated over the years. Several updates have been made to the home, including new composite decking. Come see this be

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Sharpen your pencil because this home will check all of the boxes! Beautifully situated on 15 acres in rural DeKalb County, this 4,200 sq. ft. home features 8 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, a game room, an inviting family room with fireplace, and a gorgeous completely custom kitchen with a large island capable of seating up to 8 people. The finished walk-out basement includes a second kitchen, additional living space and storage, and walks out to the stamped concrete patio where you can choose to jump into either the pool or hot tub. Outside, you'll find three large outbuildings that meet a broad range of needs - from insulated walls, concrete floors, tall overhead doors, 8 brand new box stalls a

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

3910 E Bellefontaine is a large home that was built in the early 1900’s as a show place. It has natural woodwork, and pocket doors on the first floor with lakeview from multiple rooms in the house. All the bedroom have closets. Main Bedroom has 2 closets. The attic has a staircase and a fully laid floor. On the back of the second floor is an open area that just needs a floating deck to give you an ideal outside living space. The house has updated wiring, plumbing and newer HVAC. It also has a new front porch floor and stairs. The house is in a great downtown location, close to the Public Beach. It is also near restaurants, Grocery Store, Post Office, and all the downtown events. You c

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Over 30 acres of residential, agricultural, and wooded land overlooking Ball Lake on Bellefontaine Rd, just minutes from Hamilton Lake. Great potential!

Butler, IN Homes for Sale

Approximately 64 acres of farm ground with approximately 56 tillable acres. Land is currently farmed, but many possibilities are there for recreation, hunting, etc. A recorded easement will be given to the property from CR 59 across the property at 5010 CR 59, Auburn