Old Town, FL homes for sale & real estate

Old Town, FL Homes for Sale

Welcome to 1304 Mitchell Avenue —an adorable brick home full of character and natural light! From the original hardwood floors and arched doorways to the two cozy fireplaces and huge family room, this home blends vintage charm with modern comfort. You'll love the spacious layout, porch, private backyard, and walkable location right in the heart of Midtown. Bonus: there's a garage/workshop and tons of storage space! Come see this Midtown gem before it's gone!

Old Town, FL Homes for Sale

Move in ready in Mid Town! Hike, play tennis or pickleball across the street at Lafayette Park. Walk to restaurants and entertainment in Mid Town. Near hospital, offices, shopping and Whole Foods. Updated with wood floors, granite counter tops, stainless appliances and crown moulding. Enjoy maintenance free living in this quiet and popular neighborhood! Relax on covered front porch that overlooks courtyard and fountain. Let someone else mow and maintain the beautiful grounds!

Old Town, FL Homes for Sale

Charming Midtown Split-Level with Income Potential! This beautifully maintained all-brick home is right in the heart of Midtown, just a short walk to dinner, drinks, and nearby parks! The unique split-level design features two private entrances and two kitchens, offering flexibility for an Airbnb, rental income, or multi-generational living. The main level boasts an inviting open layout with 2 bedrooms, a full bath, an office, and gorgeous hardwood floors throughout. Downstairs, you’ll find a fully renovated in-law suite with exposed brick accents, a spacious L-shaped studio layout, a full bathroom, and its own kitchen and living area. The lower level has been successfully rented on

Old Town, FL Homes for Sale

Please submit all offers by 5pm Sunday 9/14/25 with a time of response for Monday at 5pm! Sold AS-IS with right to inspect, listed $35,000 below the current appraised value. All recent inspections are available! Welcome to this one-of-a-kind opportunity in the heart of Midtown to take a wonderful home and make it your dream! The main home features 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms with nearly 1,700 square feet of living space. A bright, enclosed 200-square-foot front porch adds even more usable space, perfect for a sunroom, or casual lounge area. The garage apartment provides an additional 500 square feet of fully independent living. Complete with its own kitchen, living room, bedroom, and b

Old Town, FL Homes for Sale

“Quiet sophistication. ” That’s how a local artist describes this unique Tallahassee home. A gentle garden path graciously welcomes you to your new Downtown/Midtown home. Step inside and notice the skip-trowel plaster walls that give a subtle, old-world richness and texture throughout this thoroughly modern home. Casement windows flood the open floor plan with natural light. And speaking of light: Reed Burkhardt Lighting Design delivered the custom interior lighting scheme, which elevates the serenity and dramatic interior beauty of this urban oasis. The sleek Kitchen is thoughtfully designed for cooking and entertaining, with Thermador appliances, including an induction c

Old Town, FL Homes for Sale

Welcome to 1223 Mitchell Avenue in beautiful Midtown Tallahassee. This 1947 Bungalow is rich with history and charm, while having modern conveniences as well. The home has 1040 SF, while the detached studio has 240 SF (as well as a heated and cooled 339 SF garage). With arched openings, beautiful hardwood floors, and large windows throughout, this home has style in spades. A large deck out back overlooking the lovely yard lends itself for entertaining or quiet evenings at home. The front porch overlooks a partially fenced front yard, great to catch up with neighbors and enjoy how lovely Mitchell Avenue truly is. Don't delay in seeing this special property, you'll end up loving it as much as