Believed to date back to 1640, this is one of Connecticut's oldest surviving homes-a rare opportunity to own a piece of early New England history. Set on 8.57 private acres bordered by original stone walls, this 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath home offers approximately 2,700 sq ft of living space, with graciously sized rooms, original wood details, and a cedar-lined closet. A major highlight is the dramatic 22' x 35' studio space added in the 1970s-featuring tall ceilings and abundant light-perfect for an artist, dancer, musician, or anyone seeking an inspiring workspace. Also on the property is a large detached barn with a rustic upper-level studio, once used by notable local artists. While the barn needs restoration, it includes a fireplace, loft, and lower-level storage area with a dirt floor-ideal for equipment or gardening tools. Surrounded by protected forest and located across from Beckett Hill State Park and Nehantic State Forest, this unique property offers tranquility, history, and creative potential.
Paperwork for installation of septic tank in 2018, radon and water test results are included in the MLS attachments. Property being sold "As-is" which is reflected in the price.
Single-familyProperty Type
1640Year Built
8.57 acresLot Size
$156Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listed by Amy Jones• Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop.
Bought with Nancy Mesham• Coldwell Banker Realty
Source:Smart MLS #24087852
Redfin Estimate
$420,816
$29K since sold in June 2025$69K since September
Recently sold homes
Estimate history
Homes for sale
This home's estimate is 45.1% lower than the average sale price ($767K) of 6 comparable homes.
ONCE IN A LIFETIME OPPORTUNITY TO OWN A TREASURE OF US HISTORY AND A WORK OF ART! This hidden gem is believed to have been built in 1640, making it one of the most historic homes in America and an important part of the Saybrook Colony's founding history! This lovingly maintained home now boasts 2,700 square feet after additions in the 1800's and 1970's, with graciously sized rooms and an enormous art studio ready for your creativity to come to life. Many fortunate art scholars learned the craft from renowned artists Fred & Elsie Buchholz (the owner's brilliant grandparents). This space could also be used as a gracious first floor master bedroom suite with its adjacent half bath or a wonderful at-home office with its own exterior entrance! Let your imagination run wild! Why wait? You could be waking up in your luxurious master suite, strolling over your superb hardwood floors to your kitchen, opening your high quality solid wood cabinets to brew up a cup of coffee. Then conveniently exit the kitchen door to relax on your privately situated covered front porch and listen to your babbling brook off in the distance. If you're feeling adventurous, you can go out and enjoy your 8.57 acres, which are privately surrounded by vacant land, or experience the Beckett Hill Reserve & Nehantic State Forest across the road! Invite your friends for a day out boating on Roger's Lake with your convenient access to the public boat launch less than a mile down the road!
Smart MLS #170123813
Dec 28, 2018
Sold
$270,000
$100/sq ft
Sep 10, 2018
Listed
$275,000
$102/sq ft
RIS #1201556
Dec 28, 2018
Sold
$270,000
$100/sq ft
Dec 2, 2018
Pending
—
Nov 23, 2018
Price Changed
$275,000
$102/sq ft
Nov 12, 2018
Price Changed
$289,000
$107/sq ft
Sep 1, 2018
Price Changed
$299,000
$111/sq ft
Aug 17, 2018
Listed
$324,000
$120/sq ft
Smart MLS #170116180
Aug 15, 2018
Listed
$275,000
$102/sq ft
RIS #1183481
Aug 15, 2018
Listing Removed
—
Aug 13, 2018
Price Changed
$324,000
$120/sq ft
Jul 23, 2018
Price Changed
$349,000
$129/sq ft
Jun 12, 2018
Price Changed
$374,000
$139/sq ft
May 21, 2018
Price Changed
$400,000
$148/sq ft
Mar 10, 2018
Price Changed
$425,000
$157/sq ft
Feb 23, 2018
Listed
$429,900
$159/sq ft
Smart MLS #170054955
Aug 15, 2018
Listing Removed
—
Feb 23, 2018
Listed
$324,000
$120/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$5,737 (+37.9%)
$145,200 + $149,000
$294,200
2022
$4,160
$103,900 + $104,600
$208,500
2021
$4,160
$103,900 + $104,600
$208,500
2020
$4,160 (+13.4%)
$103,900 + $104,600
$208,500
2019
$3,667 (−9.0%)
$79,231 + $104,600
$183,831
2018
$4,031 (+1.9%)
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2017
$3,955
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2016
$3,955 (+7.4%)
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2014
$3,684 (−1.3%)
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2011
$3,732
$109,595 + $157,000
$266,595
Tax history for 193 Grassy Hill Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2023
$5,737 (+37.9%)
$145,200 + $149,000
$294,200
2022
$4,160
$103,900 + $104,600
$208,500
2021
$4,160
$103,900 + $104,600
$208,500
2020
$4,160 (+13.4%)
$103,900 + $104,600
$208,500
2019
$3,667 (−9.0%)
$79,231 + $104,600
$183,831
2018
$4,031 (+1.9%)
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2017
$3,955
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2016
$3,955 (+7.4%)
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2014
$3,684 (−1.3%)
$87,512 + $129,200
$216,712
2011
$3,732
$109,595 + $157,000
$266,595
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.