Nestled on one of Sarasota’s most sumptuous barrier islands, this 2,188-square-foot home in Casey Key embodies the essence of summer in the Hamptons — with a front-row seat to the serene sunrises, stunning sunsets and sparkling waters along the Gulf of Mexico; you can have it all. Teemed with old-Florida charm and laid-back luxury, this three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath residence boasts elegant renovations, stunning Gulf and bay views, along with a 10-foot deeded beachfront directly across the street from its doorstep. Renovated in 2013 by Jonas Yoder Custom Homes Construction, the open and airy interior features exposed beam ceilings complemented by timeless dark luxury vinyl flooring throughout most areas and a wood-burning fireplace in the spacious great room. Completely upgraded, the gourmet chef’s kitchen showcases pristine white cabinetry with plenty of storage space, a vibrant glass-tile backsplash and is fully equipped with stainless steel appliances and a double-door LG refrigerator with endless views of the bay from the kitchen window. Perfect for privacy when needed, each bedroom is en-suite and offers access to its own screened-in porch or patio and the expansive master suite highlights a spacious walk-in closet with plenty of space to retreat. Outside — an almost a half-acre opulent waterfront lifestyle awaits with gracious brick-paved and seashell-covered grounds, a seating area illuminated by tiki torches, spacious brick paver patio, two outdoor showers and a picturesque new wood dock with room for your boat overlooking the Intracoastal, mangroves and natural Floridian beauty plus plenty room to accommodate your future swimming pool. Additional high-quality improvements to this home include a new roof and HVAC system, new plumbing and electrical, new flooring throughout and all-new impact-resistant windows. Experience paradise every day! Casey Key, known for its magnificent custom homes and celebrity residents, presents a poised beachside getaway along the sugar-sand shores, with modern elegance, breathtaking sunsets and bliss at every turn. Easy access on and off Casey Key from Blackburn Point Road, near the Casey Key Fish House and the newly opened "Deep Lagoon" upscale restaurant and marina. Casey Key is just a few minutes to downtown Sarasota and St Armand's Circle, as well as The Island of Venice to the south. Easy access to I-75 and all local airports. Experience paradise every day!
Single-familyProperty Type
1950Year Built
0.49 acresLot Size
$1,033Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 car garageParking
Listed by Joe Harris• PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY
Listed by Charles Totonis• PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY
Contact: 941-907-9541
Bought with Michael Saur PLLC• CENTURY 21 SCHMIDT REAL ESTATE
Good renovation potential or build your own slice of paradise. Cypress frame home with shingle style metal roof. 100 feet of water frontage with nice views of the Intracoastal Waterway, dock and boat slip plus a 10' deeded beach easement located directly across the street. Conveniently located South of Blackburn Point Rd for easy on and off key access. This is a beautiful piece of land for the buyer seeking location, opportunity and good value.
Stellar MLS as Distributed by MLS Grid #A3937372
Apr 12, 2012
Listing Removed
—
Jan 4, 2011
Listed
*
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$20,180 (+4.4%)
$1,216,300 + $469,300
$1,685,600
2024
$19,335 (+82.2%)
$1,338,000 + $306,100
$1,644,100
2023
$10,612 (+2.2%)
2022
$10,387 (−1.2%)
2021
$10,514 (−0.7%)
2020
$10,587 (+3.0%)
2019
$10,279 (+1.9%)
2018
$10,086 (+0.7%)
2017
$10,015 (+0.2%)
2016
$9,997 (−1.9%)
2015
$10,188 (+0.3%)
2014
$10,153 (+10.7%)
2013
$9,175 (+2.8%)
2012
$8,925
Tax history for 4004 Casey Key Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$20,180 (+4.4%)
$1,216,300 + $469,300
$1,685,600
2024
$19,335 (+82.2%)
$1,338,000 + $306,100
$1,644,100
2023
$10,612 (+2.2%)
2022
$10,387 (−1.2%)
2021
$10,514 (−0.7%)
2020
$10,587 (+3.0%)
2019
$10,279 (+1.9%)
2018
$10,086 (+0.7%)
2017
$10,015 (+0.2%)
2016
$9,997 (−1.9%)
2015
$10,188 (+0.3%)
2014
$10,153 (+10.7%)
2013
$9,175 (+2.8%)
2012
$8,925
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Permits
Beds
4
Baths
4.5
Stories
1
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
21,136
Year renovated
2020
Sq. Ft.
2,188
Year built
1950
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Sarasota County
APN
0157120001
Parking Spaces
1
Basement
No
Accessible
No
HOA Dues
—
Garage
Yes
Features
Views, Green, Waterfront, Pool
Last updated by owner on Jan 13, 2026.
RE-2
Residential Estate District
The RE Districts permits large lot, estate-type development. A limited number of nonresidential uses are allowed, subject to the restrictions and requirements necessary to preserve and protect the low-density estate character of the district; The RE Districts are generally used to implement the Comprehensive Plan within those areas shown as Semi-Rural, Low Density and Moderate Density Residential on the Future Land Use Map. Locations on the Barrier Islands that have existing RE zoning are acknowledged, and are considered to be consistent with the Future Land Use Map; however, such lands shall not be rezoned to a more intensive RE District; Agricultural uses permitted under the OUE-2 District prior to October 27, 2003, shall continue to be permitted uses on those parcels converted from OUE-2 to RE-1 zoning.
Permitted uses
Include but are not limited to:
Agriculture
Equestrian facility
Livestock production
Housing-Group
Housing-Single unit
Housing-Senior
Housing-Student
Infrastructure
Veterinary clinic
Park & open space
Mar 21, 2025 • Final
Residential pool/spa
Construct a new pool and spa.
Pool and hot tub
Sep 11, 2024 • Final
Residential alteration
Renovate a home within the existing footprint.
Remodel
Permit history is from public records and may be incomplete or inaccurate. Redfin and its agents make no representations about the property condition or permit status. Buyers should independently verify all information.
Property details
Parking
Parking Information
Garage Dimensions: 20x12
Parking Features: Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Ground Level, Open, Oversized