Be the king or queen of your own 87 acre mountain overlooking Lake Monroe, the largest body of water in Indiana. The home sits approximately 750' above water level, the sailing club and boat ramp only a few miles around the corner. Rarely does big acreage this close to downtown Bloomington and IU (15 minutes away) come on the market. Having this much acreage on Lake Monroe is even more rare. Great views can be had from this elevated ridge. You would own a whole point with approximately 3,000 feet of lake frontage. Property has been surveyed for a mini subdivision, each lot tested for septic and in compliance. Keep the point, sell off the rest. All lots have been configured to have lake views. Or, with variance or self sustained waste water treatment one could add numerous lots. As you drive back on the 1/4 mile drive you'll notice mature timber and a park like setting. At the end of the point sits a 6,131 sqft 7 bedroom, 6 bath Tudor home with in-ground pool and 3 car attached garage. The home is in need of a complete remodel but is structurally sound along with solid foundation. It could be torn down and a new masterpiece constructed. Make your own tourist destination with zip lines and hiking trails, ecotourism on the lake or family compound. Let your imagination run wild! Property surrounded by DNR land and IU Foundation preserve. Property being sold "as-is", 48 hour notice on showings.
Single-familyProperty Type
1975Year Built
86.94 acresLot Size
$276Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
3 car garageParking
Listed by Aaron Steele• FC Tucker/Bloomington REALTORS
* Price is not available or MLS listing is off market.
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2024
$8,735 (−6.2%)
$144,600 + $841,400
$986,000
2023
$9,316 (+41.8%)
$144,600 + $833,600
$978,200
2022
$6,568 (+93.1%)
$144,600 + $308,700
$453,300
2021
$3,402 (−51.0%)
$227,000
2020
$6,942 (+74.8%)
$227,000 + $217,800
$444,800
2019
$3,972 (−1.1%)
$227,000 + $217,800
$444,800
2018
$4,016 (−26.8%)
$335,700 + $217,800
$553,500
2017
$5,490 (+76.5%)
$335,700 + $217,400
$553,100
2016
$3,110 (−49.4%)
$163,200 + $218,700
$381,900
2015
$6,143 (−1.6%)
$155,500 + $597,000
$752,500
2013
$6,240
$155,500 + $582,900
$738,400
Tax history for 5099 E Paynetown Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2024
$8,735 (−6.2%)
$144,600 + $841,400
$986,000
2023
$9,316 (+41.8%)
$144,600 + $833,600
$978,200
2022
$6,568 (+93.1%)
$144,600 + $308,700
$453,300
2021
$3,402 (−51.0%)
$227,000
2020
$6,942 (+74.8%)
$227,000 + $217,800
$444,800
2019
$3,972 (−1.1%)
$227,000 + $217,800
$444,800
2018
$4,016 (−26.8%)
$335,700 + $217,800
$553,500
2017
$5,490 (+76.5%)
$335,700 + $217,400
$553,100
2016
$3,110 (−49.4%)
$163,200 + $218,700
$381,900
2015
$6,143 (−1.6%)
$155,500 + $597,000
$752,500
2013
$6,240
$155,500 + $582,900
$738,400
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
5
Baths
4.5
Stories
1.5
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
16.82 Acres
Year renovated
2021
Sq. Ft.
7,807
Year built
2021
Style
Vacant Land
County
Monroe County
APN
530836100007000008
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 16, 2026.
AG/RR
AREA 1
Agriculture/Rural Reserve District
The character of the Agriculture/Rural Reserve (AG/RR) District is defined as that which is primarily intended for agriculture uses including, but not limited to, row crop or livestock production, forages, pasture, forestry, single family residential uses associated with agriculture uses and limited, very low density, rural non-farm related single family uses and not in (major) subdivisions. Its purposes are to encourage the continuation of agriculture uses, along with the associated single family residential uses, to discourage the development of residential subdivisions and non-farm-related nonresidential uses, to protect the environmentally sensitive areas, such as floodplain and steep slopes, and to maintain the character of the surrounding neighborhood. Therefore, the number of uses permitted in the AG/RR District is limited. Some uses are conditionally permitted. The conditions placed on these uses are to insure their compatibility with the agriculture-related uses. The development of new non-farm residential activities proximate to known mineral resource deposits or extraction operations may be buffered by increased setback distance.