Public Remarks: A swing-ready front porch with paneled ceiling welcomes you and once inside, gleaming Early American oak hardwood flooring and the near-perfect Rookwood tile fireplace are the first things you notice. 1870 Rutherford Avenue is a brick three bedroom, two full bath home located in the coveted Deer Park neighborhood of the Highlands. A living room that expands from the front to rear exterior walls of the house is your point of entry and the dining room which features crown molding and chair rail is to the right. An addition completed by a prior owner allows for an expanded kitchen along with the creation of a bonus room and full bathroom also on the first floor. Frequently, a traditional Bungalow will lack that ''one-extra-room'' needed for today's home/work environment but not this one! There's even a large closet that may be used for small appliances, extra kitchen items or an out-of-sight file cabinet should you choose to go the office route. The kitchen is functional, spacious and upgraded to meet the needs of multiple chefs in the space at once. White 42" wall cabinets, a 36" pantry, Bosch dishwasher, GE Smart Slide-In Induction range, concrete countertops, and glass tile backsplash all lead to a complete cooking experience. The upstairs may be accessed from the left or right side of the first level thanks to a stairway with two entry points and central landing. Upstairs are three bedrooms, each with deep closets, and a traditional 2-room bathroom typical of the 1920's. The marble floor has a vintage feel and subway tile along with the original medicine cabinet respect the integrity of the period of construction. In a location where street parking is the norm and often begrudgingly accepted, this jewel offers a driveway plus a generously-sized (22x24) poured concrete pad in the rear. Even a student driver could reasonably park and get turned around without issue. You'll also be excited to find an L-shaped family room in the basement. This is not your typical 100-year old home lower level. A stairway with a turn ensures comfortable clearance. You will also find a drywall ceiling, recessed lighting, three large windows and plush carpet. The rear yard offers a central walkway from parking and a large deck with curved copper railing. You will not want to miss out on this very special property!
Single-familyProperty Type
1925Year Built
8,276 sq ftLot Size
$226Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 spaceParking
Listed by move Real Estate Group. live. grow. invest. Dugan• Semonin Realtors
Bought with 502-727-HOME(4663) Wuest• Semonin Realtors
Beautifully renovated home in quiet, convenient Highlands neighborhood. Custom, curved deck overlooks large flat yard; mature trees & landscaping. New driveway with footers in place for garage. Move right in! No wallpaper to strip or floors to refinish! Sunny kitchen has custom oak cabinets, lots of storage, laminate flooring. Stove, microwave, dishwasher remain. 2 full baths have features such as pedestal sinks, large shower, 2001 Retro marble black/white tile, new plumbing. 13 x 25.5 living room has fireplace with original 1920's Rookwood tile. Neutral decor, nice oak floors, 9ft. ceilings throughout. Full basement, lots of storage area, furnace 2 yrs. old W/WARRANTY.
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$5,418 (+35.7%)
$60,000 + $370,000
$430,000
2024
$3,993 (+3.2%)
$60,000 + $370,000
$430,000
2023
$3,868 (−1.3%)
$60,000 + $251,000
$311,000
2022
$3,920 (−5.7%)
$55,000 + $233,260
$288,260
2021
$4,157 (+23.0%)
$55,000 + $233,260
$288,260
2020
$3,381 (+2.4%)
$55,000 + $233,260
$288,260
2019
$3,300 (+1.3%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2018
$3,258 (+1.6%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2017
$3,206 (−0.6%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2015
$3,225 (−9.4%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2014
$3,561
$30,000 + $239,000
$269,000
Tax history for 1870 Rutherford Ave
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$5,418 (+35.7%)
$60,000 + $370,000
$430,000
2024
$3,993 (+3.2%)
$60,000 + $370,000
$430,000
2023
$3,868 (−1.3%)
$60,000 + $251,000
$311,000
2022
$3,920 (−5.7%)
$55,000 + $233,260
$288,260
2021
$4,157 (+23.0%)
$55,000 + $233,260
$288,260
2020
$3,381 (+2.4%)
$55,000 + $233,260
$288,260
2019
$3,300 (+1.3%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2018
$3,258 (+1.6%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2017
$3,206 (−0.6%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2015
$3,225 (−9.4%)
$60,000 + $186,020
$246,020
2014
$3,561
$30,000 + $239,000
$269,000
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Permits
Beds
—
Baths
—
Stories
—
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
8,207 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
1925
Sq. Ft.
—
Year built
1925
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Jefferson County
APN
10079A00970000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 8, 2026.
Apr 1, 2019 • Final
Electrical residential
Install a new electrical circuit for a sump pump.
Electrical
Permit history is from public records and may be incomplete or inaccurate. Redfin and its agents make no representations about the property condition or permit status. Buyers should independently verify all information.