Rich in history and local heritage, this remarkable 1860 home has been lovingly cared for through generations of one of Addison's founding families. The residence was consecutively occupied by Marcia Ward Cleaves, the respected matriarch of the prominent Cleaves family, who lived to the age of 104, and her daughter, Alice Ward Cleaves Williams, who also enjoyed an extraordinary life spanning 105 years. The current owners purchased the home from the Alice Williams Estate to ensure stewardship of this cherished property. With deep ties to Addison's earliest settlers, the home offers a rare opportunity to own a meaningful piece of the town's history while creating your own legacy for generations to come. Adding to the property's remarkable history is the detached garage, relocated to the site in 1960 from Tumbledown Dick Road, where it originally served as the Town of Addison's blacksmith shop. A fascinating reminder of its past, the original blacksmith's forge remains intact, offering a rare glimpse into the craftsmanship and daily life of an earlier era. This one-of-a-kind feature enhances the property's historical significance and provides an exceptional conversation piece for history enthusiasts and preservation-minded buyers alike. Encompassing approximately 2,590 square feet, including the attached rear workshop and barn, this spacious home showcases the quality craftsmanship of its era. Soaring 8-foot ceilings, expansive windows that fill the rooms with natural light, and beautifully preserved original handcrafted woodwork create a warm and inviting atmosphere. Rich in character and architectural detail, the home's generous layout offers exceptional space and endless possibilities for comfortable living, creative pursuits, or future restoration. Historic home, solid construction, 1.1 acre in-town lot, Appealing price which allows budget room for expansion & improvements. 1st level occupiable area w/ all systems working. Large 26x27' garage. Boat launch nearby
Single-familyProperty Type
1825Year Built
1.1 acresLot Size
$37Price/Sq.Ft.
1 car garageParking
Listed by Karen Eldridge• Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate/The Masiello Group
Est. $2,351 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 191 Water St
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
MREIS #1671792
Aug 13, 2026
Sold
$95,000
$37/sq ft
Jul 14, 2026
Listed
$109,000
$42/sq ft
MREIS #1471292
Aug 9, 2021
Sold
$60,000
$23/sq ft
Oct 2, 2020
Listed
$75,000
$29/sq ft
+12
Older 8 room New England farmhouse with 2-story ell. House has a lot of character but needs a fair amount of TLC. In addition, there is a large garage building that was used as a blacksmith shop years ago. Nice setting and close to village and all amenities.
MREIS #1430411
Aug 22, 2019
Listed
$89,000
$34/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$2,092 (+3.1%)
$20,600 + $87,800
$108,400
2024
$2,029 (+8.7%)
$20,600 + $87,800
$108,400
2023
$1,867 (+4.6%)
$20,600 + $87,800
$108,400
2022
$1,785
$19,700 + $87,800
$107,500
2021
$1,785 (+4.3%)
$19,700 + $87,800
$107,500
2020
$1,712 (+0.6%)
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2019
$1,701
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2018
$1,701
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2017
$1,701 (+8.9%)
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2016
$1,562 (+1.8%)
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2015
$1,535 (+7.0%)
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2014
$1,434 (+7.2%)
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
2013
$1,338
$19,700 + $87,300
$107,000
Public record
Beds
4
Baths
1
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
1.1 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
2,160
Year built
1860
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Washington County
APN
580997
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Nov 17, 2025.
Property details
Parking
Parking Information
Has Garage
# of Garage Spaces: 1
Parking Features: Gravel, 1 - 4 Spaces, On Site, Detached