Welcome to 59 Tuttle Road, a beautifully restored piece of Cumberland history. Originally built in 1820 as a schoolhouse, this charming Cape has been thoughtfully renovated to preserve its character while offering the comforts of modern living. Set on a picturesque 0.66-acre lot in the desirable Cumberland Center, this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1,700 square feet of stylish and functional living space. Step inside through a spacious tiled mudroom that connects the home to an insulated, heated two-car garage with a large storage loft above. The kitchen impresses with its timeless white shaker cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and natural gas range, flowing seamlessly into a casual dining area with sliding doors to the backyard. A cozy rear living room is anchored by a gas fireplace and surrounded by custom built-ins, creating a perfect space to relax or entertain. The first-floor primary suite provides a peaceful retreat, complete with dual closets, a large linen closet, a charming alcove with a pocket door, and a full en-suite bath with tasteful finishes. Upstairs, you'll find two additional bedrooms, one currently used as a home office, and another updated full bath. Throughout the home, thoughtful updates and ample storage solutions ensure both style and practicality. Curb appeal abounds with a half-circle driveway, central garden beds, and the home's signature red exterior, an homage to its schoolhouse roots. Just moments from award winning schools and an easy commute into Portland, this special property combines timeless charm with today's amenities, offering a rare opportunity to own a piece of Cumberland's history in an unbeatable location.
Single-familyProperty Type
1817Year Built
0.67 acresLot Size
$435Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 garage spacesParking
Listed by John Fitzsimons• Portside Real Estate Group
Own a part of Cumberlands History! 1820's School House that has been completely renovated. All new systems including efficient heat & central air. Open floor plan-kitchen w/ granite & S/S appliances. 1st floor master, hardwood floors-heated 2 car garage.
MREIS #1023214
Jul 18, 2011
Listed
$239,900
$141/sq ft
MREIS #884461
Mar 25, 2008
Listed
$279,900
$165/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$8,682 (+8.3%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2024
$8,017 (+5.0%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2023
$7,637 (+4.5%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2022
$7,310 (+3.2%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2021
$7,086 (+1.0%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2020
$7,017 (+2.5%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2019
$6,844 (+0.7%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2018
$6,797 (+4.8%)
$121,900 + $223,100
$345,000
2017
$6,486 (−2.3%)
$121,900 + $223,100
$345,000
2016
$6,636 (+0.8%)
$121,900 + $241,700
$363,600
2015
$6,581 (+4.0%)
$121,900 + $241,700
$363,600
2014
$6,327 (+48.0%)
$121,900 + $241,700
$363,600
2013
$4,274
$121,900 + $129,500
$251,400
Tax history for 59 Tuttle Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$8,682 (+8.3%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2024
$8,017 (+5.0%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2023
$7,637 (+4.5%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2022
$7,310 (+3.2%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2021
$7,086 (+1.0%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2020
$7,017 (+2.5%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2019
$6,844 (+0.7%)
$121,900 + $222,900
$344,800
2018
$6,797 (+4.8%)
$121,900 + $223,100
$345,000
2017
$6,486 (−2.3%)
$121,900 + $223,100
$345,000
2016
$6,636 (+0.8%)
$121,900 + $241,700
$363,600
2015
$6,581 (+4.0%)
$121,900 + $241,700
$363,600
2014
$6,327 (+48.0%)
$121,900 + $241,700
$363,600
2013
$4,274
$121,900 + $129,500
$251,400
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
0.7 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
1,556
Year built
1817
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Cumberland County
APN
151382
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 27, 2026.
Property details
Parking
Parking Information
Has Garage
Attached Garage: Yes
# of Garage Spaces: 2
Parking Features: Storage Above, Heated, Auto Door Opener, 5 - 10 Spaces, Paved, On Site, Inside Entrance, Off Street
Vehicle Storage: 2 Car, Attached, Auto Door Opener, Direct Entry to Living, Heated, Storage Above