Welcome to your dream home located at 5840 South Middleton Avenue, located in the highly desirable subdivision of Lexington Square. When you talk about craftsmanship and custom-built homes this one saw no expense spared. This home has stunning engineered hardwood floors throughout the dining room, living room, hallways, and kitchen. The kitchen has granite countertops a breakfast bar and under cabinet lighting. Did I mention two pantries? The home has a split floor plan with the master on one side and the other 3 bedrooms on the opposite side of the home. The master bedroom is very large with a California-style walk-in closet, walk-in shower, and nice jetted/ soaking tub. The beautifully manicured and landscaped backyard offers the perfect opportunity to entertain or just sit under the pergola and enjoy that morning coffee. With easy access to 65 Highway, this location allows for convenient access to all the neighboring towns and venues. Come see your forever home.
Single-familyProperty Type
2006Year Built
0.27 acresLot Size
$185Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Kelly Stelling• The Stelling Group
Bought with Bryan Major• Murney Associates - Primrose
Custom quality-built home situated on corner lot in Lexington Square Subdivision. Split bedroom floor plan with 4 bedrooms. Stunning engineered wood flooring throughout the formal dining room, living room, hallway, and kitchen. Spacious kitchen with granite countertops and breakfast bar, granite composite sink, under cabinet lighting, new electric appliances (some stainless), tile back splash, stacked stone wall covering, two pantry cabinets, storage drawers, lazy Susan, and lots of extra storage. The master bedroom is huge with a California style walk-in closet, walk-in shower with tiled shower walls and base, corner jetted tub, granite countertops, double vanity sinks, and recently added shiplap on bedroom accent wall. Additional features include new roof 2019, new guttering 2019, new HVAC 2016, raised ceiling treatments, crown molding, Travertine stone tile, laundry room with folding countertop, cabinets, and shelving for additional storage, solar tube lighting, quality hardware, light fixtures, and faucets, water softener (owned), R-60 insulation, covered patio with extended deck, courtyard area with firepit and fountain, professional landscaping, and inground sprinkler system in the front yard and back. This home is located in SE Springfield with easy access to US HWY 65 and Springfield area retail, parks, recreation, restaurants, medical and more.
Public Records
Nov 1, 2016
Sold
—
SOMO #60056785
Oct 27, 2016
Sold
—
Jun 30, 2016
Listed
$269,900
$114/sq ft
+24
REDUCED $10,000! AND, beautiful new engineered wood floors installed in kitchen, formal dining, living area, and hallway!!! Lovely custom built home situated on corner lot in Lexington Square! Spacious, split bedroom plan boasts 4 bedrooms, along with amenities you would expect like granite, tile, and generous storage. Home is all electric and well insulated ( R-60!), making for extremely reasonable utility expenses! Wide hallways and large walk-in shower can facilitate handicap needs if necessary. Beautiful raised ceilings in several rooms - this home is quality built and ready for a new owner! Quality lighting and plumbing fixtures. Inground sprinkler system. All this and HSA Home Warranty!
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$3,029
$10,450 + $53,640
$64,090
2025
$3,029
$10,450 + $53,640
$64,090
2024
$3,029 (+0.6%)
$10,450 + $53,640
$64,090
2023
$3,011 (+8.9%)
$9,200 + $47,250
$56,450
2022
$2,766
$9,200 + $47,250
$56,450
2021
$2,765 (+3,320.8%)
$9,200 + $41,440
$50,640
2020
$81 (−97.1%)
$9,200 + $41,440
$50,640
2019
$2,787 (+1.3%)
$9,200 + $41,020
$50,220
2018
$2,752 (+1.0%)
$9,200 + $41,020
$50,220
2017
$2,724 (+2.4%)
$9,200 + $40,410
$49,610
2016
$2,661 (+0.9%)
$9,200 + $40,410
$49,610
2015
$2,637 (+4.1%)
$9,200 + $39,370
$48,570
2014
$2,533
$9,200 + $37,110
$46,310
Tax history for 5840 S Middleton Ave
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$3,029
$10,450 + $53,640
$64,090
2025
$3,029
$10,450 + $53,640
$64,090
2024
$3,029 (+0.6%)
$10,450 + $53,640
$64,090
2023
$3,011 (+8.9%)
$9,200 + $47,250
$56,450
2022
$2,766
$9,200 + $47,250
$56,450
2021
$2,765 (+3,320.8%)
$9,200 + $41,440
$50,640
2020
$81 (−97.1%)
$9,200 + $41,440
$50,640
2019
$2,787 (+1.3%)
$9,200 + $41,020
$50,220
2018
$2,752 (+1.0%)
$9,200 + $41,020
$50,220
2017
$2,724 (+2.4%)
$9,200 + $40,410
$49,610
2016
$2,661 (+0.9%)
$9,200 + $40,410
$49,610
2015
$2,637 (+4.1%)
$9,200 + $39,370
$48,570
2014
$2,533
$9,200 + $37,110
$46,310
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
4
Baths
2
Stories
1
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
0.27 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
2,277
Year built
2006
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Greene County
APN
881928201032
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Nov 12, 2026.
R-SF
Single-Family Residential District
This district is intended primarily for single-family detached dwellings at low residential densities of approximately seven units per acre. Certain other structures and uses necessary to serve governmental, educational, religious, recreational, and other needs of neighborhood areas are allowed as permitted or conditional uses subject to restrictions intended to preserve and protect the single-family residential character of the district. Internal stability, harmony, attractiveness, order, and efficiency are encouraged by providing for adequate light, air, and open space for dwellings and related facilities and by consideration of the proper functional relationship and arrangement of the different uses permitted in this district.