Just a short walk to the ocean, THE PLAYHOUSE TOO is the perfect spot to make your Hatteras Island dreams come true! This home’s location can’t be beat—walk to the most famous surfing break on the East Coast, bike to the iconic Cape Hatteras Lighthouse, and explore all the wonderful shops, restaurants, and activities that Buxton has to offer. With rich local history and plenty of modern comforts, this home is a standout for fun, relaxation, and even as an investment opportunity. It brought in over $63,000 in rental income in 2024 and already has bookings lined up for next year. The ground level welcomes you with a game room stocked with all the essentials for family fun—a ping pong table, foosball table, full-size commercial arcade game, and a wet bar with a mini-fridge. Outside, take a dip in the private swimming pool or unwind in the 6-person hot tub. Fire up the grill on the pool deck and enjoy dinner at the built-in poolside bar. This level also features two queen bedrooms—one with a private ensuite bath—and an additional shared full bath for convenience. The mid-level offers plenty of room for everyone, featuring a spacious king bedroom with an ensuite bath and private deck access. A queen bedroom and a bunk bedroom share a full hall bath, providing comfort and convenience for family and guests. On the top level, the open and airy great room serves as the heart of the home, with a well-appointed kitchen featuring a breakfast bar and an adjacent dining area. Step into the screened porch with its picnic table for a relaxed dining experience, or head out to the deck to take in the fresh ocean air and stunning coastal views. The crow’s nest above the screened porch is the perfect spot to enjoy panoramic views of the ocean and the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse. Whether you’re starting your morning with a cup of coffee or ending your day under a canopy of stars, this space is sure to impress. Beyond the property, Buxton is full of adventures waiting to be had. Treat yourself to delicious ice cream, grab a bite at one of the local restaurants, visit the arcade, or explore the historic lighthouse. With shops and amenities just a short walk or bike ride away, there’s always something to do. Whether you're relaxing by the pool, enjoying fun-filled game nights, or exploring all that Buxton has to offer, THE PLAYHOUSE TOO is a place where memories are made. Don’t miss your chance to own this little piece of paradise in Buxton!
Single-familyProperty Type
2002Year Built
10,000 sq ftLot Size
$277Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listed by Trisha Midgett & Team• Midgett Realty - Rodanthe
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.
Earn from this home
Rent
$3,773/mo
Redfin rental estimate
List your home for rent
Market trends in 27920, NC
Last updated October 2026
Buyer's Market
Seller's Market
Balanced market
Sale-to-list price
97.4%
+0.1% MoM
Median sale price
$420K
$15K MoM
Avg. days on market
171d
59 days MoM
Recently sold homes
5
1 MoM
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 46244 Old Lighthouse Rd Lot 53
Date
Event
Price
OBMLS #127954
Feb 26, 2025
Relisted
—
Feb 26, 2025
Sold
$664,000
$263/sq ft
Jan 31, 2025
Contingent
—
Jan 18, 2025
Listed
$674,999
$268/sq ft
OBMLS #108644
Feb 12, 2021
Sold
$462,500
$184/sq ft
Mar 4, 2020
Listed
$483,000
$192/sq ft
+28
This solid rental performer of 10.88% ROI delivers. The Playhouse Too is a classic beach cottage in a nostalgic Buxton seaside location. This oceanside community proudly boasts stunning beaches with world-class surf fishing at Cape Point in one of the most coveted, uncrowded locations on Hatteras Island with village shopping and food eateries down the street. Just imagine having the best of neighborhood playmates, the Atlantic Ocean and the Pamlico Sound, just minutes away for those long beach walks and all-day water fun. From sunrise to sunset, the breathtaking views of both the ocean and sound can be yours every day. Decking galore, a screened-in porch and a Crow’s Nest too will maximize your ability to stay connected to the salty smell of ocean breezes. The resort-like backyard pool with wooden decking and a hot tub is an irresistible escape for lasting entertainment. This three-story five bedroom cottage with two master suites will easily accommodate your vacay buddies. The first-floor bunk room will be a definite fav for teenagers and adults alike who might want to stay up a bit later than normal. Other mentionables include: open concept living, dining and kitchen reverse floor plan; a huge, first-floor game room with wet bar and a roomy outside shower. Also worth talking about is the Buxton Beach Nourishment Program to begin 2022.
As the MLS and public records start to fill up, we'll list the details here.