If you’ve been searching for space, privacy, and a property that truly lets you spread out, this one is worth a closer look. Situated on 4.97 acres, this property offers the perfect blend of open land and everyday comfort, complete with a pond, barn, and plenty of room for animals, hobbies, or simply enjoying the outdoors. The fully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home with a bonus room has been thoughtfully updated. Step inside to a bright, welcoming interior featuring new laminate flooring, fresh paint, recessed lighting, and stylish new fixtures throughout. The kitchen has been completely reimagined with granite countertops, new cabinetry, a modern backsplash, and brand-new appliances, creating a space that’s as functional as it is inviting. Both bathrooms showcase custom tile work and beautifully tiled showers, along with new vanities, updated fixtures, and LVT flooring that adds durability and style. Behind the scenes, the updates continue with improvements already taken care of for you - including a new septic system installed with permits, a new well pump with updated wiring and pipe, all new plumbing and electrical (both permitted), a new panel box, water heater, exterior siding, gutters, and a crawlspace vapor barrier. With acreage, outbuildings, and a move-in ready home, this property offers the freedom to create the lifestyle you’ve been dreaming about - whether that’s quiet country living, room to grow, or space to make it your own.
Single-familyProperty Type
1960Year Built
4.97 acresLot Size
$215Price/Sq.Ft.
Listed by JESSICA DESHOTEL• BLUE HOME REALTY
Bought with WELCOME HOME TEAM POWERED BY KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY• KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY (FAYETTEVILLE)
Est. $1,346 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 5456 Butler Nursery Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
LPRMLS #757892
Jun 4, 2026
Sold
$332,000
$215/sq ft
Apr 29, 2026
Pending
—
Apr 6, 2026
Relisted
—
Apr 3, 2026
Relisted
—
Mar 6, 2026
Pending
—
Feb 24, 2026
Listed
$330,000
$214/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 31, 1995
Sold
$68,700
$45/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 6, 1987
Sold
$32,000
$21/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$1,811 (+26.5%)
$81,846 + $77,468
$159,314
2024
$1,432 (+2.7%)
$45,947 + $77,706
$123,653
2023
$1,395 (+2.7%)
$45,947 + $77,706
$123,653
2022
$1,358
$45,947 + $77,706
$123,653
2021
$1,358
$45,947 + $77,706
$123,653
2020
$1,358 (+1.1%)
$45,947 + $77,706
$123,653
2019
$1,343 (+3.7%)
$45,947 + $82,853
$128,800
2018
$1,294
$45,947 + $82,853
$128,800
2017
$1,294 (+15.5%)
$45,947 + $82,853
$128,800
2016
$1,121
$45,947 + $82,853
$128,800
2015
$1,121
$44,573 + $74,346
$118,919
2014
$1,121
$44,573 + $74,346
$118,919
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Permits
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
1
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
4.97 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
1,096
Year built
1960
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Cumberland County
APN
0452455158000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Oct 19, 2026.
A1
Agricultural District
This district is designed to promote and protect agricultural lands, including woodland, within the County. The general intent of the district is to permit all agricultural uses to exist free from most private urban development except for large lot, single-family development. Some public and/or semi-public uses as well as a limited list of convenient commercial uses are permitted to ensure essential services for the residents.
Permitted uses
Include but are not limited to:
Agriculture
Gas station
Convenience store
Retail-Grocery
Housing-Group
Housing-Single unit
Housing-Multiple units
Self-Storage / mini-Storage
Bed & breakfast
Medical office
Oct 8, 2026 • Active
Residential renovation/repair/reroof
Remodel
Roofing
May 23, 2024 • Final
Residential electrical
Electrical
Permit history is from public records and may be incomplete or inaccurate. Redfin and its agents make no representations about the property condition or permit status. Buyers should independently verify all information.
Appliances: Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Microwave, Range
Flooring: Laminate, Carpet, Vinyl, Tile
Fireplace Features: None
Room Information
# of Rooms Total: 6
Basement Details: Crawl Space
Exterior
Exterior Features
Patio And Porch Features: Porch, Covered, Front Porch
Building Information
Above Grade Finished Area Units: Square Feet
Below Grade Finished Area Units: Square Feet
Levels: One
Construction Materials: Brick Veneer
Property Features
Waterfront Features: Pond
Property Information
Property Type: Residential
Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Raw Mls Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Lot Information
Lot Size : 0
Lot Size Units: Square Feet
Lot Size Acres: 4.97
Zoning Description: A1 - Agricultural District
Utilities
Utility Information
Water Source: Spring, Well
Sewer: Holding Tank, Septic Tank
Location
Schools Information
Middle Or Junior School: Grays Creek Middle School
High School: Grays Creek Senior High
Location Information
Directions: GPS friendly.
Subdivision Name: GRAYS CREEK
Public facts
Beds: 3
Baths: 2.0
Sq. Ft.: 1,096
Stories: 1.0
Lot Size: 4.97 acres
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 1960
Year Renovated: —
County: Cumberland County
APN: 0452455158000
Home facts updated by county records on Oct 19, 2026
Other
Listing Information
List AOR: Longleaf Pine Realtors
Around this home
Schools
Alderman Road Elementary
Public PreK-5 • Assigned • 2.9mi
4/10
Gray's Creek Middle
Public 6-8 • Assigned • 4.7mi
8/10
Gray's Creek High School
Public 9-12 • Assigned • 4.9mi
7/10
Provided by GreatSchools
Climate risks
1/10 Flood Factor
Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years
4/10 Fire Factor
2% chance of being in a wildfire in next 30 years
7/10 Heat Factor
7 days above 106° expected this year, 16 days in 30 years
8/10 Wind Factor
80% chance of strong winds in next 30 years
1/10 Air Factor
0 unhealthy days expected this year, 0 days in 30 years
Provided by First Street
Historical weather
Fayetteville, NC • 28306
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
51
30
57
37
71
47
79
55
81
62
90
70
93
74
84
69
83
65
74
53
67
46
56
36
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
99/ 100
Exceptional sunlight
Sunscore
This home ranks in the top 7% for direct sun exposure in Fayetteville. There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.
9.6 hrs
6.6 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Estimated sale price
$325,000 – $394,000
Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Plus, you'll save $3,418 in fees.