Listed by Amanda Plecinoga • Keller Williams Realty-Metropolitan. Bought with Your Next Move Realty LLC.
Off Market Jan 2026 for $555K
$662,648
4
bd
•
2 ba
•
3,238
sq ft
222 Old Bay Rd, New Durham, NH 03855
About this home
Steeped in history and timeless character, this remarkable New Durham home, The Berry Pike Farm, tells the story of the town itself. Set in the heart of what was once the original town center, the earliest portions of the house and foundation date back to the 1790's, while the home as it stands today was expanded in 1841. Generations of business-minded, civic-spirited families have called it home, shaping not only the property but the community around it. In the 1850's, its halls rang with music, feasts, and dancing as neighbors gathered here in celebration, and today the preserved murals painted by itinerant artists in the Rufus Porter School style still adorn the walls, a treasure over 150 years old. This 4-bedroom, 2-bath residence offers three levels of living, including a spacious sun-filled living room, separate parlor, dining room, two wood burning stoves, and a large studio space off the barn. The attached three-level barn, an awe-inspiring 50'x60' structure, provides endless possibilities for work or creative pursuits. The home sits on 2.45 acres, including a . 63-acre lot across the road with a two-car garage, once the site of the historic Shadrack Allard Tavern - remnants of its foundation and chimney still remain. With just 7+/- owners over more than 230 years, each a careful steward of its legacy, this one-of-a-kind property offers not only a grand home but also a living piece of New Durham's heritage. Showings begin at the open house, Saturday 9/6/25.
Single-familyProperty Type
1840Year Built
2.45 acresLot Size
$205Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
3 car garageParking
Listed by Amanda Plecinoga• Keller Williams Realty-Metropolitan
Bought with Cathy Levesque• Your Next Move Realty LLC
Welcome to the Berry Pike Farm. Just under 3 acres with two lots of record, this Greek Revival has a beautiful yard bordered by stone walls. Showcased inside the home are stunning murals painted by itinerant artists as well as a ballroom. Plenty of room to entertain on the first floor with a formal dining room, living room and parlor including beautifully refinished hardwood floors. Off of the kitchen is a gorgeous art studio that connects to an enormous barn. In addition to the barn, there is a 3 bay carport and a detached 2 bay garage. Come and see what this historical property has to offer!
PrimeMLS #1
Sep 23, 2015
Price Changed
$369,000
$114/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2024
$7,479 (−2.8%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2023
$7,698 (+11.6%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2022
$6,897 (+0.3%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2021
$6,874 (+5.8%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2020
$6,497 (−12.7%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2019
$7,441 (+1.6%)
$44,900 + $268,800
$313,700
2018
$7,325 (+1.4%)
$44,900 + $268,800
$313,700
2017
$7,221 (+5.2%)
$44,900 + $268,800
$313,700
2016
$6,862 (−8.0%)
$44,900 + $256,600
$301,500
2015
$7,458 (−8.1%)
$80,100 + $256,600
$336,700
2013
$8,114
$107,600 + $253,000
$360,600
Tax history for 222 Old Bay Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2024
$7,479 (−2.8%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2023
$7,698 (+11.6%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2022
$6,897 (+0.3%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2021
$6,874 (+5.8%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2020
$6,497 (−12.7%)
$87,600 + $297,300
$384,900
2019
$7,441 (+1.6%)
$44,900 + $268,800
$313,700
2018
$7,325 (+1.4%)
$44,900 + $268,800
$313,700
2017
$7,221 (+5.2%)
$44,900 + $268,800
$313,700
2016
$6,862 (−8.0%)
$44,900 + $256,600
$301,500
2015
$7,458 (−8.1%)
$80,100 + $256,600
$336,700
2013
$8,114
$107,600 + $253,000
$360,600
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Road Frontage Type: Paved, Public Maintained Road, Public
Road Frontage: Yes
Road Frontage Length: 2125
Other Location Information
Directions: Route 11, turn North on Davis Crossing Rd, House is on the corner of Davis Crossing and Old Bay. At the stop sign, turn left on Old Bay, first house on the right. Use GPS. RE sign in yard.
Block: 0
Public facts
Beds: 5
Baths: 2.0
Sq. Ft.: 2,521
Stories: 3.0
Lot Size: 1.82 acres
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 1840
Year Renovated: 1995
County: Strafford County
APN: 731451
Home facts updated by county records on Aug 5, 2026