Step into this Beautifully Restored Colonial, where character and charm eagerly await your discovery! Begin your journey in the sun-drenched enclosed porch, an idyllic spot to savor your morning coffee or tea. From there, you're welcomed into the spacious living and dining rooms, adorned with gleaming hardwood floors that seamlessly flow into a generous kitchen, full bathroom, and mudroom area leading to a delightful backyard. Upstairs, natural light pours through the windows into the hall where you will discover the second full bathroom. The hall also leads to the oversized primary suite offering ample closet space, while the second bedroom is perfectly sized for comfort. This home boasts two full bathrooms, perfect for those seeking their own space! This home is complete with plenty of storage, featuring a full attic and a walkout basement. The basement features a custom-built workbench, perfect for the craftsman looking to sneak away into their own space or convert it to a cool hangout with backyard access. The options are endless with a bit of imagination! Conveniently located near the beaches, restaurants, and stores, this gem is not to be missed. Make this charming colonial your home and experience its timeless allure! Grass is enhanced
Single-familyProperty Type
1909Year Built
2,880 sq ftLot Size
$353Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listed by Esthermarie Gallicchio• Haines Realty, LLC
•609-467-2020 (broker)
•tammyhaines03@yahoo.com (broker)
Bought with Non Member NON MEMBER• Non Subscribing Office
Step into this Beautifully Restored Colonial, where character and charm eagerly await your discovery! Begin your journey in the sun-drenched enclosed porch, an idyllic spot to savor your morning coffee or tea. From there, you're welcomed into the spacious living and dining rooms, adorned with gleaming hardwood floors that seamlessly flow into a generous kitchen, full bathroom, and mudroom area leading to a delightful backyard. Upstairs, natural light pours through the windows into the hall where you will discover the second full bathroom. The hall also leads to the oversized primary suite offering ample closet space, while the second bedroom is perfectly sized for comfort. This home boasts two full bathrooms, perfect for those seeking their own space! This home is complete with plenty of storage, featuring a full attic and a walkout basement. The basement features a custom-built workbench, perfect for the craftsman looking to sneak away into their own space or convert it to a cool hangout with backyard access. The options are endless with a bit of imagination! Conveniently located near the beaches, restaurants, and stores, this gem is not to be missed. Make this charming colonial your home and experience its timeless allure! Grass is enhanced
MOMLS #22509830
Jun 24, 2025
Sold
$520,000
$350/sq ft
May 1, 2025
Pending
—
Apr 13, 2025
Listed
$449,999
$303/sq ft
Apr 6, 2025
Coming Soon
$449,999
$303/sq ft
+37
Step into this beautifully restored Colonial, where character & charm await your discovery! Begin your journey in the sun-drenched enclosed porch, an idyllic spot for morning coffee or tea. From there, you're welcomed into spacious living & dining rooms with gleaming hardwood floors that flow into a generous kitchen, full bathroom, & mudroom leading to a delightful backyard. Upstairs, natural light pours into the hall, leading to the second full bathroom & oversized primary suite with ample closet space. The second bedroom is perfectly sized for comfort. This home boasts two full bathrooms, ideal for those seeking their own space! Complete with plenty of storage, full attic & walkout basement with endless Possibilities! Step into this Beautifully Restored Colonial, where character and charm eagerly await your discovery! Begin your journey in the sun-drenched enclosed porch, an idyllic spot to savor your morning coffee or tea. From there, you're welcomed into the spacious living and dining rooms, adorned with gleaming hardwood floors that seamlessly flow into a generous kitchen, full bathroom, and mudroom area leading to a delightful backyard. Upstairs, natural light pours through the windows into the hall where you will discover the second full bathroom. The hall also leads to the oversized primary suite offering ample closet space, while the second bedroom is perfectly sized for comfort. This home boasts two full bathrooms, perfect for those seeking their own space! This home is complete with plenty of storage, featuring a full attic and a walkout basement. The basement features a custom-built workbench, perfect for the craftsman looking to sneak away into their own space or convert it to a cool hangout with backyard access. The options are endless with a bit of imagination! Conveniently located near the beaches, restaurants, and stores, this gem is not to be missed. Make this charming colonial your home and experience its timeless allure! Grass is enhanced
BRIGHT MLS #NJMM2003494
Jun 24, 2025
Sold
$520,000
$350/sq ft
May 17, 2025
Pending
—
May 1, 2025
Pending
—
May 1, 2025
Listing Removed
—
Apr 25, 2025
Contingent
—
Apr 13, 2025
Listed
$449,999
$303/sq ft
Mar 27, 2025
Coming Soon
$449,999
$303/sq ft
Public Records
Jun 4, 2020
Sold
$245,563
$165/sq ft
MOMLS #22007223
Apr 29, 2020
Sold
$245,563
$165/sq ft
Mar 25, 2020
Contingent
—
Mar 23, 2020
Pending
—
Feb 20, 2020
Listed
$250,000
$168/sq ft
MOMLS #21543136
Feb 13, 2016
Delisted
—
Nov 14, 2015
Listed
$220,000
$148/sq ft
MOMLS #21529606
Nov 11, 2015
Delisted
—
Oct 9, 2015
Price Changed
$220,000
$148/sq ft
Jul 30, 2015
Listed
$225,000
$151/sq ft
MOMLS #21515810
Jul 26, 2015
Delisted
—
Apr 27, 2015
Listed
$225,000
$151/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 17, 2008
Sold
$205,000
$138/sq ft
Public Records
Jan 24, 2008
Sold
$178,500
$120/sq ft
Public Records
Nov 13, 1996
Sold
$84,000
$57/sq ft
Public Records
Jan 10, 1989
Sold
$98,000
$66/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$7,482 (+6.6%)
$217,100 + $234,600
$451,700
2024
$7,017 (+1.6%)
$197,300 + $178,300
$375,600
2023
$6,906 (+5.6%)
$169,500 + $169,500
$339,000
2022
$6,538 (+4.3%)
$154,100 + $160,100
$314,200
2021
$6,270 (−2.9%)
$134,000 + $139,100
$273,100
2020
$6,457 (+3.5%)
$124,100 + $124,300
$248,400
2019
$6,241 (−1.6%)
$118,800 + $135,100
$253,900
2018
$6,341 (+6.1%)
$113,800 + $132,000
$245,800
2017
$5,978 (+4.4%)
$115,400 + $113,900
$229,300
2016
$5,725 (+3.5%)
$115,400 + $113,900
$229,300
2015
$5,534 (+12.2%)
$115,400 + $106,100
$221,500
2014
$4,933 (−5.0%)
$75,400 + $116,400
$191,800
2013
$5,195 (+2.5%)
$75,400 + $116,400
$191,800
2012
$5,067 (+1.2%)
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
2011
$5,007 (+0.9%)
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
2010
$4,963 (+1.7%)
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
2009
$4,882
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
Tax history for 58 3rd St
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$7,482 (+6.6%)
$217,100 + $234,600
$451,700
2024
$7,017 (+1.6%)
$197,300 + $178,300
$375,600
2023
$6,906 (+5.6%)
$169,500 + $169,500
$339,000
2022
$6,538 (+4.3%)
$154,100 + $160,100
$314,200
2021
$6,270 (−2.9%)
$134,000 + $139,100
$273,100
2020
$6,457 (+3.5%)
$124,100 + $124,300
$248,400
2019
$6,241 (−1.6%)
$118,800 + $135,100
$253,900
2018
$6,341 (+6.1%)
$113,800 + $132,000
$245,800
2017
$5,978 (+4.4%)
$115,400 + $113,900
$229,300
2016
$5,725 (+3.5%)
$115,400 + $113,900
$229,300
2015
$5,534 (+12.2%)
$115,400 + $106,100
$221,500
2014
$4,933 (−5.0%)
$75,400 + $116,400
$191,800
2013
$5,195 (+2.5%)
$75,400 + $116,400
$191,800
2012
$5,067 (+1.2%)
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
2011
$5,007 (+0.9%)
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
2010
$4,963 (+1.7%)
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
2009
$4,882
$115,400 + $116,400
$231,800
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
2
Baths
2
Stories
2
Lot width
32 ft.
Lot depth
90 ft.
Lot size
2,879 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
1,176
Year built
1909
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Monmouth County
APN
2400082 00004
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 16, 2026.
RA
Residential District A
The predominant housing type in Keyport has been the one-family house. The purpose of this section is to preserve and continue this low- to moderate-density land use characteristic and those existing single-family residences as the preferred residential land use throughout the Borough. All single-family homes existing in the RA zone are envisioned to be maintained as such and it is strongly discouraged that any of these homes be converted to multifamily.