Set on a quiet, tree-lined street in Maplewood's enviable College Hill neighborhood, this house has the easy warmth and enduring character of a place made for settling in. Thoughtfully updated, while retaining its original character, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home feels gracious without being too formal and polished without losing its charm. Gleaming hardwood floors, abundant natural light and period details make it especially inviting. The first floor flows from a spacious living room with a stone gas fireplace to a peaceful sunroom, inviting dining room, and refreshed kitchen with open sightlines and cheerful breakfast-bar seating. Upstairs are three comfortable bedrooms and a renovated hall bath with a double vanity. The private third-floor suite feels like a retreat, with a marble bath, radiant heat, walk-in closet and room to serve as a primary bedroom, guest suite or tucked-away office. The finished lower level adds flexible space for play, work or exercise, plus laundry and storage. Outside, the level, fully- fenced yard and stone patio create an ideal setting for playtime, pets, and relaxing evenings outdoors. A detached two-car garage provides storage, while thoughtful updates to the home's systems bring everyday comfort and peace of mind. Just 500 feet from the Maplewood Jitney, close to Maplecrest Park and the library, and less than a mile from Memorial Park, the Village, and the NJ Transit metro station, this is a house with heart, ready to feel like home.
College Hill, located between South Orange Avenue and I-78, is a residential and hillside Vauxhall neighborhood with leafy side streets and a commuter-leaning layout. The neighborhood’s character concentrates around the South Orange Avenue corridor near Vauxhall Road, where corner storefronts, takeout counters, and everyday services set a steady street rhythm. Housing reads as mid-century splits and capes mixed with older colonials, with driveways and small front lawns shaping the streetscape. Seton Hall University and its Walsh Library lend a collegiate edge just up the road. For culture, the South Orange Performing Arts Center and the Baird Community Center anchor nearby calendars. Branch Brook Park’s paths and cherry trees add a big-landscape counterpoint to the compact blocks.
Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic
Market insights
10 Colgate Rd · $1,175,000
DAYS ON MARKET
9 days
The average home goes pending in 29 days.
SALE-TO-LIST
106.1%
Most homes are selling 6% above list price.
LIST PRICE
$1,175,000
Median sale price in this area is $725,999. (38% lower than this home)
PRICE DROP
0 price drops
10% of homes in this area have had a price drop in the past month.
Property details
Interior
Exterior
Finance
Kitchen
Bathroom
Bedroom
Living
Dining
Interior features
Carbon monoxide detector
Smoke detector
Drapes and shades
Finished (partially) full basement
Sump pump
Water softener (owned)
Gas water heater
Gas fireplace in living room
Bedrooms
Primary suite with full bath and walk-in closet
One third-floor bedroom (23x18)
Three second-floor bedrooms (11x21; 12x1; 13x7)
Bathrooms
Two full bathrooms
One half bathroom
Primary bath with stall shower
Kitchen
Breakfast bar
Gas range/oven
Microwave
Dishwasher
Garbage disposal
Refrigerator
Kitchen exhaust fan
Laundry & utility
Washer and dryer
Laundry room in basement
Utility and storage rooms in basement
Flooring
Wood floors
Tile floors
Heating & cooling
Steam radiator heating (natural gas)
Central air
Ductless split AC
Exterior features
Open porch(es)
Patio
Wood fence
Level lot
Home design
Colonial/Tudor style
Brick and wood exterior
Brick/gray color
Parking
Detached garage with garage door opener (2-car)
Blacktop driveway
Total of 4 off-street parking spaces
Construction
Asphalt shingle roof
Approximate year built
Utilities
Public water
Public sewer (sewer charge extra)
Electric service
Natural gas service
Garbage with extra charge
HOA & community
Pets allowed
Electricity and solar
View estimated energy costs and solar savings for this home
Set on a quiet, tree-lined street in Maplewood's enviable College Hill neighborhood, this house has the easy warmth and enduring character of a place made for settling in. Thoughtfully updated, while retaining its original character, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home feels gracious without being too formal and polished without losing its charm. Gleaming hardwood floors, abundant natural light and period details make it especially inviting. The first floor flows from a spacious living room with a stone gas fireplace to a peaceful sunroom, inviting dining room, and refreshed kitchen with open sightlines and cheerful breakfast-bar seating. Upstairs are three comfortable bedrooms and a renovated hall bath with a double vanity. The private third-floor suite feels like a retreat, with a marble bath, radiant heat, walk-in closet and room to serve as a primary bedroom, guest suite or tucked-away office. The finished lower level adds flexible space for play, work or exercise, plus laundry and storage. Outside, the level, fully- fenced yard and stone patio create an ideal setting for playtime, pets, and relaxing evenings outdoors. A detached two-car garage provides storage, while thoughtful updates to the home's systems bring everyday comfort and peace of mind. Just 500 feet from the Maplewood Jitney, close to Maplecrest Park and the library, and less than a mile from Memorial Park, the Village, and the NJ Transit metro station, this is a house with heart, ready to feel like home.
GSMLS #3940556
Feb 26, 2025
Sold
$1,252,000
Jan 16, 2025
Pending
—
Jan 8, 2025
Listed
$1,075,000
GSMLS #2720315
Dec 18, 2009
Sold
$460,000
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$21,760 (+3.8%)
$393,000 + $513,300
$906,300
2024
$20,963 (+0.5%)
$393,000 + $513,300
$906,300
2023
$20,853 (+2.6%)
$393,000 + $513,300
$906,300
2022
$20,334 (+5.8%)
$310,000 + $266,700
$576,700
2021
$19,218 (+2.9%)
$310,000 + $266,700
$576,700
2020
$18,673 (+3.0%)
$310,000 + $252,100
$562,100
2019
$18,133 (+9.6%)
$310,000 + $252,100
$562,100
2018
$16,542 (+3.1%)
$310,000 + $252,100
$562,100
2017
$16,047 (+10.8%)
$310,000 + $216,300
$526,300
2016
$14,482 (+4.6%)
$310,000 + $216,300
$526,300
2014
$13,849 (+1.8%)
$237,500 + $155,500
$393,000
2013
$13,598 (+2.5%)
$237,500 + $155,500
$393,000
2012
$13,270 (+2.7%)
$237,500 + $155,500
$393,000
2011
$12,924 (+15.2%)
$260,000 + $156,500
$416,500
2010
$11,217 (+4.7%)
$260,000 + $156,500
$416,500
2009
$10,718
$121,800 + $108,200
$230,000
Public record
Beds
—
Baths
—
Stories
2
Lot width
50 ft.
Lot depth
120 ft.
Lot size
5,998 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
—
Finished Sq. Ft.
2,042
Unfinished Sq. Ft.
—
Total Sq. Ft.
2,042
Year built
1929
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Essex County
APN
1100030 0200050
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 15, 2026.
Climate risks
1/10 Flood Factor
Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years
2/10 Fire Factor
0.00% chance of being in a wildfire in next 30 years
6/10 Heat Factor
7 days above 101° expected this year, 14 days in 30 years
6/10 Wind Factor
27% chance of strong winds in next 30 years
4/10 Air Factor
3 unhealthy days expected this year, 5 days in 30 years
Provided by First Street
Historical weather
Maplewood, NJ • 07040-2808
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
36
23
39
25
56
37
64
45
72
54
82
65
87
69
82
63
78
61
68
49
55
40
40
27
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
92/ 100
Exceptional sunlight
Sunscore
This home ranks in the top 10% for direct sun exposure in Maplewood. There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.
10.1 hrs
5.4 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Redfin Estimate for 10 Colgate Rd
$1,390,985
$216K over list price of $1.18M
Nearby comparable homes
The Redfin Estimate uses 6 recent nearby sales, priced between $1,000K to $1.2M.