This one of a kind ''Nantucket style'' home has always had many admirers & now can be your own dream come true! Situated on a wonderful lakefront property in one of Wanamassa's most charming neighborhoods. Originally built in 1901, but masterfully renovated in 2005 with over 1,000 sq ft in added living space. Quality craftsmanship and woodwork are evident thru-out from the wide plank pine floors to the breathtaking staircase & vaulted ceilings. Stunning waterviews from every room, including the 4 BDS & the very large studio above the oversized 2 car garage. 4.5 timeless baths, 3 fireplaces, gourmet EIK w/butlers pantry, 3 large outdoor decks, new bulkhead, many recent upgrades & on and on! Minutes from the excitement of Asbury's beaches & nightlife, yet a world away! A Truly Special Home!
Luxurious Lakefront Living at ''Heron Point''! Picturesque Shore Colonial w/ a myriad of porches & decks! Features living rm w/ custom built ins & wood stove, formal din rm w/ raised panel woodwork, gourmet kitchen w/ custom wood & glass cabinetry, butler's pantry, family rm w/ gas fireplace & french drs, 4 generous sized bdrms, 3 1/2 baths, full finished bsmt, in-law suite/boathouse & 2 car garage! Wide plank pine flrs, custom millwork, california closets & boise surround sound! A Perfect 10!
Public Records
Dec 2, 2008
Sold
$1,300,000
$311/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 14, 2003
Sold
$420,000
$100/sq ft
MOMLS #2287391
Jul 28, 2002
Listed
$479,000
$114/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$26,189 (+21.3%)
$742,700 + $1,472,000
$2,214,700
2024
$21,583 (−5.2%)
$742,700 + $1,156,400
$1,899,100
2023
$22,762 (+4.3%)
$642,700 + $842,700
$1,485,400
2022
$21,822 (−1.5%)
$642,700 + $819,200
$1,461,900
2021
$22,159
$457,100 + $780,000
$1,237,100
2020
$22,149 (+8.0%)
$457,100 + $649,200
$1,106,300
2019
$20,509 (+3.0%)
$457,100 + $634,500
$1,091,600
2018
$19,914 (+3.3%)
$357,100 + $630,800
$987,900
2017
$19,282 (−4.1%)
$332,100 + $568,500
$900,600
2016
$20,104 (−2.6%)
$332,100 + $568,500
$900,600
2015
$20,639 (+12.9%)
$297,100 + $546,900
$844,000
2014
$18,284 (+3.0%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2013
$17,748 (+2.2%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2012
$17,369 (+1.5%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2011
$17,116 (+2.0%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2010
$16,785
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2009
$16,781
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
Tax history for 23 Wanamassa Point Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$26,189 (+21.3%)
$742,700 + $1,472,000
$2,214,700
2024
$21,583 (−5.2%)
$742,700 + $1,156,400
$1,899,100
2023
$22,762 (+4.3%)
$642,700 + $842,700
$1,485,400
2022
$21,822 (−1.5%)
$642,700 + $819,200
$1,461,900
2021
$22,159
$457,100 + $780,000
$1,237,100
2020
$22,149 (+8.0%)
$457,100 + $649,200
$1,106,300
2019
$20,509 (+3.0%)
$457,100 + $634,500
$1,091,600
2018
$19,914 (+3.3%)
$357,100 + $630,800
$987,900
2017
$19,282 (−4.1%)
$332,100 + $568,500
$900,600
2016
$20,104 (−2.6%)
$332,100 + $568,500
$900,600
2015
$20,639 (+12.9%)
$297,100 + $546,900
$844,000
2014
$18,284 (+3.0%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2013
$17,748 (+2.2%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2012
$17,369 (+1.5%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2011
$17,116 (+2.0%)
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2010
$16,785
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
2009
$16,781
$397,100 + $392,400
$789,500
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
4
Baths
4
Stories
2
Lot width
133 ft.
Lot depth
85 ft.
Lot size
0.26 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
4,186
Year built
1905
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Monmouth County
APN
3700113 00054
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 16, 2026.
C-1
Neighborhood Commercial Zone
The purpose of the C-1 Neighborhood Commercial Zone is to provide retail centers in which will be found the shopping goods and services required to meet the daily needs of residents in the immediate vicinity or neighborhood. It is specifically intended for retail sales and services in the older established areas of the community.