Newly renovated with flawless finishes and flow, this Federal-Style/Greek Revival ensures that modern life is a perfect fit. On a prominent, stroll-to-town corner, this Mercer Hill beauty retains its 1825 charm: lofty ceilings, hardwoods, extraordinary millwork, and 4 restored wood-burning fireplaces. Modern details bring this entertainer's paradise right into today: CAT6 cable for high speed internet, air conditioning, an automatic gas generator and more. Adorned with a pair of marble fireplaces, the living and dining rooms lead right into a previously renovated kitchen, featuring a honed granite island, skylit breakfast nook, and an added pantry. A sheltered back terrace and a slate patio set in manicured gardens create an outdoor haven that belies the nearby bustle of town. There's so much flexibility in the 2nd floor's new master bedroom and bath, which now overlook the garden, a fireside, front-of-house room ready to be a bedroom, sitting room, or library, and a top floor suite, loft, and full bath. Redone walk-out lower level, 2-bay garage. Some photos are virtually staged.
TownhomeProperty Type
1825Year Built
5,942 sq ftLot Size
2 car garageParking
Listed by Maura Mills• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Princeton
•609-921-1050 (broker)
•info@callawayhenderson.com (broker)
Bought with Robin McCarthy Froehlich• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Princeton
Proudly set on a prominent corner in historic Mercer Hill, this fine Federal-Style/Greek Revival built by Charles Steadman (1790 - 1868) Princeton architect-builder is an exquisite balance of original charm and modern day comforts, thanks to period 1830 detail, recent renovations, and a stroll-to-town location. Hardwoods flow throughout, as marble fireplaces, lofty ceilings, and acorn leaf millwork adorn the living and dining rooms. The jewel of the home is the recently renovated, eat-in kitchen, anchored by a pull-up counter of honed granite, as stainless and marble gleam alongside a skylit breakfast nook with built-ins and a matching wet bar. A sheltered back terrace inspires with views of manicured gardens, a slate patio and fenced back-yard. With incredible storage, a walk-out lower level includes a half bath, great room with the original kitchen fireplace, and a charming new mudroom/laundry/craft room. A new full bath graces the landing, and then it's upstairs to 2 bedrooms: one wrapped in bookcases, and a fireside master suite. The top floor offers a 2nd suite and a loft with a full bath for the younger set. The detached 2-bay garage plus 1 additional parking space directly in front of the garage, is unique to in-town living. Located a block from Princeton's main street; Nassau Street, with Princeton University, restaurants, shops, Princeton Art Museum and more. Just a short stroll to Richardson Auditorium in Alexander Hall, McCarter Theater, and the Princeton Train Station with the "Dinky" shuttle to Princeton Junction Train Station.
Public Records
Jan 28, 2005
Sold
$996,000
BRIGHT MLS #NJME133652
Oct 15, 2004
Listing Removed
—
Sep 6, 2004
Listed
$996,000
Public Records
Aug 9, 1994
Sold
$620,000
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$28,330 (+2.6%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2024
$27,605 (+5.9%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2023
$26,060 (+3.4%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2022
$25,210 (−0.3%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2021
$25,283 (+0.8%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2020
$25,086 (+26.9%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2019
$19,761 (+1.7%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2018
$19,428 (+1.4%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2017
$19,161 (+1.6%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2016
$18,861 (+3.6%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2014
$18,203 (+2.5%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2013
$17,753 (+1.2%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2012
$17,537 (+3.1%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2011
$17,004 (+3.7%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2010
$16,392 (−36.4%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2009
$25,766
$463,000 + $346,100
$809,100
Tax history for 40 Mercer St
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$28,330 (+2.6%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2024
$27,605 (+5.9%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2023
$26,060 (+3.4%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2022
$25,210 (−0.3%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2021
$25,283 (+0.8%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2020
$25,086 (+26.9%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2019
$19,761 (+1.7%)
$528,000 + $508,600
$1,036,600
2018
$19,428 (+1.4%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2017
$19,161 (+1.6%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2016
$18,861 (+3.6%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2014
$18,203 (+2.5%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2013
$17,753 (+1.2%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2012
$17,537 (+3.1%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2011
$17,004 (+3.7%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2010
$16,392 (−36.4%)
$463,000 + $370,100
$833,100
2009
$25,766
$463,000 + $346,100
$809,100
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.