This flawless Princeton home was completely rebuilt in 2014 by longtime local builder Lewis Barber to remain in keeping with the historic feel of the one-way, in-town street, while also maximizing space, light and outdoor enjoyment. If ever there was an ideal spot to sip a drink and soak up the flavor of the friendly neighborhood, this front porch is it! There is also a rear garden festooned with roses and a sky-high deck for times when you seek fresh air in solitude. Inside, a well-planned layout makes great use of space, like a media alcove in the living room and an office behind a pocket door. The nicely sized dining area has gorgeous garden views and an open flow into the kitchen, where dark Caesarstone, open shelving and an Italian stainless steel range with matching hood look timelessly chic beneath a beamed ceiling. A huge walk-in pantry proves that storage was never an afterthought. Hardware throughout is top-of-the-line with striking glass doorknobs. Impactful details like this continue upstairs, where the main suite boasts a naturally bright, custom-organized, walk-in closet and a spotless bath done in a modern-meets-traditional mix. A nearby den adjoins the second bedroom, making it uncommonly spacious and highly flexible. The skylit third floor never fails to surprise and delight! Clever storage is tucked into every corner of a family room/TV lounge with deck access, while a third suite feels like a tree-top escape with its own bathroom and walk-in closet. A garage and private driveway parking are rare amenities in this close-to-everything location. This home is located in the Witherspoon Jackson historical district.
Single-familyProperty Type
1900Year Built
3,484 sq ftLot Size
1 garage spacesParking
Listed by Linda Twining• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Princeton
•609-921-1050 (broker)
•info@callawayhenderson.com (broker)
Bought with Robin McCarthy Froehlich• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Princeton
The future of Princeton living: right-sizing in town, in style and walk everywhere. Secluded from the hustle and bustle, but only moments from the pulse of downtown Princeton, this striking home has been beautifully rebuilt from top to bottom under the stewardship of master builder, Lewis Barber. Skylights and new windows fill 3 floors with natural light, illuminating quality finishes and elegant, efficient details like pocket doors with figured glass and fine custom cabinetry. The 1st level is composed of an inviting living room, study with built-ins, and a spectacular eat-in kitchen overlooking the delightful garden and 1-car garage, and boasting the original beamed ceiling, Caesarstone counters with matching cabinetry, walk-in pantry, and a Bertazzoni range, prized for its superb cooking precision. Four spacious, sunlit bedrooms are served by 3.5 baths featuring custom vanities, Toto toilets and porcelain tile. Perched on the 3rd level is a lovely family room with built-ins and terrace.
TREND #6213156
Nov 20, 2013
Sold
$290,000
Oct 1, 2013
Pending
—
Sep 30, 2013
Sold
$290,000
Aug 15, 2013
Pending
—
May 6, 2013
Price Changed
$314,900
May 4, 2013
Listed
$324,900
BRIGHT MLS #1003435906
Nov 20, 2013
Sold
$290,000
Aug 10, 2013
Listing Removed
—
May 4, 2013
Listed
$314,900
BRIGHT MLS #1007227870
Mar 13, 2013
Listing Removed
—
Sep 13, 2012
Listed
$325,000
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$20,571 (+3.4%)
$240,000 + $512,700
$752,700
2024
$19,903 (+5.9%)
$240,000 + $512,700
$752,700
2023
$18,790 (+3.4%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2022
$18,177 (−0.3%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2021
$18,229 (+0.8%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2020
$18,087 (+2.0%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2019
$17,728 (+1.7%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2018
$17,429 (+32.9%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2017
$13,112 (+1.6%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2016
$12,907 (+56.5%)
$205,000 + $365,100
$570,100
2014
$8,246 (+2.5%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2013
$8,042 (+8.0%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2012
$7,444 (+3.4%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2011
$7,203 (−5.8%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2010
$7,646 (+15.1%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2009
$6,643
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
Tax history for 9 Lytle St
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$20,571 (+3.4%)
$240,000 + $512,700
$752,700
2024
$19,903 (+5.9%)
$240,000 + $512,700
$752,700
2023
$18,790 (+3.4%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2022
$18,177 (−0.3%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2021
$18,229 (+0.8%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2020
$18,087 (+2.0%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2019
$17,728 (+1.7%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2018
$17,429 (+32.9%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2017
$13,112 (+1.6%)
$240,000 + $507,400
$747,400
2016
$12,907 (+56.5%)
$205,000 + $365,100
$570,100
2014
$8,246 (+2.5%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2013
$8,042 (+8.0%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2012
$7,444 (+3.4%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2011
$7,203 (−5.8%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2010
$7,646 (+15.1%)
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
2009
$6,643
$205,000 + $172,400
$377,400
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.