Whether you seek a quaint cottage in the country or a year-round sanctuary away from city life, this colonial gem offers the perfect blend of charm, comfort, and natural beauty on over five acres surrounded by million-dollar estates and preserved land. Here is your very own hidden treasure! Hundreds of hellebores and daffodils surround the 1850s cottage with a Williamsburg replica addition and rehab, complementing a carefully planted garden, with staggered plantings offering beautiful flowers and color from Spring to Fall. A fenced garden oasis with a stone-walled courtyard and a frog pond greet you with a chorus of amphibians and birds. Cross the open lawn to a moss-lined path down to your own private waterfall as the property includes over 600 feet of frontage on the Wickecheoke Creek and falls! Inside, the living room features a stunning wood-fired cook stove, where you can tend a fire or even bake bread. Your favorite recipes will come to life in the renovated kitchen with copper-topped cabinetry and loads of charm. Above, a convenient home office provides a welcome space for work or hobbies. Adjacent to the kitchen, are a powder room and the dining room. A cozy library, complete with built-ins and an exposed stone wall, will be loved by book lovers. Upstairs, two bedrooms and a full bath promise restful sleep. This home is within easy commuting distance to NYC and Philadelphia! The outbuildings are being sold as-is.
Single-familyProperty Type
1850Year Built
5.5 acresLot Size
2 car garageParking
Listed by Andrea Mergentime• Callaway Henderson Sotheby's Int'l-Lambertville
•609-397-1974 (broker)
•info@callawayhenderson.com (broker)
Bought with Non Member NON MEMBER• Non Subscribing Office
Set in tranquil elegance, along one of the area's most idyllic roads, this endlessly charming historic home has been painstakingly restored and expanded over the years in perfect keeping with its Colonial roots. Bucolic grounds span 5.5 acres and include shore-to-shore and beyond ownership of a portion of splendid Wickecheoke Creek, complete with a private waterfall! Mature forest, open space and lushly planted gardens hark back to the Enlightenment era, when this jewel of a homestead first came to be. The original 19th Century frame dwelling remains intact, while a graceful cottage style expansion effortlessly adjoins, offering added living space and modern convenience. Down to the most minute of elements, the home displays an impeccable attention to detail. The kitchen includes custom cabinetry, copper countertops and period-appropriate design features and leads onward to the sunny dining room with an oversized, deep-set window and petite fireplace. Wide-width wood floors run throughout, including in the handsome library with built-in shelving. The centerpiece of the expansive living room is an oversized stone hearth, fit with a wood burning cooking stove. Through Dutch doors, find a lovely covered sitting porch. A half bath completes the first floor. The second level is accessed via one of two sets of pie stairs. One wing holds two bedrooms and a full bath, while a third potential sleeping area is located over the kitchen, and all overlook the splendor just beyond. Back outside, the natural surrounds are accompanied by a wraparound brick and stone patio/courtyard, a koi pond and multiple nooks naturally situated for outdoor leisure and entertaining. A barn is suitable for use as a garage or added storage. Quality upgrades and improvements have been made by the current owners, including a new roof (2011), extensive carpentry and structural work, the addition of a high velocity HVAC system and a whole house generator. With too many special features to list, this enchanting home truly must be seen to be fully appreciated!
BRIGHT MLS #1009519758
Jul 19, 2012
Listing Removed
—
May 25, 2012
Listed
$625,000
Public Records
Jul 6, 2007
Sold
$660,000
BRIGHT MLS #NJHT100260
Mar 23, 2007
Listing Removed
—
Feb 19, 2007
Listed
$660,000
Public Records
Aug 3, 1989
Sold
$10,000
Public Records
Jan 3, 1989
Sold
$340,000
Public Records
Jul 1, 1976
Sold
$62,900
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$11,855 (+4.9%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2024
$11,304 (+2.7%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2023
$11,012 (+3.6%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2022
$10,625 (−0.6%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2021
$10,691 (+0.7%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2020
$10,621 (+2.1%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2019
$10,399 (−0.8%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2018
$10,486 (+1.7%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2017
$10,313 (+0.8%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2016
$10,230 (+1.0%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2014
$10,127 (+2.5%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2013
$9,881 (−8.6%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2012
$10,807 (+1.7%)
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
2011
$10,627 (−0.4%)
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
2010
$10,668 (+0.4%)
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
2009
$10,621
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
Tax history for 16 Old Mill Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$11,855 (+4.9%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2024
$11,304 (+2.7%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2023
$11,012 (+3.6%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2022
$10,625 (−0.6%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2021
$10,691 (+0.7%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2020
$10,621 (+2.1%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2019
$10,399 (−0.8%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2018
$10,486 (+1.7%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2017
$10,313 (+0.8%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2016
$10,230 (+1.0%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2014
$10,127 (+2.5%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2013
$9,881 (−8.6%)
$178,500 + $232,700
$411,200
2012
$10,807 (+1.7%)
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
2011
$10,627 (−0.4%)
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
2010
$10,668 (+0.4%)
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
2009
$10,621
$222,500 + $293,100
$515,600
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
—
Baths
—
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
5.5 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
1,373
Year built
1850
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Hunterdon County
APN
0700011 00013
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 14, 2026.
A-2
Lockatong / Diabase Agricultural / Residential Zone
Development in this zone requires residential usage averaging six-acre-minimum lots. Continuing agricultural and woodland use of land shall be encouraged. More specifically, the intent of the A-2 Zone is: To facilitate land use patterns, densities and practices that support local, county and state efforts toward sustaining agriculture; To support the continuation of existing and future agricultural operations by limiting opportunities for nonagricultural land use conflicts and nuisance complaints; To preserve prime agricultural soils and soils of statewide importance which are inextricably linked to long-term agricultural productivity and whose agricultural value, once lost, is irretrievable; To offer diverse land use options, and in so doing, support a variety of agricultural pursuits; To provide opportunities for compact development patterns that are a logical extension of existing historic hamlets or similarly configured new hamlets and that result in preservation of farmland and open space; To facilitate land use patterns and practices that avoid environmental degradation, which may in turn threaten public and/or ecosystem health; To maintain residential densities that ensure the protection of drinking water supplies and quality; To ensure adequate recharge areas for new residential lots to protect drinking water supply and quality and provide for future agricultural needs; To facilitate land use patterns, densities and practices that retain woodlands; and To implement the Land Use Plan Element of the Master Plan.