Stunning, custom-designed home with unique architecture and bay views is now available in the highly desirable Cape May Beach neighborhood!! This unique property home is across the street from the entrance to the beautiful bay beach. This area is known for the fabulous sunsets and the natural, uncrowded beaches that are perfect for kayaking, long walks or just relaxing and enjoying the water and abundant wildlife. This light and bright home is open and airy, and it is an impressive space to entertain all of your friends and family. Enter the home from a large front porch to the large foyer that has plenty of space to receive your guests. On this level there are two bedrooms and one bathroom and back deck. The beautiful wood stairs lead to the second level that can be used as a huge master suite or used as currently configured into 2 bedrooms. One bedroom has a gas fireplace and built-in shelving and drawers. This floor also contains a laundry room, a screened in deck, and a huge master bathroom with Jacuzzi tub that was thoughtfully designed with a private water closet. The top level is sun-filled open concept with hard-wood maple flooring throughout, and it contains a dining area, kitchen, t. v. area, and living room, and two decks. Even though it is open, it provides enough separation to allow all to enjoy their own activities. The mature trees reach to this level, and makes it feel like you are in a tree house. The kitchen area has bay views, upscale finishes including granite counters, and stainless appliances. There is a large island that has room for at least 4 people. The dining area is close by and it accommodates a large table for more formal dining. There in another area for relaxing with a television and gas fire place. The front area is a great area to relax and catch up on your day. This level also contains 2 decks that allow enjoyment of the outdoor and one currently contains a natural gas grill. This level also contains a convenient powder room, and a dumb waiter to make transporting food and clothes to other floors easy. Dual-zone air conditioning/heat. Updates include new hardwood flooring in hallway, refinished maple floors, newer A/C, new carpet on ground and second level, and the home has been converted to natural gas heat and city water. This well-manicured neighborhood is two blocks from the 253 acre Cox Creek Wild Life Management area and is also close to shopping and minutes from Historic Cape May. This area is high and dry, so it does NOT require flood insurance. Whether you are looking for a full-time residence or a second home with a well-established summer rental history that generates substantial rental income, make sure that you consider this great property! Come and see why Cape May Beach is the area’s best kept secret!! One owner is a licensed NJ Realtor.
Single-familyProperty Type
1999Year Built
$529Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
Listed by Wendy Christian• REALTY MARK ADVANTAGE
Bought with Stephanie Coffey• COASTLINE REALTY, LLC
PRE-FORECLOSURE -SINGLE FAMILY 4 BEDROOM 2.5 BATH This one needs to be seen to be appreciated. This 3 story home is just steps from the bay and boasts 4 outside decks with unbelievable views. The home has all the modern bells and whistles. open floor plan, 2 living spaces, stepped up kitchen , granite , hardwood floors, 2 fireplaces , large Master suite w/ his / her sink , sitting room. ALL OFFERS CONSIDERED
Public Records
Jun 9, 2004
Sold
$690,000
$289/sq ft
Public Records
Jul 2, 1998
Sold
$50,100
$21/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$9,883 (+2.9%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2024
$9,609 (+1.5%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2023
$9,471 (+3.1%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2022
$9,182 (+3.1%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2021
$8,907 (+1.6%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2020
$8,765 (+2.5%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2019
$8,547 (+2.4%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2018
$8,344 (−0.1%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2017
$8,353 (+1.6%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2016
$8,225 (+6.8%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2014
$7,699
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
Tax history for 516 Mistletoe Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$9,883 (+2.9%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2024
$9,609 (+1.5%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2023
$9,471 (+3.1%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2022
$9,182 (+3.1%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2021
$8,907 (+1.6%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2020
$8,765 (+2.5%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2019
$8,547 (+2.4%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2018
$8,344 (−0.1%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2017
$8,353 (+1.6%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2016
$8,225 (+6.8%)
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
2014
$7,699
$220,000 + $253,800
$473,800
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.