Lovely 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath home located on a quiet street with a large, well-manicured yard, fenced lot, and storage shed with electric. Quick access to Hayes Highschool, U. S. 23 and downtown Delaware. Schedule a private showing today! Open House Sunday, 5/1/22 from 12-2.
Single-familyProperty Type
1973Year Built
9,147 sq ftLot Size
$147Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Miranda Lytle• Keller Williams Consultants
•614-394-3376 (agent)
•mirandalytle@kw.com (agent)
•614-932-2000 (broker)
•kayleen@theantrittgroup.com (broker)
Bought with John Mongold• Parker Realty Associates
Ryan Reynolds • Keller Williams Consultants, (614) 932-2000
See all
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 538 Rutherford Ave
Date
Event
Price
CBRMLS #222013326
May 27, 2022
Sold
$317,000
$131/sq ft
May 2, 2022
Contingent
—
Apr 28, 2022
Listed
$294,900
$121/sq ft
Apr 25, 2022
Coming Soon
$294,900
$121/sq ft
CBRMLS #2802481
Mar 3, 2008
Sold
$132,900
$55/sq ft
Jan 31, 2008
Listing Removed
—
Jan 17, 2008
Listed
$129,900
$54/sq ft
3 Bedroom split level home in Hayes Colony needs updating. Good potential with some TLC and your personal touch. Fenced yard w/ shed storage and patio. Being sold 'AS IS'. All buyers must be pre-approved. * * * HIGHEST & BEST OFFERS TIL THURS 1/31 AT NOON! * * *
CBRMLS #2409185
Sep 14, 2004
Sold
$141,500
$58/sq ft
Sep 10, 2004
Listing Removed
—
Mar 15, 2004
Listed
$144,450
$59/sq ft
Large SPACIOUS rooms offered in this 4 level split that has recently been painted and has some new carpets. Fully applianced eat-in kitchen. Family rm. w/ woodburning stove. Updated bathrooms. Partially finished basement. Replacement windows. Storage shed. Fenced yard. 24 hour notice a must!
CBRMLS #84100
May 23, 1997
Sold
$99,200
$41/sq ft
Apr 15, 1997
Listing Removed
—
Jan 11, 1997
Listed
$109,900
$45/sq ft
Public Records
Aug 2, 1988
Sold
$78,000
$32/sq ft
Public Records
Dec 29, 1986
Sold
$75,000
$31/sq ft
Public Records
Jan 1, 1980
Sold
$62,000
$26/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$4,663 (+5.4%)
$18,100 + $75,640
$93,740
2024
$4,426 (−0.2%)
$18,100 + $75,640
$93,740
2023
$4,434 (+25.7%)
$18,100 + $75,640
$93,740
2022
$3,527 (−2.2%)
$13,060 + $51,660
$64,720
2021
$3,606 (−3.5%)
$13,060 + $51,660
$64,720
2020
$3,738 (+11.4%)
$13,060 + $51,660
$64,720
2019
$3,356 (−1.4%)
$11,340 + $41,340
$52,680
2018
$3,403 (+0.9%)
$11,340 + $41,340
$52,680
2017
$3,371 (+20.3%)
$11,340 + $41,340
$52,680
2016
$2,803 (−0.6%)
$9,840 + $37,560
$47,400
2015
$2,819 (−1.6%)
$9,840 + $37,560
$47,400
2014
$2,864
$9,840 + $37,560
$47,400
Tax history for 538 Rutherford Ave
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$4,663 (+5.4%)
$18,100 + $75,640
$93,740
2024
$4,426 (−0.2%)
$18,100 + $75,640
$93,740
2023
$4,434 (+25.7%)
$18,100 + $75,640
$93,740
2022
$3,527 (−2.2%)
$13,060 + $51,660
$64,720
2021
$3,606 (−3.5%)
$13,060 + $51,660
$64,720
2020
$3,738 (+11.4%)
$13,060 + $51,660
$64,720
2019
$3,356 (−1.4%)
$11,340 + $41,340
$52,680
2018
$3,403 (+0.9%)
$11,340 + $41,340
$52,680
2017
$3,371 (+20.3%)
$11,340 + $41,340
$52,680
2016
$2,803 (−0.6%)
$9,840 + $37,560
$47,400
2015
$2,819 (−1.6%)
$9,840 + $37,560
$47,400
2014
$2,864
$9,840 + $37,560
$47,400
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
3
Baths
2.5
Stories
2
Lot width
75 ft.
Lot depth
120 ft.
Lot size
9,017 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
2019
Sq. Ft.
1,838
Year built
1973
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Delaware County
APN
519-311-01-006-000
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Aug 3, 2026.
R-3
Single-Family Residential District
The R-1, R-2 and R-3 Districts are established to primarily permit the development of low density and medium-low density single-family dwellings with a variety of lot sizes to meet different housing needs and characteristics expected by the residents and to recognize different location and land use characteristics in various parts of the City.
Property details
Parking
Parking and Garage Information
Has Garage
Has Attached Garage
# of Garage Spaces: 2
Parking Features: Attached Garage
Interior
Bathroom Information
# of Full Bathrooms: 2
# of Half Bathrooms: 1
Bathrooms Total Integer: 3
Bathrooms Total Decimal: 2.5
Heating & Cooling
Has Cooling
Cooling: Central Air
Has Heating
Heating: Forced Air
Interior Features
Living Area: 2428.0
Flooring: Carpet
Window Features: Insulated All
Interior Features: Dishwasher, Gas Water Heater, Refrigerator
Has Fireplace(s)
Basement: Partial
Has Basement
Exterior
Exterior Features
Foundation Details: Block
Property Information
Property Sub-Type: Single Family Residence
Year Built: 1973
Other Structures: Shed(s)
Building Area Total: 1838.0
Building Area Source: Auditor
Lot Information
Lot Features: Wooded
Lot Size Area: 0.21
Lot Size Square Feet: 9147.6
Lot Size Acres: 0.21
Additional Parcels YN: No
Financial
Tax Information
Tax Annual Amount: $3,605.64
Tax Year: 2022
Utilities
Utilities Information
Sewer: Public Sewer
Water Source: Public
Location
HOA Information
Association Amenities: Sidewalk
School Information
High School District: DELAWARE CSD 2103 DEL CO.
Location Information
Township: None
Subdivision Name: Hayes Colony
Public facts
Beds: 3
Baths: 2.5
Sq. Ft.: 1,838
Stories: 2.0
Lot Size: 9,017 square feet
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 1973
Year Renovated: 2019
County: Delaware County
APN: 519-311-01-006-000
Home facts updated by county records on Aug 3, 2026
Other
Listing Information
Home Warranty YN: Yes
Around this home
Schools
David Smith Elementary School
Public K-5 • Assigned • 1.0mi
7/10
John C Dempsey Middle School
Public 6-8 • Assigned • 0.6mi
8/10
Rutherford B Hayes High School
Public 9-12 • Assigned • 0.7mi
7/10
Provided by GreatSchools
Lifestyle
Provided by Walk Score and Local Logic
Climate risks
1/10 Flood Factor
Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years
3/10 Fire Factor
0.31% chance of being in a wildfire in next 30 years
3/10 Heat Factor
7 days above 99° expected this year, 18 days in 30 years
2/10 Wind Factor
1% chance of strong winds in next 30 years
2/10 Air Factor
1 unhealthy days expected this year, 2 days in 30 years
Provided by First Street
Historical weather
Delaware, OH • 43015
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
30
14
38
21
58
36
67
45
69
50
83
63
86
67
82
61
81
55
68
44
52
36
40
25
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
In this area, properties receive around 8.8 hours in
June and 2.7 hours in December, placing it below the
U.S. average for solar exposure.
8.8 hrs
2.7 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Estimated sale price
$340,000 – $412,000
Reach more buyers when you sell with Redfin. Save up to $3,575 in fees.3 minutes to get started.