Looking for one-floor living near the Sheffield border with space to spread out? This 3-bedroom home in Elyria offers a quiet neighborhood feel with quick access to I-90, schools, shopping, and everyday errands. Morning light fills the main living area, while charming French doors add warmth and character between the living room, hallway, and kitchen. Inside, you’ll find 1 full bath and 2 half baths, 1,232 square feet above ground and another 1,232 square feet below ground! Updated LVT flooring, stainless steel appliances, and a washer and dryer that stay with the home. The fully fenced backyard includes a patio, playset, sandbox, and small shed for extra storage. The full finished basement with a built-in bar and half bath gives you flexible space for a home office, gym, playroom, homeschool setup, craft room, or second living area — with storage still left over. New Roof 2024.
Single-familyProperty Type
1955Year Built
10,454 sq ftLot Size
$200Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Ahren Booher• Keller Williams Elevate
Listed by Erin Chappelle• Keller Williams Elevate
Contact: 440-373-1950
Bought with Sophia Hernandez-Ortiz• Keller Williams Elevate
Est. $1,083 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 537 Randall Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
MLSNOW #5211359
Jun 25, 2026
Sold
$245,800
$200/sq ft
Jun 2, 2026
Pending
—
May 29, 2026
Listed
$240,000
$195/sq ft
MLSNOW #4262591
Apr 29, 2021
Sold
$172,000
$140/sq ft
Apr 20, 2021
Pending
—
Mar 23, 2021
Contingent
—
Mar 20, 2021
Listed
$164,900
$134/sq ft
Mar 18, 2021
Coming Soon
$164,900
$134/sq ft
+30
Look no further than this truly move-in ready ranch home. Enter through the front door into your open concept living/dining area that features modern colors, new carpeting and laminate flooring. Double french doors lead the way into the updated eat-in kitchen with all appliances that remain. Three generous bedrooms along with a full bath are located down the main hallway. On the opposite side of the kitchen, you will find the main floor laundry and a charming half bath. The full, finished basement with classic reclaimed red brick walls is an entertainers dream showcasing a full bar, fireplace , expansive living area and an additional half bath. Finally make your way out to the fully fenced in backyard with koi pond and loads of space for all your outdoor fun. Shadow box fence 2011, Kitchen remodeled 2014, Living room built-ins 2013, vinyl plank flooring 2018. Schedule your showing today.
MLSNOW #1013001
Nov 4, 2020
Price Changed
$59,900
$49/sq ft
Aug 25, 2020
Price Changed
$59,900
$49/sq ft
Aug 11, 2000
Sold
$107,000
$87/sq ft
Jul 18, 2000
Listed
$110,000
$89/sq ft
Dec 24, 1997
Price Changed
$110,000
$89/sq ft
Dec 24, 1997
Price Changed
$110,000
$89/sq ft
Partially Finished Rec Room And Dry Bar In Basement. Nice Ranch With 1st Floor Laundry. Quiet Backyard W/ Pond In Landscaping. Quick Possession, Easy To Show.
MLSNOW #3099339
Jun 4, 2010
Sold
$112,000
$91/sq ft
Jan 23, 2010
Listed
$119,000
$97/sq ft
Public Records
Aug 10, 2000
Sold
$107,000
$87/sq ft
MLSNOW #902408
Apr 13, 1998
Sold
$114,000
$93/sq ft
Feb 18, 1998
Listed
$117,900
$96/sq ft
MLSNOW #837204
Dec 6, 1996
Listing Removed
—
Sep 6, 1996
Listed
$117,900
$96/sq ft
MLSNOW #821683
Jul 30, 1996
Listing Removed
—
May 11, 1996
Listed
$117,900
$96/sq ft
Public Records
Jun 29, 1994
Sold
$101,000
$82/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 29, 1990
Sold
$81,000
$66/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$2,621 (−0.5%)
$11,340 + $44,310
$55,650
2024
$2,634 (+10.8%)
$11,340 + $44,307
$55,647
2023
$2,376 (+0.4%)
$8,988 + $34,608
$43,596
2022
$2,367 (−0.2%)
$8,988 + $34,608
$43,596
2021
$2,373 (+2.8%)
$8,988 + $34,608
$43,596
2020
$2,309 (+2.4%)
$7,644 + $29,428
$37,072
2019
$2,254 (−0.2%)
$7,644 + $29,428
$37,072
2018
$2,258 (+7.8%)
$7,644 + $29,428
$37,072
2017
$2,095 (+2.9%)
$7,840 + $24,609
$32,449
2016
$2,035 (+8.1%)
$7,840 + $24,609
$32,449
2014
$1,883
$7,840 + $24,609
$32,449
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
3
Baths
1.5
Stories
1
Lot width
70 ft.
Lot depth
150 ft.
Lot size
—
Year renovated
1995
Sq. Ft.
1,232
Year built
1955
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Lorain County
APN
0625031111006
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Aug 20, 2026.
R-MD
Residential Medium Density District
It is the purpose of the R-MD Residential-Medium Density District to establish and maintain high quality areas within the City for homes with a medium population density to preserve the existing residential neighborhoods characterized by single household residences.