Step into the timeless charm of this beautifully maintained, architecturally pleasing, colonial home in the heart of Lyndhurst! From the moment you drive down the welcoming tree lined street, you will want to call this home yours! Offering 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths, a first floor half bath, and a wonderful blend of classic character and modern updates, this home is ready for its next chapter! Inside, you'll find hardwood floors, crown molding, an updated kitchen designed for both everyday living and entertaining, and spacious living areas highlighted by a cozy fireplace. The first-floor office provides the perfect work-from-home space or quiet retreat. On the second floor you will find the desirable en suite primary bedroom featuring a beautifully renovated bathroom. A second full bath is shared with the additional two bedrooms. The finished basement, (which includes a THIRD full bath), adds valuable living space, ideal for a recreation room, fitness area, media room, or playroom. Outside, on almost a quarter acre, the meticulously maintained exterior showcases outstanding curb appeal, while the newly refinished deck offers the perfect place to relax, grill, or entertain family and friends. Additional highlights include mature landscaping and a two-car garage for added convenience. Recent capital improvements include the A/C (2026), water heater (2026), roof (2025), Master bath renovation (2025). Additionally a deck restoration (2025), side entrance door (2025), many freshly painted walls and trim work (2026) and much more, make this an amazing place to call your own! Ideally located just minutes from Lyndhurst Park, Legacy Village, shopping, dining, medical facilities, schools, major highways, and so many more. This exceptional home combines the warmth and craftsmanship of a classic home with the updates today's buyers are looking for. Don't miss this opportunity to own a home full of character, comfort, and convenience!
Single-familyProperty Type
1928Year Built
10,454 sq ftLot Size
$169Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Carolyn Corsillo• Keller Williams Greater Metropolitan
Est. $1,627 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 5195 Spencer Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
MLSNOW #5198128
Oct 1, 2026
Sold
$290,000
$169/sq ft
Aug 7, 2026
Pending
—
Aug 5, 2026
Listed
$285,000
$166/sq ft
MLSNOW #1061035
Mar 30, 2023
Price Changed
$159,900
$93/sq ft
Aug 25, 2020
Price Changed
$159,900
$93/sq ft
Aug 25, 2020
Price Changed
$159,900
$93/sq ft
May 14, 2015
Price Changed
$169,900
$99/sq ft
Feb 11, 2014
Price Changed
$159,900
$93/sq ft
Feb 11, 2014
Price Changed
$159,900
$93/sq ft
Apr 10, 1999
Price Changed
$169,900
$99/sq ft
Apr 10, 1999
Listing Removed
—
Apr 10, 1999
Price Changed
$169,900
$99/sq ft
Apr 10, 1999
Price Changed
$169,900
$99/sq ft
Apr 10, 1999
Price Changed
$169,900
$99/sq ft
Apr 10, 1999
Price Changed
$169,900
$99/sq ft
Dec 10, 1998
Listed
$159,900
$93/sq ft
Public Records
Aug 24, 2001
Sold
$166,900
$97/sq ft
Public Records
Jan 1, 1978
Sold
$62,000
$36/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$5,765 (+11.3%)
$13,090 + $61,430
$74,520
2024
$5,178 (+4.1%)
$13,090 + $61,430
$74,520
2023
$4,974 (+0.6%)
$10,220 + $47,530
$57,750
2022
$4,945 (+0.9%)
$10,220 + $47,530
$57,750
2021
$4,902 (+6.7%)
$10,220 + $47,530
$57,750
2020
$4,593 (+10.9%)
$8,370 + $38,960
$47,330
2019
$4,140 (+0.5%)
$8,370 + $38,960
$47,330
2018
$4,118 (−1.9%)
$8,370 + $38,960
$47,330
2017
$4,198 (+0.8%)
$8,330 + $36,020
$44,350
2016
$4,166 (+3.8%)
$8,330 + $36,020
$44,350
2015
$4,014 (−1.3%)
$8,330 + $36,020
$44,350
2014
$4,067
$8,510 + $36,750
$45,260
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Permits
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
2
Lot width
50 ft.
Lot depth
205 ft.
Lot size
10,250 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
1972
Sq. Ft.
1,716
Year built
1928
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Cuyahoga County
APN
71211040
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 9, 2026.
10,000 SF SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT
10,000 Square Foot Single-Family District
The purposes of this chapter are as follows: To provide for single-family residential uses where they are compatible with existing residential development within the City
Permitted uses
Include but are not limited to:
Housing-Single unit
Housing-Other
Jul 23, 2026 • Final
Hvac
HVAC
Feb 2, 2026 • Final
Plumbing
Work on a water heater.
Plumbing
Water heater
Permit history is from public records and may be incomplete or inaccurate. Redfin and its agents make no representations about the property condition or permit status. Buyers should independently verify all information.