Don't miss this charming 3 bed 1.5 bath Lyndhurst Colonial. This home, clean as a whistle, has been lived in and cared for and is now ready for a new owner. Lovely stone facade, quality concrete driveway, bay window and newer front door boasts traditionally stunning curb appeal. Entering the home, the main living space is cozy, hardwood floors, fireplace & mantel, window treatments and a neutral color palette. The kitchen has newer cabinetry, granite countertops, built-in breakfast area, stainless steel appliances, newer fridge and microwave (2021). Good sized dining area with access to the 3 seasons room and rear deck recently painted and some boards replaced (2024). A half bath off the kitchen and basement access round out the first level. Upstairs, three bedrooms and full bath all recently painted (2019), the oversized primary bedroom is bright, plenty of natural light and has a bonus room, perfect home office for the remote worker. Cozy third bedroom was re-insulated (walls, ceiling, floors) for winter warmth. The lower level was recently updated with new flooring on the steps, carpet and paint (2021) perfect for kids play area, fitness space, etc and new sump pump (2024). Don't miss this lovely home, the current owners have taken great care of it for the last 5 years, any new owner will appreciate it.
Single-familyProperty Type
1950Year Built
7,104 sq ftLot Size
$197Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 car garageParking
Listed by Jeffrey Longo• Keller Williams Greater Metropolitan
Pristine! ~this right size colonial home features three bedrooms one and a half baths. As you enter through the front foyer the eye is drawn to gleaming hardwood floors and a beautifully renovated kitchen. A three season sunroom off of the dining room allows you direct access to a large deck and a well manicured backyard. Upstairs you find two large bedrooms a huge master bedroom with nursery and walk up attic access as well as a full bathroom. The home features a finished rec room in the lower level laundry and systems room and a vast amount of storage. This home boasts traditionally stunning curb appeal, with stone, brick and wood accents. It is very conveniently located just north of Mayfield road in the bustling community of Lyndhurst.
MLSNOW #2346977
May 31, 2007
Sold
$157,500
$126/sq ft
Jan 18, 2007
Listed
$159,900
$128/sq ft
Beautifully Updated 3bdrm, 1 1/2 Bath Colonial Featuring Dr, Lr W/ Marble Accented Wbfp, Updated Kit W/ Breakfast Nook, Finished Rec Room, Refinished Hdwd Flrs, Updated Baths & Bonus Office Off Master. Walkup 3rd Floor, Sun Room Overlooking Backyard. Newer Windows, Furnace, Roof, Drive, Gutters, Elec & More. Just Move I
MLSNOW #2296154
Dec 31, 2006
Listing Removed
—
Jun 2, 2006
Listed
$169,900
$135/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 26, 2003
Sold
$114,000
$91/sq ft
MLSNOW #2070725
Feb 6, 2003
Listed
$129,900
$104/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$5,136 (+11.3%)
$11,590 + $54,570
$66,160
2024
$4,615 (−11.8%)
$11,590 + $54,570
$66,160
2023
$5,235 (+0.6%)
$9,450 + $51,450
$60,900
2022
$5,205 (+0.9%)
$9,450 + $51,450
$60,900
2021
$5,160 (+24.7%)
$9,450 + $51,450
$60,900
2020
$4,137 (+10.9%)
$7,740 + $34,720
$42,460
2019
$3,729 (+0.5%)
$7,740 + $34,720
$42,460
2018
$3,710 (−10.5%)
$7,740 + $34,720
$42,460
2017
$4,147 (+0.8%)
$7,350 + $36,440
$43,790
2016
$4,115 (+3.8%)
$7,350 + $36,440
$43,790
2015
$3,964 (−1.3%)
$7,350 + $36,440
$43,790
2014
$4,017
$7,490 + $37,210
$44,700
Tax history for 5243 Mayview Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$5,136 (+11.3%)
$11,590 + $54,570
$66,160
2024
$4,615 (−11.8%)
$11,590 + $54,570
$66,160
2023
$5,235 (+0.6%)
$9,450 + $51,450
$60,900
2022
$5,205 (+0.9%)
$9,450 + $51,450
$60,900
2021
$5,160 (+24.7%)
$9,450 + $51,450
$60,900
2020
$4,137 (+10.9%)
$7,740 + $34,720
$42,460
2019
$3,729 (+0.5%)
$7,740 + $34,720
$42,460
2018
$3,710 (−10.5%)
$7,740 + $34,720
$42,460
2017
$4,147 (+0.8%)
$7,350 + $36,440
$43,790
2016
$4,115 (+3.8%)
$7,350 + $36,440
$43,790
2015
$3,964 (−1.3%)
$7,350 + $36,440
$43,790
2014
$4,017
$7,490 + $37,210
$44,700
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
3
Baths
1.5
Stories
2
Lot width
49 ft.
Lot depth
145 ft.
Lot size
7,105 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
1981
Sq. Ft.
1,254
Year built
1950
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Cuyahoga County
APN
71121022
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Sep 9, 2026.
10,000 SF SINGLE FAMILY DISTRICT
10,000 Square Foot Single-Family District
The purposes of this chapter are as follows: To provide for single-family residential uses where they are compatible with existing residential development within the City