This beautifully-renovated stone Colonial in one of Wynnewood s most coveted neighborhoods will instantly win your heart and feel like home. Set on a lovely tranquil street and surrounded by lush grounds, the distinctive Main Line jewel features an attached 2-car garage, 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and gracious living spaces for hosting family & friends. Move-in ready with plenty of upgrades, 440 Witley enjoys a harmonious blend of classic charm mingled with the modern luxuries & amenities a discerning buyer desires. Tasteful finishes abound, as do many recent improvements include an incredible new master spa bath & walk-in closet, new mudroom with heated floor, new 2nd floor laundry room, updated lighting & d cor throughout, plus a new hot water heater. Not to be outdone, the incredible newly-finished outdoor living space with a bluestone patio & retaining wall, BBQ & outdoor fireplace has been enhanced with upgraded lighting for just the right ambience. Inside, a gracious center hall entry welcomes you. Through wide airy openings sits a large living room with a showstopper wood-burning fireplace & elegant dining room with wainscoting affording an easy flow for guests. Hardwood floors extend into the spacious eat-in gourmet kitchen where the chef & family will love spending time, appointed with generous custom wood cabinetry, granite countertops & island with seating, and stainless steel appliances including a new dishwasher & 200+ dual-zone wine fridge. The light-filled sunroom with skylights & tile floors provides a perfect place to relax. Both the kitchen & sunroom access the spacious patio, overlooking the manicured yard. Completing the main level is a convenient mudroom & powder room. The highlight of the 2nd level is the divine master retreat, with 2 closets (one a new walk-in) and luxurious new en-suite bath with heated floors, double sinks, a claw-foot tub & glass-enclosed shower. There are 2 more sunny bedrooms with deep closets that share a Jack & Jill bath, plus the laundry room. The 3rd floor is set up for an au-pair, in-law suite, and/or additional bedroom & bath, with tons of storage space. The finished basement with its striking stone wood-burning fireplace is great as a rec room, kids playroom, or hangout for the teens. It gets even better, with a prime location in the award-winning Merion School District, near all amenities like Giant, Whole Foods, Trader Joe s, downtown Ardmore, Narberth & Philadelphia.
Single-familyProperty Type
1935Year Built
9,800 sq ftLot Size
$367Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 garage spacesParking
Listed by Robin Gordon• BHHS Fox & Roach-Haverford
•610-649-4500 (broker)
•wendy.civitella@foxroach.com (broker)
Bought with Lisa Getson• BHHS Fox & Roach-Haverford
Center Hall entry, with formal dining room with Wainscoting woodwork, and expansive living room with wood burning fireplace. The dining room can easily seat 10 with buffet and china cabinet. Kitchen was remodeled in 2006 in a Tuscany style with...
built-in wine cabinet, Bathrooms have been updated. Jack and Jill style bathroom is convenient for two bedrooms on second floor. The master bedroom has two separate walk in closets. Master Bathroom completely modernized and updated with marble look tiles. Third floor is finished to provide a 4th bedroom, with access door to floored attic. Finished basement has been modified to addition of an egress window. Classic flagstone patio and garden landscaping add to home for back yard entertaining.
7 years ago• May not reflect the current state of the home
Jeanette Fontanella
Redfin Associate agent
Sale history for 440 Witley Rd
Date
Event
Price
BRIGHT MLS #PAMC626326
Nov 19, 2019
Sold
$905,000
$231/sq ft
Oct 3, 2019
Pending
—
Sep 25, 2019
Listed
$875,000
$224/sq ft
TREND #6053758
Aug 17, 2012
Sold
$730,000
$187/sq ft
Jul 12, 2012
Pending
—
May 30, 2012
Price Changed
$749,900
$192/sq ft
May 14, 2012
Listed
$795,000
$203/sq ft
+13
BRIGHT MLS #1003441689
Aug 17, 2012
Sold
$730,000
$187/sq ft
May 14, 2012
Listed
$749,900
$192/sq ft
+13
Prepare to be charmed by this meticulously maintained, Wallace & Warner-designed 5 BR, 3 1/2 BA Stone Colonial on a beautiful & tranquil street in Wynnewood's most coveted neighborhood. Reflectng all of the classic richness & enduring quality of the Main Line's finest residences, this home artfully blends the best of 1930's vintage charm with today's modern amenities. 1st Flr features a CH entry, formal LR w/ oversized w-b fireplace, tiled Sunroom, formal DR, PR, Laundry, & fabulous chef's quality Kitchen with granite ct, ss appliances, & custom cabinetry. Lower Level FR off Kitchen has ceramic tile floors & 2nd w-b fireplace. Private flagstone patio accessed from Sunroom or Kitchen overlooks a lush garden. 2nd Flr consists of the MBR, MBA w/ marble floor, 2nd bedroom w/ access to both the MBA & hall which allows it to function as a nursery, study, or private BR, & 3rd & 4th BRs with Jack-and Jill Bath. 3rd Flr consists of 5th BR, full BA, & storage. Hardwood floors t/o. Award-winning Lower Merion Schools.
BRIGHT MLS #1003377089
Jul 14, 2004
Sold
$207,000
$53/sq ft
Nov 12, 2003
Listing Removed
—
Nov 12, 2003
Listed
$207,000
$53/sq ft
BRIGHT MLS #1003377235
May 17, 2004
Sold
$580,000
$148/sq ft
Nov 12, 2003
Listed
$580,000
$148/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$12,641 (+4.6%)
2025
$12,086 (+5.4%)
2024
$11,467 (+4.4%)
2023
$10,989 (+1.9%)
2022
$10,785 (+2.3%)
2021
$10,540 (+2.5%)
2020
$10,282 (+1.8%)
2019
$10,101 (+1.9%)
2018
$9,916 (+1.9%)
2017
$9,729 (+8.4%)
2015
$8,972 (+6.0%)
2014
$8,464
2013
$8,464 (+3.1%)
2011
$8,213 (+4.0%)
2010
$7,898 (+3.6%)
2009
$7,627
Tax history for 440 Witley Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$12,641 (+4.6%)
2025
$12,086 (+5.4%)
2024
$11,467 (+4.4%)
2023
$10,989 (+1.9%)
2022
$10,785 (+2.3%)
2021
$10,540 (+2.5%)
2020
$10,282 (+1.8%)
2019
$10,101 (+1.9%)
2018
$9,916 (+1.9%)
2017
$9,729 (+8.4%)
2015
$8,972 (+6.0%)
2014
$8,464
2013
$8,464 (+3.1%)
2011
$8,213 (+4.0%)
2010
$7,898 (+3.6%)
2009
$7,627
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
5
Baths
3.5
Stories
2
Lot width
70 ft.
Lot depth
—
Lot size
9,800 Sq. Ft.
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
2,915
Year built
1935
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Montgomery County
APN
400066780005
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Aug 5, 2026.
LDR3
Low Density Residential Districts
LDR3 is a low intensity district intended for detached single-family residential homes and the preservation of the existing neighborhood character.