Lakeside Luxury at 5194 S Hamilton Dr, Saylorsburg, PA 18353 3-5 Beds | 2 Baths | 3,100+ Sq Ft | 0.73 Acres | 73 Ft of Lake Frontage | Sauna | Stroudsburg SD Discover your dream home on the peaceful shores of Saylors Lake Fishing Association! This expanded and beautifully renovated lakefront retreat offers over 3,100 sq ft of refined living on nearly 3/4 of an acre with stunning panoramic views. Step into a sun-drenched open-concept layout featuring vaulted ceilings, new wood and tile floors, and an original stone fireplace with a gas insert. The custom new wood-floored kitchen, that boasts granite countertops, a central island, a cozy breakfast nook, and a banquette for extra seating and charm. Enjoy the ease of main-floor living with a spacious primary suite and laundry room on the first level. Upstairs, a sunny enclosed porch with private upper-level deck is perfect for lounging or tanning. The flexible 3-5 bedroom layout offers room for guests, office, or creative space. OUTSIDE SHOWER and the Original Vintage Spring House Year-round comfort is ensured with many mechanical updates: new furnace, hot water heater, central air, oil tank, paint, flooring, kitchen and paved driveway. Unwind in your own sauna, relax on the covered porch, or gather around the lakeside fire pit under the stars. The dual-level deck overlooks your private 73 feet of lake frontage, and the walk-out basement offers storage for your canoe, kayak, or fishing gear. Located in the Stroudsburg School District with quick access to Routes 33 & 80, this home is minutes from skiing, hiking, and shops—yet feels like a secluded resort. Your lakefront lifestyle starts here. Don't miss this rare find!
Single-familyProperty Type
1902Year Built
0.61 acresLot Size
$169Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
1 garage spacesParking
Listed by Tiffanie Bailey-Romey• Bairo Real Estate LLC
'Property is Under Contract & Considering Backup Offers Only at this Time'. Your dream lakefront lifestyle is waiting on the peaceful shores of Saylors Lake Fishing Association! This rare find in the Hamilton Township/Stroudsburg School District offers over 3,100 sq. ft. of renovated living space on nearly ¾ of an acre, with an impressive 73 feet of private lake frontage. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, vacation home, or investment, this retreat blends rustic charm with modern luxury in one of the Poconos' most desirable locations. Step into a sun-drenched open concept design where vaulted ceilings, new hardwood & tile floors & an original stone fireplace with gas insert create a warm, inviting ambiance. The custom kitchen is the heart of the home, showcasing granite countertops, central island, and a banquette dining nook, perfect for hosting friends or enjoying Sunday breakfast with a lake view. The flexible 3-5 bedroom layout includes a spacious main-level primary suite with laundry, while upstairs you'll find an enclosed sun porch, private deck & bonus rooms for guests, office, or creative space. Updates abound: new furnace, central air, hot water heater, oil tank, paved driveway, fresh paint & new flooring. Extra touches like a sauna, outdoor shower, vintage spring house & dual-level lakefront decks make this home truly unforgettable. Outside, entertain on the covered porch, roast marshmallows at the lakeside firepit, or launch your kayak, canoe, or paddleboard right from your own shoreline. Every season is spectacular swim & fish in summer, take in fiery foliage in fall, cozy up by the fireplace in winter & enjoy the rebirth of spring on the water. All of this is just minutes to Routes 33 & 80, with easy access to skiing, hiking, vineyards, restaurants & shopping. Stroudsburg School District adds top-rated education to this unbeatable lifestyle. Your lakefront luxury retreat starts here, don't miss this exceptional value!
GLVRMLS #760166
Dec 4, 2025
Sold
$437,500
$139/sq ft
Nov 11, 2025
Pending
—
Sep 24, 2025
Price Changed
$499,999
$159/sq ft
Jul 24, 2025
Price Changed
$569,998
$182/sq ft
Jun 20, 2025
Listed
$599,999
$191/sq ft
+70
‘Property is Under Contract & Considering Backup Offers Only at this Time’ Discover your dream home on the peaceful Saylors Lake! This expanded and beautifully renovated lakefront retreat offers over 3,100 sq ft of refined living on nearly 3/4 of an acre with stunning panoramic views. Step into a sun-drenched open-concept layout featuring, new wood and tile floors, and an original stone fireplace with a gas insert. The custom new wood-floored kitchen, that boasts granite countertops, a central island, a cozy breakfast nook, and a banquette for extra seating and charm. Enjoy the ease of main-floor living with a spacious primary suite and laundry room on the first level. Upstairs, a sunny enclosed porch with private upper-level deck is perfect for lounging or tanning. The flexible 3-5 bedroom layout offers room for guests, office, or creative space. OUTSIDE SHOWER and the Original Vintage Spring House Year-round comfort is ensured with many mechanical updates: new furnace, hot water heater, central air, oil tank, paint, flooring, kitchen and paved driveway. Unwind in your own sauna, relax on the covered porch, or gather around the lakeside fire pit under the stars. The dual-level deck overlooks your private 73 feet of lake frontage, and the walk-out basement offers storage for your canoe, kayak, or fishing gear. Located in the Stroudsburg School District with quick access to Routes 33 & 80. Your lakefront lifestyle starts here. Don't miss this rare find!
GLVRMLS #578865
Jul 27, 2018
Sold
$325,000
$104/sq ft
Apr 27, 2018
Listed
$325,000
$104/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 4, 2013
Sold
$240,000
$76/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$9,350
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2025
$9,353 (+4.7%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2024
$8,930 (+2.5%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2023
$8,714 (+2.6%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2022
$8,490
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2021
$8,490 (+3.6%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2020
$8,195 (+32.4%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2019
$6,187
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
2018
$6,187
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
2017
$6,187 (+3.3%)
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
2015
$5,990
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
Tax history for 5194 Hamilton S
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2026
$9,350
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2025
$9,353 (+4.7%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2024
$8,930 (+2.5%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2023
$8,714 (+2.6%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2022
$8,490
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2021
$8,490 (+3.6%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2020
$8,195 (+32.4%)
$54,740 + $226,900
$281,640
2019
$6,187
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
2018
$6,187
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
2017
$6,187 (+3.3%)
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
2015
$5,990
$7,040 + $26,110
$33,150
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
3
Baths
2
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
0.61 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
3,140
Year built
1902
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Monroe County
APN
07 12 1 71
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 21, 2026.
C-1
Neighborhood Commercial District
The purposes of the C-1 Neighborhood Commercial District are: To provide convenient, limited areas for shopping and related services within and adjacent to residential neighborhoods, but not to satisfy broader regional commercial needs or serve as an employment center.; To protect adjacent residential land uses and residential zoning districts from adverse impacts of non-residential land use activity.; To provide for the continued stability and, where feasible, additional development of the existing mixed-use village land use pattern in Saylorsburg, Hamilton Township, Pennsylvania, with predominantly small lots for residential structuresand smaller-scale businesses that may be served by public or community water facilities.