Full of character & rich with history, this charming Cape Cod sits on 2.7 acres & was once a church, offering a truly one-of-a-kind living experience. Soaring 18-foot ceilings create an open, airy feel, while the living room fireplace w/ gas logs adds warmth & charm. The side entry opens to a mudroom/office area. Spacious main-level primary suite features a walk-in closet & ensuite bath w/ handicap accessibility. The large kitchen offers butcher block countertops plus stainless appliances and a new dishwasher. Upstairs you'll find a large loft area, 2 additional bedrooms, & 2 bonus rooms. Recent updates include a new water heater, well pump & some plumbing. Metal roof, bricked front porch floor, 2 HVAC units, storage building & chicken coop. Furnishings negotiable with offer.
Est. $2,926 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 4740 Payneton Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
DRRAR #78930
Jul 29, 2026
Sold
$337,000
$93/sq ft
Jul 5, 2026
Contingent
—
Jun 22, 2026
Listed
$339,000
$93/sq ft
DRRAR #67752
Nov 10, 2023
Sold
$300,000
$83/sq ft
Oct 4, 2023
Price Changed
$309,900
$85/sq ft
Sep 21, 2023
Listed
$349,900
$96/sq ft
+29
Don't miss your chance to own this unique Cape Cod on almost 3 acres in a country setting. This 3500sq ft home was once a church and has been transformed into an amazing 3 BR-2.5bath home! You'll love the blend of history and modern luxury with beautiful wood floors, expansive rooms and 18'ceilings in LR. Beautiful front porch with brick floor and wrought iron railings. LR has stone gas log FP; Open concept kitchen/dining room features custom countertops and stainless appliances. Master suite has en-suite bath and walk in closet. Main level laundry. Staircase has amazing woodwork and goes to a Loft; 2 more bedrooms and den/game room and bath. This property is more than a home, it's a piece of Sheva's history!
LMLS #348270
Nov 10, 2023
Sold
$300,000
$83/sq ft
Oct 14, 2023
Pending
—
Oct 4, 2023
Price Changed
$309,900
$85/sq ft
Sep 19, 2023
Listed
$349,900
$96/sq ft
+44
DRRAR #57761
Oct 26, 2018
Sold
$175,000
$48/sq ft
Mar 28, 2018
Listed
$179,000
$49/sq ft
As the MLS and public records start to fill up, we'll list the details here.