Welcome to 126 Lancaster Road, a rare 2.5-acre waterfront retreat in the heart of Irvington, just moments from the acclaimed Tides Inn Resort. This rambling 1940s cottage has been thoughtfully renovated and offers 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, vaulted ceilings, and a spacious living and dining area framed by a wall of glass doors overlooking Carter’s Creek. A detached two-car garage with tool shed includes a guest cottage featuring a fourth bedroom and full bath, perfect for overflow visitors or private office space. The property features a large grandfathered pool within the 100-foot resource protection area, offering an exceptional opportunity to reimagine this outdoor space with a pool house, outdoor kitchen, or other resort-style amenities. The deep-water pier is outfitted with two lifts, power, and water, with over 7 feet MLW to easily accommodate yachts and deep draft sailboats. With frontage on both Lancaster and York Roads, this expansive parcel is one of the few remaining large tracts in Irvington. Mature landscaping and prime water access make it a rare find, offering privacy, convenience, and the potential for future redevelopment. Showings to begin Friday October 3rd.
Single-familyProperty Type
1945Year Built
2.64 acresLot Size
$530Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
2 car garageParking
Listed by Bo Bragg• Bragg & Company Real Estate, LLC.
•804-435-2299 (broker)
•bo@braggco.com (broker)
Bought with Non Member Member• Metropolitan Regional Information Systems, Inc.
Welcome to 126 Lancaster Road, a rare 2.5-acre waterfront retreat in the heart of Irvington, just moments from the acclaimed Tides Inn Resort. This rambling 1940s cottage has been thoughtfully renovated and offers 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, vaulted ceilings, and a spacious living and dining area framed by a wall of glass doors overlooking Carter’s Creek. A detached two-car garage with tool shed includes a guest cottage featuring a fourth bedroom and full bath, perfect for overflow visitors or private office space. The property features a large grandfathered pool within the 100-foot resource protection area, offering an exceptional opportunity to reimagine this outdoor space with a pool house, outdoor kitchen, or other resort-style amenities. The deep-water pier is outfitted with two lifts, power, and water, with over 7 feet MLW to easily accommodate yachts and deep draft sailboats. With frontage on both Lancaster and York Roads, this expansive parcel is one of the few remaining large tracts in Irvington. Mature landscaping and prime water access make it a rare find, offering privacy, convenience, and the potential for future redevelopment. Showings to begin Friday October 3rd.
NNAR #119460
Dec 5, 2025
Sold
$1,649,000
$570/sq ft
Oct 25, 2025
Contingent
—
Sep 30, 2025
Listed
$1,649,000
$570/sq ft
+39
Welcome to 126 Lancaster Road, a rare 2.5-acre waterfront retreat in the heart of Irvington, just moments from the acclaimed Tides Inn Resort. This rambling 1940s cottage has been thoughtfully renovated and offers 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, vaulted ceilings, and a spacious living and dining area framed by a wall of glass doors overlooking Carter's Creek. A detached two-car garage with tool shed includes a guest cottage featuring a fourth bedroom and full bath, perfect for overflow visitors or private office space. The property features a large grandfathered pool within the 100-foot resource protection area, offering an exceptional opportunity to reimagine this outdoor space with a pool house, outdoor kitchen, or other resort-style amenities. The deep-water pier is outfitted with two lifts, power, and water, with over 7 feet MLW to easily accommodate yachts and deep draft sailboats. With frontage on both Lancaster and York Roads, this expansive parcel is one of the few remaining large tracts in Irvington. Mature landscaping and prime water access make it a rare find, offering privacy, convenience, and the potential for future redevelopment.
Public Records
Aug 9, 2010
Sold
$750,000
$259/sq ft
Public Records
Oct 7, 2002
Sold
$692,000
$239/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2024
$5,132 (−9.9%)
$523,800 + $374,200
$898,000
2023
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2022
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2021
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2020
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2019
$5,697 (+1,679.0%)
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2018
$320
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2017
$320 (−90.7%)
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2016
$3,458
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2014
$3,459 (+11.1%)
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2012
$3,114
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
Tax history for 126 Lancaster Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2024
$5,132 (−9.9%)
$523,800 + $374,200
$898,000
2023
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2022
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2021
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2020
$5,697
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2019
$5,697 (+1,679.0%)
$498,800 + $364,400
$863,200
2018
$320
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2017
$320 (−90.7%)
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2016
$3,458
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2014
$3,459 (+11.1%)
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
2012
$3,114
$352,800 + $287,700
$640,500
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.