Welcome to 3439 Colony Mill Rd, Toano, VA, nestled in the desirable Fenwick Hills community. For Sale by Owner — Please call or text 732-870-7699 to schedule a private showing. This beautiful home offers a wonderful blend of space, comfort, and functionality. Rest easy knowing that the roof is new and the AC Units (3 years old) is new as well. Step inside to a bright and inviting two-story foyer that leads to a convenient half bathroom and laundry room. The dining room provides the perfect setting for family gatherings and special occasions, while the spacious kitchen features abundant counter space, ample cabinetry, a pantry, and a sunny breakfast area. The family room offers plenty of space to gather and unwind, complete with a cozy fireplace that creates the perfect atmosphere on chilly evenings. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite features a large bedroom, walk-in closet, and en-suite bathroom with a double-sink vanity, soaking tub, and separate shower. Three additional bedrooms and a full second bathroom provide plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. A large finished room above the two-car garage offers even more flexible living space and can be used as a fifth bedroom, playroom, home office, or whatever best suits your needs. The possibilities are endless! Outside, enjoy an oversized yard with plenty of room for kids, pets, entertaining, gardening, or simply relaxing and enjoying your outdoor space. The pet-friendly Fenwick Hills community is conveniently located near the neighborhood park and playground and offers great schools and a low HOA fee. Don't miss the opportunity to make this beautiful Fenwick Hills home your own! For Sale by Owner. Please call or text 732-870-7699 to schedule a showing. Highlights include: * Spacious two-story home * New Roof * Central Air (3 years Old) * Large finished room above the garage with fifth-bedroom potential * Two-car garage * Oversized yard * Primary suite with walk-in closet and en-suite bathroom * Soaking tub and separate shower * Three additional bedrooms * Two-and-a-half bathrooms * Spacious kitchen with pantry and breakfast area * Family room with cozy fireplace * Convenient laundry room * Pet-friendly community * Neighborhood park and playground * Great schools * Low HOA fee
Median sale price in this area is $548,543. (15% higher than this home)
PRICE DROP
0 price drops
18% of homes in this area have had a price drop in the past month.
Property details
Exterior
Property Features
Year Built: 2006
Living Area: 2639
Public facts
Beds: 4
Baths: 2.5
Finished Sq. Ft.: 2,639
Unfinished Sq. Ft.: —
Total Sq. Ft.: 2,639
Stories: 2.0
Lot Size: 0.29 acres
Style: Single Family Residential
Year Built: 2006
Year Renovated: —
County: James City
APN: 1220600168
Home facts updated by county records on Jul 29, 2026
Sale and tax history for 3439 Colony Mill Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
FSBO.com #cmst70dt600wjs601rg19pxbm
Aug 14, 2026
Listed
$477,000
$181/sq ft
WMLS #2001187
Feb 10, 2022
Price Changed
$119,500
$45/sq ft
Nov 2, 2021
Price Changed
$119,500
$45/sq ft
Nov 2, 2021
Price Changed
$119,500
$45/sq ft
Jul 27, 2020
Sold
$310,000
$117/sq ft
Mar 20, 2020
Listed
$324,900
$123/sq ft
Mar 16, 2001
Price Changed
$324,900
$123/sq ft
Mar 16, 2001
Price Changed
$324,900
$123/sq ft
Mar 16, 2001
Price Changed
$324,900
$123/sq ft
+39
You will love this floor plan! Two story foyer, living room, dining room, kitchen with eat-in area opens to a family room with fireplace! Four bedrooms plus bonus or fifth bedroom! Hardwood flooring, new carpet, garage door and opener - 2 years old, stainless appliances - 5 years old, patio with trellis, quiet neighborhood, easy access to I-64. Subject to a ratified contract with contingencies. Owner wishes to continue to show the property and will consider other offers.
Public Records
Jul 29, 2020
Sold
$310,000
$117/sq ft
Public Records
Mar 4, 2005
Sold
$1,100,000
$417/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$3,435 (+6.4%)
$94,700 + $319,200
$413,900
2024
$3,228 (+18.8%)
$94,700 + $319,200
$413,900
2023
$2,717
$94,700 + $319,200
$413,900
2022
$2,717 (+7.4%)
$72,800 + $254,500
$327,300
2021
$2,530
$72,800 + $254,500
$327,300
2020
$2,530 (+5.0%)
$65,000 + $236,200
$301,200
2019
$2,410
$65,000 + $236,200
$301,200
2018
$2,410 (+1.6%)
$59,900 + $227,000
$286,900
2017
$2,371
$59,900 + $227,000
$286,900
2016
$2,371 (+14.4%)
$59,900 + $222,400
$282,300
2015
$2,072
$59,900 + $222,400
$282,300
2014
$2,072
$59,900 + $209,300
$269,200
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
4
Baths
2.5
Stories
2
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
0.29 Acres
Year renovated
—
Finished Sq. Ft.
2,639
Unfinished Sq. Ft.
—
Total Sq. Ft.
2,639
Year built
2006
Style
Single Family Residential
County
James City
APN
1220600168
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Jul 29, 2026.
R2
General Residential District
The General Residential District, R-2, is composed of certain quiet, low-density residential areas plus certain open areas where similar residential development is likely to occur. The regulations for this district are designed to stabilize and protect the essential characteristics of the district, to promote and encourage the clustering of residential developments to maximize shared and purposeful open space, to protect the natural environment and to promote a sense of community, to limit activities of a commercial nature and to implement the policies and designations of the Comprehensive Plan applicable to low-density residential areas. To these ends, development is limited to low-density residential and permitted uses are limited to dwellings designed to be occupied by one family or more than one family under certain conditions plus certain additional community-oriented uses that serve the residents of the district.
Permitted uses
Include but are not limited to:
Community / recreation center
Housing-Group
Housing-Single unit
Housing-Multiple units
Communications tower
Park & open space
Timberland
Climate risks
1/10 Flood Factor
Minimal risk of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years
1/10 Fire Factor
Unlikely to be in a wildfire in next 30 years
8/10 Heat Factor
7 days above 109° expected this year, 17 days in 30 years
6/10 Wind Factor
62% chance of strong winds in next 30 years
2/10 Air Factor
1 unhealthy days expected this year, 1 days in 30 years
Provided by First Street
Historical weather
Toano, VA • 23168
Average low and high temperatures (°F)
45
26
49
31
65
42
74
51
77
57
87
67
89
72
83
66
78
62
70
49
62
41
49
31
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Sun exposure
93/ 100
Exceptional sunlight
Sunscore
There appears to be minimal shading by surrounding buildings, terrain, and vegetation.
8.9 hrs
5.9 hrs
JuneDecember
Provided by Shadowmap
Redfin Estimate for 3439 Colony Mill Rd
There isn’t enough information to generate an accurate estimate at this time. Learn More