Listed by Diane Jahn-The Diane Jahn Sales Team • FIRST WEBER (homeinfo@firstweber.com). Bought with KPR BROKERS, LLC.
Off market aug 2023 for $360K
$421,550
Est. refi paymentEst. refi$1,612/mo
3
bd
•
2 ba
•
2,406
sq ft
5437 Lime Lake Rd, Amherst, WI 54406
About this home
Public Remarks: This is the one you have been waiting for! Join me at the Open House Saturday August 5th from 2 to 4 o'clock to see it for yourself. Located on Lime Lake, this half-log home has so much character you'll want to move right in! Set on a picturesque 4.83 acres you could have horses, chickens and more. From the open concept living room, dining room and kitchen to the master suite with walk in tiled shower the pride of ownership really shines through. The ceiling is beautiful knotty pine tongue and groove. There is new luxury vinyl plank flooring, large island with room for 4 stools and newer cabinetry and stainless-steel appliances. First floor laundry is a plus. The view of the lake from the kitchen and dining room is phenomenal! French doors from the dining room to the maintenance free deck give you direct access to the lake. The master suite has a walk-in tile shower with dual shower heads, a walk-in closet and an additional closet. There is a beautiful view of the lake from this room and a door to a small Trex deck. ,The basement contains a family room, bedroom, additional room and it is a walk out level with the yard for access to the lake. There is a 19X23 extra building that could be used as a studio or converted to a guest house. A one car attached garage and a 2-car detached garage will give you plenty of room for your toys. The barn is 40X24 for more storage or animals. New roof was installed on house and detached garage in June of 2023. This home has to be seen to be appreciated so call now for your personal showing, before it's too late.
Single-familyProperty Type
1962Year Built
4.83 acresLot Size
$175Est. Price/Sq.Ft.
3 car garageParking
Listed by Diane Jahn-The Diane Jahn Sales Team• FIRST WEBER
Claim this home to receive a free report every month with insights on the changing estimate.
Earn from this home
Refinance
$0
Est. cash available
Get cash now or lower your monthly rate
Rent
$2,188/mo
Redfin rental estimate
List your home for rent
Market trends in 54406, WI
Last updated September 2026
Buyer's Market
Seller's Market
Balanced market
Sale-to-list price
98.1%
0.5% MoM
Median sale price
$375K
$15K MoM
Avg. days on market
50d
1 days MoM
Recently sold homes
11
2 MoM
Provided by Redfin
Sale history for 5437 Lime Lake Rd
Date
Event
Price
Public Records
Aug 31, 2023
Sold
$360,000
$150/sq ft
HSBOR #21813258
Feb 20, 2020
Sold
$250,000
$104/sq ft
Sep 25, 2019
Listed
$269,900
$112/sq ft
+31
HOUSE, LAKE & OUTBUILDINGS…Rolling picturesque landscape! Enjoy 300ft of Lime Lake Frontage set on 4.83 gorgeous acres…Perfect hobby farm setting with a 40x24 barn, 23x19 storage building/guest house, chicken coop, fenced pastures, garden, fruit trees and easy access to the lake. Fish, kayak & canoe on beautiful Lime Lake. Home boasts a partial log exterior with an open concept interior…Vaulted ceiling, walkout lower level, 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, 3 garage stalls and numerous updates including new furnace & A/C! Kitchen features newer maple cabinetry, high definition counter tops, large center island with counter seating and stainless appliances. Spacious dinette leads to the composite deck that overlooks the rolling landscape and picturesque water views. Large sunken living room has rustic knotty pine finishing, exposed framing beams and a free-standing wood burning fireplace. Master suite boasts a private bath with custom tiled showered, walk-in closet and patio door access to the private deck. Additional main level finishing includes a second bedroom, laundry room, pantry and updated full bathroom. Partially finished lower level includes the third bedroom and hobby room with sink and storage cabinetry makes a perfect hobby/guest room. Family room includes a patio door exit/walkout to the concrete patio and backyard exposing the massive stone retaining walls. Barn features 4 stalls and open walk, 19x23 storage building could be finished as a guest house. Seller represents the following: 500 Gallon LP Tank is leased, 2019=New LP furnace and Central Air, 2017=New composite deck and refrigerator, 2006=whole house renovation. Six lot parcels are being sold together for a combined 4.83 acres. Combined estimated taxes approximately $4000/year. Lime Lake is a no wake lake. Exceptional country setting…Call today for your private showing of this beautiful property!
CWMLS as distributed by WIREX #1204940
Apr 17, 2013
Listed
$255,900
$106/sq ft
Apr 17, 2013
Listing Removed
—
Jan 31, 2013
Sold
$243,000
$101/sq ft
Public Remarks
"Log Home on Lime Lake" Amherst. About 300 feet of water frontage on Lime Lake, great view of the lake from the dining room table, with patio door to large deck overlooking the lake. 4.83 acres of land. Home has 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, 2,400 Square feet of living area. In 2006 the home was completely remodeled interior and exterior to the log home theme. Family room addition w/ log vaulted ceiling and free standing fire place. ,Updates include wood 1/2 log siding, roof, windows, well w/ high capacity pump, 200 amp electric service, master suite w/ walk-in closet, 5 x 5 title shower and private office w/ small deck. All new kitchen w/ new cabinets, island and stainless appliances that are included. All first floor ceilings are beautiful knotty pine tong & grove, except master bedroom. 2 bedrooms in lower level and sauna. One car attached garage. Outbuildings, detached 2 car garage, 4 stall horse barn/garage, w/ fenced areas, a guest cabin with pool table, and 2 garden sheds. Six lot parcels being sold all together to make this a wonderful country retreat. The antique wood burning stove in FR included. Newly remodeled lower level 2 bedrooms w/ patio door. Walk out your door and go fishing any time you want. Life is good. .When do you want to move in ?
Public Records
Feb 1, 2013
Sold
$243,000
$101/sq ft
Public Records
May 14, 2001
Sold
$137,500
$57/sq ft
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$3,323 (+1.5%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2024
$3,273 (+32.8%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2023
$2,464 (−23.1%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2022
$3,204 (+36.6%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2021
$2,346 (−10.0%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2020
$2,608 (−7.7%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2019
$2,827 (+18.8%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2018
$2,379 (−0.7%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2017
$2,396 (−1.1%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2016
$2,423 (+8.7%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2014
$2,229
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
Tax history for 5437 Lime Lake Rd
Year
Property tax
Land + Additions
Assessment*
2025
$3,323 (+1.5%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2024
$3,273 (+32.8%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2023
$2,464 (−23.1%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2022
$3,204 (+36.6%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2021
$2,346 (−10.0%)
$15,100 + $169,300
$184,400
2020
$2,608 (−7.7%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2019
$2,827 (+18.8%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2018
$2,379 (−0.7%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2017
$2,396 (−1.1%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2016
$2,423 (+8.7%)
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
2014
$2,229
$13,800 + $131,100
$144,900
*Taxable value of land and structures on it ("additions") is determined regularly by local assessors and does not affect market price.
Public record
Public record
Zoning
Beds
—
Baths
—
Stories
—
Lot width
—
Lot depth
—
Lot size
1.35 Acres
Year renovated
—
Sq. Ft.
—
Year built
—
Style
Single Family Residential
County
Portage County
APN
010220901-01.04
Parking Spaces
—
Basement
—
Accessible
—
HOA Dues
—
Garage
—
Features
—
Last updated by owner on Oct 23, 2026.
A3
Low Density Agricultural District
This District is intended to provide for a broad range of rural-oriented land uses including agriculture, forestry and open space. It is further intended that this District be used to preserve the rural character of certain outlying areas of Portage County, where only large lot residential development is desirable, particularly where identified in locally adopted comprehensive plans.
Permitted uses
Include but are not limited to:
Agriculture
Dairy
Greenhouse / nursery
Livestock production
Housing-Single unit
Bed & breakfast
Public service
Agriculture-Cropland
Housing-Mobile home park
Park & open space
Property details
Parking
Garage Information
# of Garage Parking Spaces (Total): 3
Garage: 3 Car, Attached, Detached, Opener Included
Interior
Bedroom Information
Master Bedroom Dimensions: 17 x 13
Master Bedroom Level: Main
Bedroom 2 Dimensions: 14 x 9
Bedroom 2 Level: Main
Bedroom 3 Dimensions: 12 x 12
Bedroom 3 Level: Lower
Bathroom Information
Bath Description(s): Master Bedroom Bath
# of Baths (Full): 2
Interior Features
Water Softener (Seller Leased), Vinyl Floors, Tile Floors, Wood Floors, Ceiling Fan(s), Smoke Detector(s), All Window Coverings, Walk-In Closet(s), High Speed Internet
Room Information
Walk Out/Outer Door, Partially Finished, Full, Block