Listed by Julie White • Restaino & Associates (Home: 608-345-0906). Bought with Restaino & Associates.
Sold on Jul 2026
$533,000
2
bd
•
1.5 ba
•
1,347
sq ft
5106 St Cyr Rd, Middleton, WI 53562
Is this your home?
Track this home’s value and nearby sales activity
About this home
Public Remarks: Lake Lovers & Hobbyists Take Note! Rare Find! Charming cottage set in a desirable neighborhood across from Lake Mendota. Flowering trees, tall oaks and perennials grace this mature 1/3 acre lot with garden space. Mendota County Park is steps away with boat/kayak launch, beach & pier. Efficient floor plan features hardwood floors, flagstone fireplace, soaring windows, skylights & chic Herman Miller light fixture. Composite deck to enjoy outdoor living. 22x17 heated 2-story premium woodworking shop with industrial grade vacuum filtration system & water service is a real show stopper?perfect for artists or trades, bring your own vision for the space. 27x24 covered slab offers endless storage or pavilion potential. Home interior is freshly painted with new appliances, many newer mechanicals, electrical/plumbing upgrades, carpentry work and trim, new garage opener and much more! UHP Ultimate Home Warranty. Middleton schools & Town of Westport taxes! This Home Feels Good!
Est. $2,370 per month, based on comparable rentals
Sale and tax history for 5106 St Cyr Rd
Sale History
Tax History
Date
Event
Price
SCWMLS #2024061
Jul 6, 2026
Sold
$533,000
$396/sq ft
May 29, 2026
Contingent
—
May 23, 2026
Listed
$518,800
$385/sq ft
SCWMLS #2008827
Nov 14, 2025
Sold
$461,500
$343/sq ft
Public Remarks
Desirable Lake neighborhood. Enjoy beautiful Lake Mendota just across the street, & Mendota County Park right behind this charming home, lovingly maintained for 45 years. Launch your kayak steps from your backyard. Main-level living, featuring oak hardwood floors throughout, a spacious living room with a cozy fireplace, & designated dining room with access to a large maintenance-free deck. A heated 22x17 workshop connects to the 2 car garage and is a dream for hobbyists or woodworkers. Outfitted with water service, an industrial-grade vacuum filtration system, & a loft above is a versatile space ready for your vision. Outdoors, the 27? x 24? covered concrete slab currently used for storage would make the perfect pickleball court. All this in a top-rated school district.