Shelter Island, NY homes for sale & real estate

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

Set on over two secluded acres within the coveted Shellfisher Preserve association near Paradise Point, this extraordinary estate offers sweeping water views from the backyard, kitchen, and upstairs rooms. A private deeded beach and your own deep-water dock is just a short pathway away, while the property is graced by a pristine tidal lagoon, preserved and maintained by the Peconic Land Trust. The traditional-style residence, custom built from the ground up by its sole owner, is features four bedrooms—three upstairs and a potential guest suite or office on the main level. Expansive sundecks capture the water vistas, while the spacious primary suite provides a serene retreat. A remarka

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

Coming Soon to West Dublin – This renovated 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Dutch Colonial offers a thoughtfully redesigned floor plan highlighted by open concept living and spacious primary suite. Notable upgrades include solid white oak floors, Marvin windows, and new energy-efficient systems. The exterior features a private deck and a detached garage awaiting your vision. With water only a block away in nearly every direction, this location is truly A++. Ready for your finishing touches and move-in by October 2025. Additional photos coming soon!

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

Modern Design Meets Coastal Living Welcome to your brand-new custom build in East Marion-crafted with an eye for detail and built for everyday luxury. This 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home, complete with a spacious primary en-suite, balances timeless design with modern conveniences in a coveted beach community. Step inside to soaring ceilings, red oak select flooring, and Allwood custom cabinetry anchored by sleek quartz countertops. The kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring a Galiano Moena 36" gas range, double electric wall ovens, and a 24" wine cooler-because hey, why not! Light-filled spaces flow seamlessly to the outdoors, where a custom 18x36 Gunite saltwater pool (heated, of course)

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

Charming one bedroom and one bathroom co-op situated few minutes away from the Village of Greenport. Enjoy the beaches, restaurants and vineyards of the North Fork. Well maintained house comes with hardwood floor and an open layout.

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

Renovated 1910 Colonial with Beautiful Open Floor Plan. Down the Road From Town Beach. Just a Short Bike Ride to Down Town Greenport and Wineries !! Possibility of Selling Fully Furnished !! Large Back Building Could Be Turned into a Pool House, Garage or Shed, Additional information: Appearance Diamond, Interior Features: Living Rm, Dining Area, Spacious Eat in Kitchen with Large Island, Breakfast Nook, 3 Bedrooms(Small one on First Floor, 2 On 2nd Floor), 1.5 Renovated Bathrooms. Separate Hotwater Heater, 2 Separate Driveways

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale

This charming two-story home is perfectly situated just a quarter mile from the beach, offering an ideal blend of comfort and convenience. The open-concept first floor features a welcoming living area with a fireplace, an eat-in kitchen equipped with quartz countertops, a gas stove, and stainless steel appliances, as well as a formal dining room with sliding glass doors that open to a private backyard with ample space for a pool. The Town of Southold previously issued a building permit for a pool that has since expired. A half bathroom completes the main level. Upstairs, you’ll find three generously sized bedrooms and two full bathrooms, providing plenty of space for family and guests