Willing to be flexible? Here are some rentals that closely match your search.
$75,000/mo
6 beds4.5 baths4,600 sq ft
15 Montclair Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964Parking • A/C • Car-dependent
$50,000/mo
3 beds3 baths3,000 sq ft
28 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965Parking • A/C • Car-dependent
$14,400/mo
4 beds2 baths2,669 sq ft
12 Dogwood Ln, Shelter Island, NY 11964Available 01/01 • Parking • A/C
$63,000/mo
3 beds2 baths1,487 sq ft
4 Ivy Pl, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965Parking • A/C • Dishwasher
$30,000/mo
4 beds4 baths3,100 sq ft
15 N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964Dogs welcome • Parking • A/C
61 Peconic Ave, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963
7 North Dr, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of Sun Dec 21 2025. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.
More to explore in Shelter Island, NY
- Property Types
- Bedrooms
- Amenities
- Price
Rentals near Shelter Island, NY
Cities
- Neighborhoods
- Zip Codes
Apartments for rent near Shelter Island, NY
Cities
- Neighborhoods
- Zip Codes
Popular rental markets in New York
- Rentals
- Apartments





















United States
Canada