Gaines, NY homes for sale & real estate

Gaines, NY Homes for Sale

House being sold "As-Is" Bring your vision and transform this completely gutted home into something special. The interior has been cleared, offering a rare chance to design every detail to your taste. Significant renovations are needed, making this an ideal project for experienced renovators or investors.

Gaines, NY Homes for Sale

This spacious 4-bedroom, 1-bath Colonial offers over 1,700 sq ft of living space and endless potential. Nestled on just under an acre, the home welcomes you with a charming wraparound front porch and an easily accessible wrap. Step inside to find original hardwood floors, rich character, and multiple main-floor living areas—including a formal dining room, cozy living room, and bright front entryway. The updated kitchen features newer cabinets, modern countertops, a tile backsplash, and some stainless steel appliances. Upstairs, hardwoods continue throughout all four generous sized bedrooms. Enjoy a fully fenced backyard perfect for pets or play, plus a convenient dog wash station in t

Gaines, NY Homes for Sale

Lake Alice and Oak Orchard River. Make new memories at this rarely available waterfront bungalow on Knights Lane - quietly tucked away and secluded among only 4 cottages and is a double lot 2258 and 2256 Knights Lane ~120ft of waterfront frontage with dock. In addition to the cottage, there are two sheds, a fire pit, a gazebo structure (needing fabric), and a picnic table. The cottage has newer vinyl windows, A/C air conditioning, a newer tiled shower, a metal roof, and laminate flooring throughout. There are two parcels: 2258 Knights Lane tax numbers 342400-038-009-0001-005-000 at . 09 acres and 2256 Knights Lane 342400-038-009-0001-006-000 at . 10 acres - for a total of . 19 acres. The pr

Gaines, NY Homes for Sale

CHARMING 1907-BUILT SCHOOL HOUSE W/ 6,900SF!! NINE BEDROOMS, SIX BATHS, 3 STAIRCASES, LOVELY OUTDOOR SPACE AND MORE FOR UNLIMITED POSSIBILITES!!! FIRST FLOOR HAS WARM & INVITING BEAD BOARD MAIN KITCHEN, LIVING ROOM, 7 BEDROOMS AND 5 BATHS!! * GIGANTIC SECOND STORY "BALLROOM/THEATER" WITH ORIGINAL STAGE, A WORKING CATERING KITCHEN, A TWO BEDROOM, ONE BATH PRIVATE ENTRANCE SUITE!! OUTSIDE HAS SPRAWLING LAWN! ALMOST AN ACRE WITH WATER FEATURE/POND & PATIO! THIS PROPERTY STILL HAS MANY ORIGINAL SCHOOL HOUSE FEATURES - CHALKBOARD WALLS, HAND HEWN STAIRCASES, DOORS, TRANSOMS, AND MORE! TAKE A TRIP DOWN ANTIQUE MEMORY LANE AND DISCOVER ORIGINAL STUDENT DESKS AND OT

Gaines, NY Homes for Sale

Don't miss this awesome opportunity to own a piece of history and, a prime lakefront location on beautiful Lake Alice! This property offers a large, 3 story home that has been used in the past as a general store, 3 lakeside cottages that are nearly always rented to fisherman from around the country and also has 2 RV parking spaces. The cottages are rented on a per/night, per fisherman basis and are a huge source of income. The main home features 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a huge showroom / family room, 1st floor laundry and a great country kitchen with access to a deck overlooking the lake.

Gaines, NY Homes for Sale

Discover a rare opportunity to own a beautiful parcel of land on Harris Road in scenic Waterport. Just minutes from Lake Alice. This spacious and versatile property offers the perfect setting to build your dream home, create a private retreat, or make a smart long-term investment. Surrounded by a peaceful natural landscape with open space and mature trees, the land provides a quiet country atmosphere while still offering easy road access for convenient travel throughout Orleans County. Ideal for outdoor enthusiasts, hobby farming, or those simply seeking room to breathe, the property combines privacy, flexibility, and lifestyle potential. Located just minutes from local amenities, parks, la