Otisco, NY homes for sale & real estate

Otisco, NY Homes for Sale

This completely remodeled, move-in-ready home in the Tully School District is ready for its new owner! Featuring 3 bedrooms and 2½ baths, this gorgeous home offers modern updates, beautiful finishes, and an incredible setting with waterfront views. The remodeled kitchen boasts granite countertops, while the first floor offers the convenience of laundry and a spacious layout perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Major updates include a new roof, new furnace, and new hot water heater, providing peace of mind for years to come. The property also features a fantastic barn that can easily accommodate two cars, making it ideal for garage space, storage, hobbies, or recreational equ

Otisco, NY Homes for Sale

Showings begin on Friday 8/14/2026 at noon. Welcome to your very own private retreat near the south end of Otisco Lake, set on approximately 8 acres of picturesque landscape featuring two natural waterfalls, a tranquil stream, and a footbridge leading to open green space with vibrant gardens. This meticulously maintained three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath log home blends rustic charm with key recent upgrades, including exterior log staining completed two years ago and a roof that is only three years old. Enjoy peaceful year-round views from the extensive screened-in wrap-around porch, or take advantage of the prime location situated just minutes from the Otisco Lake boat launch, nearby ski

Otisco, NY Homes for Sale

Surrounded by picturesque apple orchards and offering breathtaking views for miles, this well maintained colonial is the perfect blend of peaceful country living and everyday convenience. Nestled on 2.68 acres, the property delivers a private backyard, and a location just minutes from both I-81 North and South. Inside, you'll find four spacious bedrooms, two full baths, a private home office, a playroom/flexible main-floor room that could easily serve as a fifth bedroom or guest room. The generously sized primary suite features its own full bath, while the mostly finished lower level provides abundant additional living and recreation space. Main floor laundry center/mud room. The eat-in kit

Otisco, NY Homes for Sale

Privately situated on 5.7 acres within the 250-acre Bacon Hill Association, this 3,000+ square foot Adirondack-inspired home offers a rare opportunity to enjoy the natural beauty and outdoor lifestyle of Skaneateles Lake. Surrounded by mature woods and abundant wildlife, residents enjoy 280 feet of shared, level lakefront featuring a beach area, boat launch, dock, swim float, pavilion, picnic tables, and grill. The fabulous home features soaring ceilings, expansive windows, a stunning stone fireplaces, new hardwood flooring & fresh carpeting. The spacious floor plan includes a dramatic Great Room with 25-foot ceilings, an eat-in kitchen with stainless appliances, a morning room adjace

Otisco, NY Homes for Sale

Bring your imagination and reinvent this piece of Skaneateles history formerly known as the 1820 House. This home sits on just under five acres, has 5,300 feet of interior living space and offers lake views from all levels of the home. This property is in need of a complete renovation to be brought back to its formerly glory. Since 1946 this venue has been serving the area as a restaurant , pub and a bed and breakfast. Currently zoned mixed use which brings you endless options for the best return on your investment.

Otisco, NY Homes for Sale

Positioned between Skaneateles Lake and Otisco Lake and surrounded by nearly 20 private acres, this one-of-a-kind farmhouse property offers the rare opportunity to create a true multigenerational country retreat in the highly sought-after Marcellus School District. Adjacent to Spafford Forest and located within the Skaneateles Lake Watershed Agricultural Program area, the setting offers exceptional privacy, natural beauty, and added peace of mind through thoughtful surrounding land stewardship. Originally built in 1894 and thoughtfully updated over time, the home maintains its classic farmhouse character while offering the space and flexibility today’s buyers are searching for. With 6