Waterfront homes for sale & real estate in Cromwell, IN

Waterfront Home for sale in Cromwell, IN:

Updated in 2025 this 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is located Marine Land Gardens and includes a pier thru the association to enjoy Lake Wawasee, also association swimming area and pier. Nice size master bedroom with walk in closet. Updated kitchen with breakfast bar and all new appliances, bathroom updates, new flooring thru out, fresh paint, new water softener, and more. Spacious yard for outdoor living and deck to enjoy. Shed for extra storage. Ready to move in and enjoy!

Waterfront Home for sale in Cromwell, IN:

Papakeechie Lakefront home with two finished bedrooms and one unfinished bedroom upstairs. One bath, laundry room, 1240 sq. ft. home sitting on 50' of Papakeechie Lake. Wonderful views of peaceful Papakeechie Lake excellent for fishing, ice fishing, ice skating, kayaking, swimming and floating. A flagstone patio with firepit on the lake side is a great place to have bonfires and sit with friends and family. Great looking landscaping with eye appealing retaining walls. There is a finished shed with electric and AC that you can use as a "She Shed", "Mancave" or use it for quests or hobbies. Plus, there are 2 additional sheds that you can store your summer toys or yard tool

Waterfront Home for sale in Cromwell, IN:

Beautiful Lakefront home on Papakeechie Lake awaits. Your dream home with a rare opportunity to own on the pristine shores of Papakeechie, in a paradise setting. This spacious home was recently updated and boasts 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 2 half baths. Enjoy the brand-new kitchen with ample counter space, breakfast bar, eat in kitchen and plenty of storage. Oversized living room on main level, family room or game room in lower level of walk about basement. Step out on the beautiful new 948 sq ft deck and enjoy the peace and tranquility of all this lake and home has to offer. Brand new 2 car detached garage for additional storage and convenience. Papakeechie lake is beautiful retreat for

Waterfront Home for sale in Cromwell, IN:

3 -BEDROOM , 2 - BATH RANCH ON HARPER LAKE , PIER INCLUDED WITH ACCESS TO KROPP LAKE , APPLIANCES ARE NEWER , DECK OVERLOOKING THE LAKE , FURNITURE IS INCLUDED & PONTOON IS FOR SALE FOR $ 10,000. NO WAKE LAKE THAT GOES INTO KNAPP LAKE , 12 X 37 DECK OVER LOOKING THE LAKE

Waterfront Home for sale in Cromwell, IN:

Lakefront Living on Webster Lake! Welcome to your move-in ready lake retreat! This 2019 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers breathtaking views of beautiful Webster Lake. Enjoy easy lake living with everything included -- a pontoon boat, and your own boat slip just steps away. The home comes fully furnished, so you can start enjoying lake life the moment you arrive. Relax on the deck and take in the stunning sunsets, unwind by the cozy fire pit, or hop on the boat for a day on the water. With modern features and open-concept living, this property is perfect for weekend getaways or year-round enjoyment. Don't miss this rare opportunity for a turnkey lakefront home with all the extras -- all that

Waterfront Home for sale in Cromwell, IN:

Winter Buyer Bonus: Seller is offering a $10,000 credit toward new bedroom design or updates—make it yours before spring! Personalize the cottage during the cozy winter months so your lake retreat is exactly how you want it by the time the ice thaws. Experience the beauty of Webster Lake in every season from this charming and versatile waterfront retreat. Whether you’re sipping coffee while watching snowflakes across the water or enjoying long summer evenings on the deck, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, character, and year-round lake living. Situated on the shores of Webster Lake — one of Indiana’s most desirable all-sports lakes — this property