Interlaken, NY homes for sale & real estate

Interlaken, NY Homes for Sale

Step into history with this beautifully maintained 1850s home that perfectly blends timeless character and modern comfort. The newly renovated kitchen features contemporary finishes and appliances while retaining the home's warm, inviting feel. The first-floor primary bedroom offers convenience and privacy, complete with an en suite bath. Enjoy cozy evenings by the wood-burning stove, or relax on the front covered porch overlooking lush gardens bursting with flowers and fruit trees. This one-of-a-kind property offers historic charm, modern amenities, and a serene setting ready to welcome you home.

Interlaken, NY Homes for Sale

Welcome to 5761 Burr Road, Trumansburg—a charming 4-bedroom, 3-bath farmhouse nestled on approximately five acres, with the option to purchase additional adjoining land. Perfectly situated between Cayuga and Seneca Lakes, this property combines peaceful country living with easy access to all that the Finger Lakes region has to offer. Step inside and you’re greeted by a massive country kitchen featuring updated appliances, ample cabinetry, and plenty of space for entertaining. The first floor offers a full bath, cozy living room, formal dining room, mudroom, sunroom, and Florida room—each filled with natural light and farmhouse charm. Upstairs, the primary suite includes it

Interlaken, NY Homes for Sale

Discover an easy-to-own, easy-to-maintain multi-family gem in the heart of the Finger Lakes region. This centrally located property features three unique rental units, all-electric utilities (no gas or furnace maintenance required), and long-term tenants who love the convenience and charm of this lovely small town. Situated on a spacious quarter-acre lot, it offers off-street parking, a nice yard, and a walkable location close to the local diner, shops, restaurants, bank, library, healthcare, and more. Recent updates include a major kitchen remodel and a roof replacement in 2024, ensuring minimal upkeep. An excellent income producer with steady demand? This property is perfect for investors

Interlaken, NY Homes for Sale

Welcome to the Preacher’s Retreat- a stunning Victorian built in 1873 as the manse for the Lodi Presbyterian Church, now lovingly restored and decked out in a hip, eclectic style. This one-of-a-kind home perfectly blends historic charm with modern conveniences and sits in the heart of the Finger Lakes, centrally located between Seneca and Cayuga wine trails and just minutes from Watkins Glen, Ithaca, and some of the region’s most beautiful state parks for swimming, hiking, and boating. Step inside and be wowed by soaring ceilings, period details, and thoughtful updates throughout. Recent renovations (2021) include: all-new electrical and plumbing, high-efficiency dual-fuel force

Interlaken, NY Homes for Sale

This gracious village home has a lot to offer! Approaching the front door, you'll see a beautiful new walkway that was poured this summer, with a handsome iron railing. Enter to see a home with beautiful hardwood floors throughout, a center staircase with dining to the left, living room to the right. The living room is the full length of the home, with a convenient gas fireplace to warm you on winter nights. The dining room looks out toward the street with nice big windows to let the sun in! The kitchen is compact but full service. There is a wonderful 3 season sun room on the rear of the house - this space is not heated but has places to connect a wood stove and chimney. The main floor als

Interlaken, NY Homes for Sale

Dirt/stone basement. This is your chance to build equity and bring your vision to life! Restore this Civil War era home to it's former beauty! Offered at a fraction of the area average, this home is an affordable entry into the rehab market. Needs total upgrade, the home can not be occupied in it's current state.