The Shelter Island housing market is somewhat competitive. The median sale price of a home in Shelter Island was $1.6M last month, up 25.5% since last year.
What is the housing market like in Shelter Island today?
In January 2025, Shelter Island home prices were up 25.5% compared to last year, selling for a median price of $1.6M.
$1.6M
Sale Price
$965
Sale $/Sq. Ft.
Under List Price
2.1%
Days on Market
58
Down Payment
—
Total Homes Sold
1
To compare other locations to the Shelter Island and U.S. housing market, enter a city, neighborhood, state, or zip code into the search bar. Learn which home features in San Diego add value to a home.
How much is your home worth? Track your home’s value and compare it to nearby sales.
Work with the best agents in Shelter Island
Redfin agents are among the most experienced in the industry, so we know how to help you win in today's market.
How hot is the Shelter Island housing market?
Shelter Island is somewhat competitive. Homes sell in 58 days.
0
100
54
Somewhat Competitive
Redfin Compete Score™
The Redfin Compete Score rates how competitive an area is on a scale of 0 to 100, where 100 is the most competitive.
Calculated over the last 12 months
Some homes get multiple offers.
The average homes sell for about 2% below list price and go pending in around 58 days.
Hot homes
can sell for around list price and go pending in around 9 days.
School data provided by GreatSchools. School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.
Climate's impact on Shelter Island housing
Learn about natural hazards and environmental risks, such as floods, fires, wind, and heat that
could impact homes in Shelter Island.
Flood Factor - Minor
33% of properties are at risk of severe flooding over the next 30 years
Flood Factor
Shelter Island has a minor risk of flooding. 3 properties in Shelter Island are likely to be
severely affected
by flooding over the next 30 years. This represents 33% of all properties in Shelter Island. Flood risk is increasing slower than the national average.
Shelter Island has minimal risk of severe winds over the next 30 years
Wind Factor
Shelter Island has a Minimal Wind Factor®, which means there is a very low likelihood that hurricane, tornado or severe storm winds will impact this area.